- Jun 22, 2020
I'm not trying to be vague or disingenuous. The questions you pose are not yes and no questions.Honestly, like many of your posts on these topics it comes across as deliberately vague and disingenuous. You haven’t directly answered the question, which should be quite simple.
I’ll rephrase it - in a hypothetical ideal Islamic state with “100% Islam” as you put it, according to you is consensual sex between two adults of the same gender legal or illegal? And if illegal, what if anything is the appropriate punishment?
But here you go
Sodomy is a sin/illegal. Same sex is a sin/illegal.
There is no punishment, by the people/ruler etc if it's not open and public. This is the same for all sex and genders.
If there is to be a punishment then this can vary too. See hadud laws.
That's not me being evasive. Conditions have to be met for certain punishments. However the ultimate penalty would be death