I don't think Obertan earned his shot, he got it by default because Nani was suspended, Giggs was injured and the likes of Welbeck and Tosic have been sent on loan. If we had an experienced winger who could have played, I don't think Obertan would have made the bench. SAF had no choice but to play him. And when we went down 2-1, SAF had no choice but to try and freshen things up by bringing him on. It was a gamble in less then ideal circumstances and one that didn't pay off.Disagree with that. Young players can learn even more from a bad performance than a good one. Obertan earned his shot at first-team football - just like Macheda did against Villa around this time last season - by putting in a fantastic performance for our reserves. The vast majority of 'tards on here slagging him off didn't see him put in a MOTM peformances two days ago, in the same side as a regular first-teamer, Anderson. Obertan ripped Everton's reserves to pieces last Thursday night. Fergie was there, hence he decided to give him a chance.
Turns out he didn't make anything like the impact Macheda did, not least because Moyes counteracted Fergie's subs perfectly and Everton kicked our arse for the final quarter of the game. None of which was Obertan's fault. The fact remains, he earned his chance and learning about the difference between excelling for our reserves and playing against top PL opposition is a crucial part of any young player's development.
He did earn it though. He earned it by being the best player on the pitch in the reserve game on Thursday. It's really that simple.I don't think Obertan earned his shot, he got it by default because Nani was suspended, Giggs was injured and the likes of Welbeck and Tosic have been sent on loan. If we had an experienced winger who could have played, I don't think Obertan would have made the bench. SAF had no choice but to play him. And when we went down 2-1, SAF had no choice but to try and freshen things up by bringing him on. It was a gamble in less then ideal circumstances and one that didn't pay off..
Not saying he won't make it or anything but I can't see that talent many here are seeing(talking about how some people compare him to Ronaldo).
He can't control the ball and no where similar/near to when Ronaldo came here first.
And he had looked equally as impressive on the previous two outings for the Reserves, getting two assists. He did deserve a place on the bench at least and I don't see why people argue that he didn't, especially when two of our first choice wingers in Giggs and Nani were absent.He did earn it though. He earned it by being the best player on the pitch in the reserve game on Thursday. It's really that simple.
Obviously, he may not have come off the bench if we weren't trailing (just like Macheda wouldn't have got his game against Villa last season) but that doesn't change the fact Obertan was on the bench on merit.
He was on the bench because Nani was suspended, and Giggs is injured. If either of these two players were fit, Obertan wouldn't have made the bench. He could have scored a hat trick and he would still be playing in the reserves. Of course, that's just my opinion and at this stage its pure conjecture, but i find it hard to believe SAF would have picked him ahead of our more experienced wing options.He did earn it though. He earned it by being the best player on the pitch in the reserve game on Thursday. It's really that simple.
Obviously, he may not have come off the bench if we weren't trailing (just like Macheda wouldn't have got his game against Villa last season) but that doesn't change the fact Obertan was on the bench on merit.
Not many can emulate Ronaldo so that's a bit of an unfair comparison. I haven't seen enough of Obertan to really judge what he's capable of. He's only been here for five minutes and he's still settling in to a new country, culture, and club. Give his a chance.Not saying he won't make it or anything but I can't see that talent many here are seeing(talking about how some people compare him to Ronaldo).
He can't control the ball and no where similar/near to when Ronaldo came here first.
Same's true of players like Neville etc., they were never the most technically gifted players of their age group but they left so many "better" players behind them because they worked harder and they wanted it more. Sadly that drive isn't something that can easily be instilled in someone.More important then his technique is his mentality. Ronaldo like Rooney at 18-19 year old was a fearless player. He would do 10 stepovers because he believed he could beat a man everytime. He would shoot on sight because in his mind he could score all the time. With Obertan I don't see that (not in first team games anyway). I see a nervousness. It's obvious he does have good dribbling skills, but yesterday like he did on debut there were times he just kind of fell over the ball. That's a sign of nerves. A sign that perhaps he doesn't believe he is good enough to be out there. That's more to do with his mental strength then technique.
I don't care about his technique at this stage. What I want to see is a bravery in his play, which I so far have not seen. Even when he made a run into the box, he seemed to do it without any kind of plan. It was like the legs were traveling and the mind had been paralyzed with fear. So when he crossed it was too late / blocked / defended.
There are a lot of young players who don't yet have the technique but they are fearless on the pitch, and you can tell they feel they belong out there. That to me is a sure sign of a player who will make it because technical ability will improve, but that mental strength is hard to develop once you're 18-20 years old.
Fletcher is a good example of that. He has never been technically gifted. But his mental strength was immense (it had to be to play alongside the likes of Keano / Scholes ). That's why he's become the player he is today. Not because his dribbling or passing has suddenly become world class.
And people already start to write him off?
I agree with what you're saying but I think thats natural for a 20 year old to feel nervous in big games...not all players at that age have the courage and bravery of Rooney and Ronaldo. I'm glad he's got the talent...the courage will come in a couple of years?More important then his technique is his mentality. Ronaldo like Rooney at 18-19 year old was a fearless player. He would do 10 stepovers because he believed he could beat a man everytime. He would shoot on sight because in his mind he could score all the time. With Obertan I don't see that (not in first team games anyway). I see a nervousness. It's obvious he does have good dribbling skills, but yesterday like he did on debut there were times he just kind of fell over the ball. That's a sign of nerves. A sign that perhaps he doesn't believe he is good enough to be out there. That's more to do with his mental strength then technique.
I don't care about his technique at this stage. What I want to see is a bravery in his play, which I so far have not seen. Even when he made a run into the box, he seemed to do it without any kind of plan. It was like the legs were traveling and the mind had been paralyzed with fear. So when he crossed it was too late / blocked / defended.
There are a lot of young players who don't yet have the technique but they are fearless on the pitch, and you can tell they feel they belong out there. That to me is a sure sign of a player who will make it because technical ability will improve, but that mental strength is hard to develop once you're 18-20 years old.
Fletcher is a good example of that. He has never been technically gifted. But his mental strength was immense (it had to be to play alongside the likes of Keano / Scholes ). That's why he's become the player he is today. Not because his dribbling or passing has suddenly become world class.
Struck a cord have we?You have some nerve to call others spastics and then start off with a comment like that. Sonny, go the feck to bed already...
Sadly this is the problem with most united fans. They compare a lad with potential like Obertan to an exceptional talent like Rooney, or Ronaldo. They look at Diouf, call him the one (ok, clearly a joke) and start to believe in the hype without realizing that most of the young players we have bought in the last year aren't exceptional talent. They are potentials. With a lot of hard graft and self belief they might make the grade but the odds are they probably won't. To ride the high horse and make believe that these boys are world beaters after a few reserve games just shows how much you buy into the message board hype.
Have you read the recent Evans one?This thread is embarrassing.
Extremely. Some posters have made themselves look like right idiots. Reputations are inflated and destroyed on here quicker than The Sun at times.This thread is embarrassing.
Why not ? Fergie had full confidence in the lad, and if you've been closely watching the reserves you'll know that Obertan has been doing really well and certainly deserved a chance as Park was fading and his game in Milan where he ran 12km didn't help him look fresh.Agreed he should be given time. But Saturdays game? Never. We were abysmal in the second half, and to remove Park, and try Obertan was imo stupid.
Show me one match where Obertan has come to standard.Why not ? Fergie had full confidence in the lad, and if you've been closely watching the reserves you'll know that Obertan has been doing really well and certainly deserved a chance as Park was fading and his game in Milan where he ran 12km didn't help him look fresh.
It certainly wasn't stupid, but Everton just played better than us that day in which we must accept it.
Obertan is still one for the future, even Ronaldo at 21 wasn't doing the goods week in and week out there but you can certainly see the potential.
It's the desperate wish of many on here that we may have found the new ronaldo in one of our young talents or that we might find him soon.People should stop comparing young players to Ronaldo
Against Wolfsburg perhaps?Show me one match where Obertan has come to standard.
Berbatov aside he wasn't worse than the rest of them.Do people actually think he was poor against Everton?
I thought he done OK.
I dont understand why there is a sudden rush of negative comments, especially after a fantastic performance for the reserves.Berbatov aside he wasn't worse than the rest of them.
He had a couple of decent contributions but he also made one or two fairly rookie errors. Probably slightly worse than "OK" but not terrible either.Do people actually think he was poor against Everton?
I thought he done OK.
He certainly will. He's been a joy to watch for the reserves, he just needs a bit more experience of playing in the first team because some of his play (albeit against reserve standards) has been first class.I've said it before and I'll say it again: Obertan will come good, you have my word.
I don't know what everyone throwing out these negative comments hopes to achieve.
Nail. Head. Bang!It's the desperate wish of many on here that we may have found the new ronaldo in one of our young talents or that we might find him soon.
Yeah, I'm a bit mystified by these attacks. I just watched the game, as I was away on Sat. He was no better or worse than anyone else on the pitch.Do people actually think he was poor against Everton?
I thought he done OK.