Wait what? Of course there is an advantage, you can come from behind the CB who never sees you coming to collect the ball from deep.These are definitely the most infuriating offsides. I too think that if you've had to move way from goal to collect the ball then there's no advantage. Though if that was added as a rule, it probably makes a convoluted rule even more convoluted. It's a rule that seems to get more bloated every season.