aeh1991
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 13, 2022
- Messages
- 3,718
Who knows, the best he can do is prove everyone wrong.
Same. Carrick seems willing to trust the youth to a certain extent so maybe if the opponent is weak enough he'll get a chance?Why is that? Have we blocked someone from buying him? Doesn't sound like the price set was high.
I would be really, really surprised if he got any significant minutes this season. The problem is we have a lot of players that CAN play LB, and most likely all will be ahead of Amass in the pecking order. I doubt he gains anything by staying here. Especially that the club apparently wanted him sold, probably he isn't rated that high.
I don't get it though. He was quite alright in pre-season, especially against Leeds. I get that we shouldn't use him against the fastest wingers, but otherwise he should be good enough to rotate with Shaw, no?Seems pretty clear that he isnt rated by the manager, and so I suspect even with a lack of options he still wont see any senior minutes.
Shaw, Mazraoui, Dalot and probably even Martinez likely ahead of him for minutes at LB and who knows maybe even Dorgu too. Yoro emerging as a legitimate option at RB means we can spare Dalot or Maz over at LB too.
I don't get it though. He was quite alright in pre-season, especially against Leeds. I get that we shouldn't use him against the fastest wingers, but otherwise he should be good enough to rotate with Shaw, no?
I don't get it though. He was quite alright in pre-season, especially against Leeds. I get that we shouldn't use him against the fastest wingers, but otherwise he should be good enough to rotate with Shaw, no?
Attacking I think he'll be fine, it's his defense that will be the question. For someone his age he's good defensively, but if you take age out of it he's probably average to below average defensively compared to the rest of the PL. Combination of inexperience, overall speed and burst, and lack of strength is what makes him poor defensively. I think if he was in the Championship it'd be a different story or even if he was somewhere like Spain or Germany he'd be fine but in bigger faster leagues he'll get caught out. But what he does have is a bit of a mean streak and he's not afraid to get into tackles, and he's got enough confidence to not get rattled.Can't say I've seen much of Amass. Does he have the strengths to step up for those who have?
Was he? Just quick glance at post match comments and he isn't getting good reviews. General consensus was "he was an easy target" and "lacks physicality".I don't get it though. He was quite alright in pre-season, especially against Leeds. I get that we shouldn't use him against the fastest wingers, but otherwise he should be good enough to rotate with Shaw, no?
I thought he was good until they used an exceptionally fast winger (I think it was Gnonto?) and didn't have the LW (was it Rashford?) helping him defensively, leaving him exposed. In the first half he was very impressive, playing good passes, tackled well, etc. Seemed to be capable of playing against a EPL team, unlike Tyler Fletcher for example. So for cup games and against a team like Sabah I think he should be tested.Was he? Just quick glance at post match comments and he isn't getting good reviews. General consensus was "he was an easy target" and "lacks physicality".
Personally I don't see him against Premier League and Champions League opponnents, and we're not going to play many games against lower tier opposition. Don't see him getting game time this season. Should have been sold for the sake of kids career.
I think he could be an option against lower tier opponents in the CL. Premier League I think is not for him in terms of pace and physicality, where he is clearly lacking and crucial for fullback. He is good on the ball that's for sure.I thought he was good until they used an exceptionally fast winger (I think it was Gnonto?) and didn't have the LW (was it Rashford?) helping him defensively, leaving him exposed. In the first half he was very impressive, playing good passes, tackled well, etc. Seemed to be capable of playing against a EPL team, unlike Tyler Fletcher for example. So for cup games and against a team like Sabah I think he should be tested.
Really depends on the oppontent, but CL and cup games could slowly prepare him for the physicality (also meeds bulk up). I think his technique could eventually compensate his physical flaws. It's not like every good EPL fullback has good physique.I think he could be an option against lower tier opponents in the CL. Premier League I think is not for him in terms of pace and physicality, where he is clearly lacking and crucial for fullback. He is good on the ball that's for sure.
Like Lacey, he hardly had much time and everyone around him was already planning their dinner/viewing schedule tonight.Not a fantastic outing, Dorgu was better at LB today. That said, he was still one of the few players who at least moved in the final minutes
So much negativity tonight, don't get it. Thought it was an ok cameo for a young kid who doesn't have many first team minutes under his belt?
Really did nothing wrong tonight. Was good in what he was doing against a weak side. Whether he is ready to play in EPL is a different story but nothing to criticize tonight.Never really did anything wrong from what I could see in my seat in the stadium, unless he made a really bad error beyond the 86 minute I fail to see what he's done wrong.
Very similar to Santos, getting stick for absolutely nothing.
KDilkington’s matchday player rating scaleHe's solid enough but he's not got any 'WOW' factor about him that makes you think he can be a regular. Move him on. There's no value in a loan for him, just take the woeful sum we'll inevitably get.
I mean he will need time to adjust, even if he was good.He's solid enough but he's not got any 'WOW' factor about him that makes you think he can be a regular. Move him on. There's no value in a loan for him, just take the woeful sum we'll inevitably get.
Gotta have that WOW! factor.KDilkington’s matchday player rating scale
10 - World class performance
9 - Very good match, belongs on the bench
8 - solid enough, may go on a loan
7 - solid enough, but move him on
6 - just move him on
5 - move him on, already
4 - feckin git!
3 - go
2 - death penalty
1 - death’s to good for him