He isn’t brilliant. He is an average defender with great heading ability, but is at the same time prone to making silly decisions. Dias has «matched» him? Dias plays in a team that hardly lets in goals and will easily win the league because of it, Maguire plays for a team where everyone kind of expects silly mistakes to be made every game. The revisionism on here is spectacular after a win, we are one Rodri-miss to goal away from not having posts like these, Man City failed to score today because of themselves, not because United were especially good at the back.
City failed to score because they failed to create a match winning chance.
Sterling missed one golden opportunity, other than that Henderson barely had a save of note to make.
United are actually capable of really good defensive displays, take today and Chelsea as examples.
The issue is often Maguire and Lindelof are left exposed by the attacking nature of our midfield and full backs, causing the pressure and hence mistakes happen.
Maguire is a very good defender, as is Lindelof, just they need a bit of protection every now and then in order to show it. Cities defence barely let goals in because they dominate the ball most games and have Fernandinho or Rodri sitting back and holding the middle.
Neither Fred not McT are that type of player, no matter what people try to say.