- Oct 31, 2021
The fact that we still defensively struggled without him last year in no way supports that Maguire is good enough as a Man Utd starter.VVD would struggle on a team with no DM and a keeper who keeps his mouth shut and stands on his line. If you think our defense was bad last year when Maguire played, then you obviously didn't watch the games when he didn't play. In January Maguire only played one game. Vs West Ham. De Gea only had to make one save for the entire match. For the rest of the games in January De Gea had to make more saves than any other keeper in the league and ended up getting the EPL player of the month award. And we didn't play City, LIverpool and Chelsea. We played Villa, Brentford and Wolves. But go on....tell us more about how Maguire is the problem...
We struggled defensive without Lee Grant as well, it doesn't mean Lee Grant is good enough as a Man Utd starter.
it is a simple logic.
On the other hands we have tones of records and stats that show that he is never a CB good enough to play for any top clubs with aspiration for title challenge.