ReallyUSA
Full Member
- Joined
- Jun 6, 2015
- Messages
- 2,990
Haven't United always have players who come in, and provide in small batches. He might not be the all world beater right now, but every so often he shows up and shows out.
Welcome back mate.Perfect squad player. And that is what you need to win trophies -- a squad of players.
Cheers! Always been around but the United forum is hard to read nowadays.Welcome back mate.
Yes I've seen it, it gets posted on this site multiple times in any :ingard thread as if it cancels out any criticism of him. I don't need a video to tell me what he brings to this team, I can see with my own eyes it isn't much.Has anyone watched that first video to understand his role?
You're madWhat Lingard did tonight is exactly what I expect from a Manchester United squad player. If he can do that more often, there would be no issues.
No, only those who haven't got a clue what they're talking about think that, Try and think past the Dab, we've all been young.....I know I was quoted in the OP. But the goal he had, as sad as it is to say it, will pretty much keep him afloat for another string of bad performances, until he scores again, thus continuing the cycle over and over. I know we're all thinking it...
I've practically given up on the forum...after 20 years. @Raoul @Niall I know you've been trying hard to get more new posters on the forum but it's seriously time for a mass cull because the place has got as bad as RAWK of late and it will drive away all the decent posters. Half the poster's I seriously doubt are even United fans. Quite simply, if someone starts attacking a United player or our manager in a way that if an oppo fan did that in the street he would get lynched by Reds then that should be bannable by itself.Cheers! Always been around but the United forum is hard to read nowadays.
I really can't work out why you don't like this thread.
You joined in 2016?I've practically given up on the forum...after 20 years. @Raoul @Niall I know you've been trying hard to get more new posters on the forum but it's seriously time for a mass cull because the place has got as bad as RAWK of late and it will drive away all the decent posters. Half the poster's I seriously doubt are even United fans. Quite simply, if someone starts attacking a United player or our manager in a way that if an oppo fan did that in the street he would get lynched by Reds then that should be bannable by itself.
I was @Neil Thomson previously. After a long absence rejoined.You joined in 2016?
Good one..Says his biggest defender. Are you 2 related?
feck me.My personal fav.
That's one of the more absurd statements I've seen in a long time. Gary Neville has even said what an underrated player he was.I don't get it ! I think he's a really good player. As a squad player I think he's a great option to have. He's extremely intelligent in his movement and capable of scoring brilliant goals.
When I look at how players like Park, who literally offered nothing more than work rate, are remembered I can only assume the issues lie in his personality. That people don't like his personality so it influences their opinion of his ability
He is probably his mum and been waiting to make this thread since the Swansea match when he scored his last two goals.You seem genuinely upset every time someone criticises Lingard. Are you related to him or something?
Do you think it’s justified to call him a championship level player?I don't hate him, but all the criticism he got and will get later is justified IMO.
No way! Welcome back fella, old schoolI was @Neil Thomson previously. After a long absence rejoined.
Personally, probably not. That said I think the majority of his performances don't really justify him being a player for a 'top four' Premier League team either.Do you think it’s justified to call him a championship level player?
Aren't you the one who said that Gomes could be put in place of Lingard and we wouldn't see a difference?He is probably his mum and been waiting to make this thread since the Swansea match when he scored his last two goals.
Why is any kind of criticism described as hate on here? Hate is such a strong word, I've never hated and never will hate a United player.
Try reading some of the threads and you will see. Genuine hateHe is probably his mum and been waiting to make this thread since the Swansea match when he scored his last two goals.
Why is any kind of criticism described as hate on here? Hate is such a strong word, I've never hated and never will hate a United player.
Please see my post after this. I wasn’t saying that he should be scoring goals like that anywhere near regularly. I meant that a squad player that plays for United still needs to be of a standard that he can help us complete in title races. Not a squad player that’s just there for numbers.You're mad
I could understand not liking him so much if he played a lot but he doesn't. A poster said it best, he is "innofensive". Squad players like that are always needed in any team.
Bollocks. Every player gets criticism. Problem is nobody goes all 'protective mother hen' every time someone points out Herrera's played shite. Lingard's performances are routinely poor and people's assessments reflect that.Try reading some of the threads and you will see. Genuine hate
I agree, there does seem to be genuine hatred towards him from certain posters which is weird.Try reading some of the threads and you will see. Genuine hate
Yeah I am the one who said that. And it is stupid looking at it after last night's game, but in contrast if you look at the rest of the showings from Jesse it looks much more reasonable. Lets be sincere, till now games like last night happen for him every couple of months and games like the one against Basel are the norm. He got criticized because he was very poor, and I alluded to some of our youngsters that could take those minutes with greater longterm benefits for the club. Before Gomes I've mentioned Indy Boonen also, I'm not sure what is so stupid if our options are what they are.Aren't you the one who said that Gomes could be put in place of Lingard and we wouldn't see a difference?
That's a stupid statement and the criticism that Geebs had in mind when he created this thread. Constructive and fair criticism is okay.
Maybe there are some who hate him, I was generally referring to myself. I don't hate him, I'm just rarely satisfied by what he offers to our play and criticize him, like I did with Darmian, Herrera or anyone who has played poorly.Try reading some of the threads and you will see. Genuine hate
What? Yes they do.Bollocks. Every player gets criticism. Problem is nobody goes all 'protective mother hen' every time someone points out Herrera's played shite.
I agree. He's a player at the lower end of decent, always has been. His stats are terrible, his final ball is non existent, he doesnt provide enough quality. There is one moment of brilliance here and there, but that's about it. But at the end of the day, he's a squad player and as long as he's treated as one, I dont have a problem with himI don't hate him, but all the criticism he got and will get later is justified IMO.