Before we talk about high press, we have to talk about what we want. We want to win the ball back, ok, but how? Force them into the long ball and push them back with a quick attack? Do we want to trap them and intercept the pass? High press is not high press.
For different styles a manager needs different players. The problem high press is just a word for Ole, no idea, no plan, just attacking the defence. So it does not work.
A good manager would coach this team high press, the players would work together, we have great material but no idea to use it.