His price is likely to shoot up after his first cap 
Ivan Toney | Banned until 16th January 2024 Stay on Topic!
- Thread starter Classical Mechanic
- Start date
More good newsHis price is likely to shoot up after his first cap
More good news
Isn't Osimhen broken all the time? Seems to get injured a lot for a player in Seria A.
Would get Phil Jonesed in the PL
Would get Phil Jonesed in the PL
My little Toney
Skinny and boney
Skinny and boney
Blasphemy!
He is free to come watch games. When it comes to British players the standard tend to drop among the fan base. We should buy players who are top class/ world class (Eriksen, Casemiro) or promising talents already at a good level (Antony, Malacia, Martinez). Ivan is your run of the mill EPL forward (good player), not what you want if you want to compete at the very top in the league and Europe.
I’m not trying to read any of this nonsense. Ivan Toney is a very good player that would make us stronger. Considerably too.
We paid a fortune for a fidget spinner in Antony and he’s not at a level higher than Toney. No one in our forward line is currently.
United finished 6th with a 0 goal difference. We have some way go to compete at the very top of the league and in Europe and Toney can help us in said way.
I agree Toney would be a good signing but unsure why there’s a need to shit on Antony when he’s just set foot at the club?
I understand being protective of new signings, but I wasn’t shitting on Antony. We did pay a fortune for him, and the fidget spinner remark was lighthearted in intent and alluding at his trademark skill. I’m a fan and I hope he becomes a beast for us - post history can attest.
I’d argue our biggest issue is not hitting on the players in the middle. I hate to keep returning to them but Pool for a period scouted players with EPL experience who just needed to be brought on further.
I’ve not truly seen enough of Toney to say whether he is good enough but we shouldn’t restrict ourselves to the 2 types of signings you mention. Van Dijk, Mane, Robertson, Wijnaldum say hello. We need to be more proactive with courting these players.
He'd be a good second choice striker. I'm not convinced he is our answer to Haaland. I'm also not convinced that Brentford would want a second choice fee.
Toney is better than all our forwards you say. I have had it all now.
Do we need a second Choice 9, who is the first choice?
Poor reading comprehension is not the move bro. Not the move.
Haaland is an outlier talent so no forward we're going to sign will stack up in that comparison.
But generally I agree. If we signed Toney he'd currently be our best CF but I don't think it would be long before there were calls to sell someone like Martial and bring in legitimately top level CF talent who would then push Toney into a squad role.
At which point you have to ask if there's a legitimately top level CF talent we could sign next summer instead, cutting out that middle step.
We haven't really got a first or second choice number 9, unless we consider an injury prone Martial. That's the problem. I don't rate Toney highly enough to be first choice, but he would be a good second choice. However, he would cost £60-80m and that money would be better served going towards a bona-fide top class striker, or one who at least has the potential to be.
What you describe is our dilemma. It's almost a choice between two options.
Option 1: Moving for a world class, but ageing striker. Kane or Benzema come to mind.
Option 2: Taking a bit of a Nunez-like punt on one of the many younger options out there in the hope that they could reach that level.
It's also very possible that we won't have the luxury of Option 1.
what a player
We will only sign him if he is overpriced, so the more expensive the better! Couldn’t we have got antony at 45 million at the beginning of the window? Same with maguire, could have had him cheaper the year before. But our system is clear. With big signings, only sign when it’s way over price!His price is likely to shoot up after his first cap
I still think Liverpool missed a trick by not bringing him in last summer and using the remaining cash to bolster the midfield.
I'm not sure if he's top top quality but think he could more than do a job as a squad player at a top team.
He's the best option we can go for in the summer.
I just posted in the Georgian Messi thread.
We should unearth a really good striker in smaller leagues.
Toney is really good but will cost a bomb.
We should unearth a really good striker in smaller leagues.
Toney is really good but will cost a bomb.
Get him in
This fits with our MO of selling players at peak value too
What a lovely finish for the first goal tonight - pure class.
The beeb article mentions he’s perfect from the penalty spot. So you know he’ll miss if he’s taking one at the WC.
Needs to get in squad first
Yep! Good for your club and hope you spend it wellThis fits with our MO of selling players at peak value too
What a lovely finish for the first goal tonight - pure class.
Good on Toney for exposing that neanderthal cnut.
Takes a special kind of knob to write that stuff while showing their face.
Remember when we were scrambling around for a second striker and we ended up with Ighalo on loan? While we were doing this, Brentford signed Ivan Toney for 5 million quid. He was EFL top goal scorer and player of the season. He has proved that the step up hasn't held him back at all. If anything, he is better in the PL.
The other night, when we couldn't hit a barn door with a banjo, (33 attempts on goal) Toney would have been looking at double figures. He just knows where the goal is and has honed his talents into becoming a top striker. I watched him last night and that first goal was sublime. His movement, his first touch, his confidence. He really is at the top of his game. Imagine him getting top quality service from Erikson and Bruno.
He's not even a gamble. Relying on the fitness of Martial or the diminishing talent of Ronaldo is a gamble.
Go and get him. He will score 25+ goals every season. He's also got another 5-7 years at the top level, so even when he's not in the first team, he can come on from the bench and score goals.
The other night, when we couldn't hit a barn door with a banjo, (33 attempts on goal) Toney would have been looking at double figures. He just knows where the goal is and has honed his talents into becoming a top striker. I watched him last night and that first goal was sublime. His movement, his first touch, his confidence. He really is at the top of his game. Imagine him getting top quality service from Erikson and Bruno.
He's not even a gamble. Relying on the fitness of Martial or the diminishing talent of Ronaldo is a gamble.
Go and get him. He will score 25+ goals every season. He's also got another 5-7 years at the top level, so even when he's not in the first team, he can come on from the bench and score goals.
Some of the comments on that feed are disgusting
I’d prefer Sesko but would mind Toney
Brentford would demand stupid money for him. Need to look elsewhere.
Agree with everyone here. He's a brilliant player and has scored goals at every level he's played at (From league 2). Works hard, has good hold up play, presses like an animal and knows where the goal is (8 in 10 is a brilliant return).
Would instantly be our best striker.
He also had very good chemistry with Eriksen, the end of last season iirc. That's another positive.
Would instantly be our best striker.
He also had very good chemistry with Eriksen, the end of last season iirc. That's another positive.
Last edited:
He’s already signed for someone else though
There was talk of him being sold before kicking a ball for Leipzig