Yes, that has been his general problem since he has been herePogba’s going nowhere
Júnior Firpo
- Thread starter MyOnlySolskjaer
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran hold a long overdue conversation about United's awful league form with 1 win in 7. They discuss a disappointing draw at Bournemouth, a not so disappointing draw against Liverpool and a crushing defeat at Chelsea - Is time nearly over for Erik Ten Hag?
Then in a special second half of the pod, Nik welcomes Natalie ( https://twitter.com/natalie_17) to discuss the fortunes of Manchester United Women as they booked a place in the FA Cup Final after a historic first ever win vs. Chelsea.
Brutal..
Couldn't agree more
Roy Keane did say that Shaw wasn't good enough.
Signing a LB and RB this summer would mean the end of Laird and his pathway to the first team, unless we make Dalot a RW. Rather we avoided this scenario as Laird looks promising and would mean Ole going back on his word of bringing through youth.
Personally I believe in Laird and would go for a LB instead. Would love Tierney, but that's not gonna happen.
Laird will probably move inside as his game develops so nothing to worry about on that score, he did play there the last time I saw him for England.
Don't disagree much.
If Laird is good enough nothing will stop his pathway to the first team. Right now he's just a promising academy prospect, nothing more. The club should have an eye on the future of course but we should be looking at proven players that will improve United right away
Last edited:
So what?
We need to improve the first team especially starting eleven with players whose main experience isn’t the reserves or u21s. If they good enough then they’d break through. The sams goes for Greenwood. Unless you wanna wait a few more years for Young to be starting whilst Laird develops. Get players in who can start for you now.
We have a great academy but people are way too obsessed with the class of 92 and all that trying to replicate it. How many youngsters are our rivals in the top 5 producing? Not many. The premier league is more ruthless league now we can’t be seen as a youth development side. Pep was lauded as the man who gave youth a chance and look what he’s done in the prem. He even admitted he’s not going to give many players from the City academy a chance.
There could be something in this folks.. Real Madrid have turned their attention to Ferland Mendy of Lyon. And we seem to be ahead in the race for his signature according to local Betis media.
He is a very good attacking fullback. Not sure about his defensive qualities, but attacking wise, he will make Shaw look like a league one player. At that price, you wont find a better modern fullback. With modern i mean someone who has a clue what to do with and without the ball when he passes the halfway line.
Would be a good signing at €30m if the above report is to be believed.
30m is a great price for a young full back. I’m down. Starting to actually think we need a LB more as we have a lot of prospects at RB, especially if you think O’connor will be a RB too.
Been saying for two years that we need a summer like City where we let go pretty much all of our full backs and bring in at least two new ones. At the time I wanted Young, Valencia and Shaw our, although Shaw has obviously shown his worth since then.
If there were not so many holes in the side, or we had unlimited funds, the. I’d be all for getting Firpo and a right back. This is what the team needs.
If there were not so many holes in the side, or we had unlimited funds, the. I’d be all for getting Firpo and a right back. This is what the team needs.
I think Ole probably spoke to Roy Keane..
Why?I think Ole probably spoke to Roy Keane..
Roy Keane said on Sky that Luke Shaw isn't good enough.
Ah, okay. What do you think?
There's question marks with him going forward and he seems to have a weight issue. A LB is required due to him needing competition regardless. He needs to be challenged for his place.
Agree on all points. It was great to see a solid defensive presence on the left, but as far as attacking output goes, he had to be on the low end of the scale for PL leftbacks.
He is good defensively but not outstanding. He is very limited going forward. LB should not be a priority position this summer, unless we have huge war chest.
Why aren’t we looking at Telles?
He’s 26, has 4G 8A from 33 matches in the league and 1G 3A from 10 champions league games. He’s in the whoscored team of the season and is rumoured to have a 35 million euro release clause. There was a lot of talk last summer linking us and Bayern to him but it just fizzled out. If the clause is there, shouldn’t we be looking at Telles considering he is more experienced than Shaw and Junior?
He’s 26, has 4G 8A from 33 matches in the league and 1G 3A from 10 champions league games. He’s in the whoscored team of the season and is rumoured to have a 35 million euro release clause. There was a lot of talk last summer linking us and Bayern to him but it just fizzled out. If the clause is there, shouldn’t we be looking at Telles considering he is more experienced than Shaw and Junior?
Saw him live at Camp Nou in november. Was good in that game. Scored a goal too, but he played as a left winger. I’m not sure he would adapt to premier league either. If he is bought to compete with Shaw I think he would be a good punt.
Local media reporting our first bid has been rejected..
Probably the last position we should be looking at to strengthen if we're indeed making 5-6 purchases this window.
I think we will get Meunier, with Dalot and Laird as back-up
I’m not so sure, we offer very little attacking width that side, so it would be good to have an option and some competition for Shaw.
Not really? We have Shaw... and that's it. Unless you're counting Darmian/Rojo/Young as valid options
I reckon If we signed him, he'd be our first choice left back within a month. Shaw isn't good enough for a team wanting to be challenging for trophies
I wouldn't say no to a bit more competition to Shaw, but CB, 2 CM's, RW, ST, AM - far more important positions to strengthen right now. GK as well if we lose DDG(or he doesn't sign).Not really? We have Shaw... and that's it. Unless you're counting Darmian/Rojo/Young as valid options
Link/source
The only way I see this happening is if Shaw is converted into a CB in a system with three at the back. I actually think Shaw would flourish in this role, as he has the physique to compete with most strikers and is extremely solid one-on-one. This will also give us a left-footed CB that is comfortable with the ball in his feet. This may allow us to bring in Firpo as a wing-back, who would provide width down the left side, which is absolutely neccessary as Martial and Rashford keep cutting in when playing LW.
In theory it works, but I recall that he played LCB one game in the 2nd half of last season and his man scored. So it might be a longer process than you think for him to get used to the role
@Ekeke I agree that this will take some time, but we have seen Azpilicueta successfully making this transition in Chelsea. I think Shaw has all the tools to succeed in this role, even if it may take him a few years to get the mindset of a proper CB.
Cheers
If the release clause of Alex Telles is true at 35-40m euro, then I'd much rather go for some experience rather than being left with two young left backs
Not heard much of this guy though to be honest
Not heard much of this guy though to be honest