A very fair question. On the surface, one could say that Amorim was so beholden to his 343 that there simply was no place for Mainoo over either Bruno or Casemiro. And to a certain extent fair enough, but when the losses kept piling up week after week Amorim preferred taking the losses than make the obvious tactical adjustment -- which I believe he did once, against Newcastle, and we won the game, though Mainoo was out due to injury on that day. And thus Amorim was sacked, and we know all about the reversal of fortunes under Carrick, with Mainoo being a central figure in the restoration.
But the Tuchel decision to refuse playing Kobbie is inexplicable. All Tommy had to do was to watch the video from 2024 to see Mainoo perform brilliantly with Rice for England. Taken with the help of AI, but AI is getting better by the day in cobbling confirmed facts:
- Record-Breaking Passing: According to Opta statistics via Manchester United, Mainoo recorded a 96% pass completion rate during the tournament. This is the highest accuracy ever recorded by a midfielder at a European Championship since data collection began in 1980. He misplaced only five passes during the entire tournament. [1, 2, 3]
- Semi-Final Milestone: At just 19 years and 82 days old, he became the youngest player ever to start a major tournament semi-final for England in their victory over the Netherlands. [1, 2]
- Complete Midfield Display: In that semi-final, LiveScore match data highlighted that Mainoo won 100% of his duels and tackles, while leading the team in defensive recoveries and interceptions. [1]
The obvious reply is that Tuchel had Anderson whereas Southgate did not. Was Anderson reliable? Without a doubt, but the England midfield -- barring Bellingham, if you consider him more a midfielder than a second striker -- struggled to make an impact against an admittedly very good Argentina side, but what England was missing was the kind of close control passing and ball retention nous that Mainoo excels at.
As for being a great one, we're in agreement but I'll go one step further and state that Mainoo is already a great one. He has a manager who understands what Mainoo is capable of.