He spent too long playing centre back at United and didn't develop the attacking side of his game as a full back.
Yeah I see him as a decent versatile player but I've never understood the hype he got here, it's never great not having any clear position on the field. I think he will be a very useful player in the future for a club like Norwich which isn't too bad if that happens.
I don't see him as being 'raw' at all. On the contrary, I think he's quite a cultured footballer. His main problem for me is a lack of outstanding physical attributes be it searing pace, imposing height/strength. This may have prevented him making it at United but there's no way in hell he's Scottish Championship level. He got a full Irish international cap at 19 in a game where he really shone. He's also been a key player in an excellent Irish U21 team. I'm so disappointed that he hasn't just cut his losses at Celtic (like United, they're very strong in his position) and sought a move back to the English Championship.
