TwoSheds
More sheds (and tiles) than you, probably
- Joined
- Feb 12, 2014
- Messages
- 12,903
I'm coming round to the idea that he's the best in the league at the moment. Fantastic to have a player like him again.
Hopefully this works out better than Heinze and tevez ... (And veron for different reasons )I havent bought a kit with name and number on the back in ages. Hell, havent bought a kit itself in ages, but I'm thinking of buying one with Martinez on the back.
Yeah, 2 of them were great but then turned out to be pricks, Veron deal never worked out sadly.Hopefully this works out better than Heinze and tevez ... (And veron for different reasons )
To be fair Maguire is actually very good at that (only to the left side though). Not many hit that cross field pass to the left winger/fullback better than he does. Otherwise yes his passing is fairly average, and (more importantly) he tends to dwell on the ball for way too long before actually making the pass.That claim puzzles me as well. From what I saw in the past 4 years, all Maguire can do is making diagonal long passes to the wingers, that's it. He can't play one touch football (and always need 2nd 3rd 4th or 5th touch before releasing the ball) and rarely make good through balls vertically forward.
Honestly that’s a hard ass fit. I love it.
Bruh.Honestly that’s a hard ass fit. I love it.
He's become a Mancunian now
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
The Butcher then put in a 2 footed tackle on the kids and sped offTweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
No, it has been discussed to death, EtH doesn't rate him there, just let him play centre back.Could he play as a DM? I just feel like he has the quality. Him next to Casemiro in that midfield could be one hell of a duo.
The contrast to Joe Gomez for Brighton's winner yesterday is quite something.
It has a lot but his quality and performances have really doubted that judgement for me. Perhaps he has improved as a player since then and can do a good job there now.No, it has been discussed to death, EtH doesn't rate him there, just let him play centre back.
What is it with everyone's obsession with taking every great ball playing defender and sticking them at CDM?It has a lot but his quality and performances have really doubted that judgement for me. Perhaps he has improved as a player since then and can do a good job there now.
Unlike the other usual 'oh he's doing a good job as a defender and is technically good therefore he should play as a DM' ala the Shaw and even Lindelof shouts, Martinez looks altogether a completely different (potential) proposition to play that role. Firstly, he's played there before, he doesn't really have lapses of concentration, he's fairly pressed resistant as he can stand on the ball and turn quite nimbly away from a player, is technically very very good on the ball and of course, off the ball offers a lot of tenacity with interceptions, jostling and tackling.
If anything, when I see Martinez play, he seems to be more playing within himself in the sense that he's being professional doing a job at the back rather than a 'natural'; he doesn't try to force passes or try to influence the play more than he needs to, when he has the quality to do so. He doesn't suit box to box but another 10-20 yards up the field honestly is that not much of a stretch for me. The only question mark is perhaps his back to goal play/awareness and in the pockets where you can lose the ball more easily etc as we've not seen much of that due to his current position.
We already have casemiro playing CDM. Literally the best CDM in the world. Licha is pulling up trees playing his natural position at CB and the pairing with varane is potentially the best cb duo in the league right now. I certainly can't think of any I'd swap them for.It has a lot but his quality and performances have really doubted that judgement for me. Perhaps he has improved as a player since then and can do a good job there now.
Unlike the other usual 'oh he's doing a good job as a defender and is technically good therefore he should play as a DM' ala the Shaw and even Lindelof shouts, Martinez looks altogether a completely different (potential) proposition to play that role. Firstly, he's played there before, he doesn't really have lapses of concentration, he's fairly pressed resistant as he can stand on the ball and turn quite nimbly away from a player, is technically very very good on the ball and of course, off the ball offers a lot of tenacity with interceptions, jostling and tackling.
If anything, when I see Martinez play, he seems to be more playing within himself in the sense that he's being professional doing a job at the back rather than a 'natural'; he doesn't try to force passes or try to influence the play more than he needs to, when he has the quality to do so. He doesn't suit box to box but another 10-20 yards up the field honestly is that not much of a stretch for me. The only question mark is perhaps his back to goal play/awareness and in the pockets where you can lose the ball more easily etc as we've not seen much of that due to his current position.
What is it with everyone's obsession with taking every great ball playing defender and sticking them at CDM?
I'm thinking hypothetically for discussion's sake and because we may require his ability from time to time i.e isolated situations, with the Arsenal game being the most recent example. Not trusting to start Fred in that game and having McT is a worst trade off than potentially having a player like Martinez, who could do a job there. Just like Pepe/Ramos at Madrid or Marquinhos at PSG etc. Also as I said above, I think he has a much stronger claim than the usual 'can he play as xyz?' comments you'd see.We already have casemiro playing CDM. Literally the best CDM in the world. Licha is pulling up trees playing his natural position at CB and the pairing with varane is potentially the best cb duo in the league right now. I certainly can't think of any I'd swap them for.
Why would you want to break up that partnership to move him into a role where the manager has openly stated he doesn't excel in?
Lets play our best players in their correct position, that's whats got us this far this season.
I can't see them both playing together unless it's for like 10 minutes to preserve a lead, but I still sort of think we'll see Lisandro at DM this season at some point.Could he play as a DM? I just feel like he has the quality. Him next to Casemiro in that midfield could be one hell of a duo.
It’s a discussion point on a forum. That’s all.What is it with everyone's obsession with taking every great ball playing defender and sticking them at CDM?
Seeing Shaw can play CB, and we've obviously missed out on a trick like that for years while being starved of good footballers (Maguire says hi) maybe there's good reasons to consider if other players fit other places?What is it with everyone's obsession with taking every great ball playing defender and sticking them at CDM?
thank you for providing his services. CaptainWhat a player. We miss his defensive capabilities in our current Ajax team, but more so his mentality. We have a team of soft whimps at the moment, having one Martinez in there would transform our team immensely. Good to see him doing so incredibly well at United.
Not sure why but the first thing I thought was is that the bond villain Nick Nack.
It's been tried and considered by our manager in a much weaker league. Our manager doesn't rate him in there.Seeing Shaw can play CB, and we've obviously missed out on a trick like that for years while being starved of good footballers (Maguire says hi) maybe there's good reasons to consider if other players fit other places?
We haven't missed that trick, we just didn't have anyone else to play at LB. We've played Jones, Smalling, Blind, O'Shea, Bailly, Lindelof, and even lesser players like Blackett and McNair(?) on both fullbacks and CBs. Even Shaw played a CB in 3 man defence before for us.Seeing Shaw can play CB, and we've obviously missed out on a trick like that for years while being starved of good footballers (Maguire says hi) maybe there's good reasons to consider if other players fit other places?
I understand where you and some others are coming from, but moving one of the best CB's in the world to CDM and then moving one of the best LB's in the world to CB to cover for him is just a terrible way of building a side (barring some sort of insane emergency where every midfielder is injured).Seeing Shaw can play CB, and we've obviously missed out on a trick like that for years while being starved of good footballers (Maguire says hi) maybe there's good reasons to consider if other players fit other places?
Seriously, are people still pushing this?Seeing Shaw can play CB, and we've obviously missed out on a trick like that for years while being starved of good footballers (Maguire says hi) maybe there's good reasons to consider if other players fit other places?
Maybe because he tried it 2 years ago and he improved a lot during that time?Seriously, are people still pushing this?
Martinez will not play in midfield for Manchester United, barring the most serious of injury crisis. EtH knows this, because he didn't think he suited the role in the Eredivisie...why would he think he can in a far more competitive league?!
He's also our best defender this season. You keep keep playing him where he is, because that's where he offers the most to the team.