UnitedSofa
You'll Never Walk Away
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2013
- Messages
- 9,981

This fact ought to be instructive to the decision makers at United because the two outstanding positions (GK and CM) will put a ceiling on what we can achieve this season. It might also necessitate an early managerial sacking which brings with it uncertainty and kills continuity, we can't always be in this cycle of always offloading unwanted players signed by the previous manager so we must give Amorim the best chance to succeed this season. The fees being touted aren't budget busters, surely a club like United shouldn't have trouble covering a PSR hole of 7m, the consequences of continuing this season with just Casemiro and Ugarte for the DM are too dire to contemplate.From looking at the stats, he looks like a similar profile to Casemiro but maybe a bit better at ball carrying. If it's true that he isn't the most mobile, I'd rather avoid and target a player who can do that to a good standard, and ideally a player who also scores well on defensive and passing metrics.
Baleba's the gold standard for that, but I don't think we can afford to neglect those needs entirely on the basis we might go back in for him next summer. We need those qualities in the team now.
I think we need this more than anything, more so considering he is decent with the ball.He was my choice for Case replacement - is raw but has the broad skillet, decent on the ball, good passer, a languid but deceptively fast dribbling style but I think his main strength is reading the game defensively - he's a real pain in the arse for teams to get around or run past and picks up a lot of interceptions and turnovers or at least slows stuff down.
Ugarte was poorly scouted, it feels like more of a case of us signing the name and not really analyzing a player's skill set and how it would translate to the PL. Hopefully those days are behind us, but you will always have the occasional poor signing - all clubs have them but they are not as detrimental to their performances because the inherent quality in those squads compensates for these duds.Don't really want to be risking more potentially sub-standard players. It's only last year we signed Ugarte and now he's considered to be crap. Our recruitment is just shocking bad.
Ugarte's biggest issues are his limitations on the ball, if he was a bit better in possession, he'd be a very good player because his off the ball stats are great.He's fairly slow, no? Going to come up against the same problems Ugarte has.
Especially if someone has excellent positioning he can sweep off the high press.Speed isnt and never will be a requirement for central midfield
The problem is we need a good season this season and preferably to also get CL football or at least EL otherwise the gap between us and the chasing pack will be wider. Midfield is going to cost us this season if it doesn't get addressed and for someone costing 35m it won't be too much of a hustle, that is if we don't go crazy with the wage offer, to transition him to a squad role as he would only set us back by 7m a season re PSR.The midfield needs a complete rebuild like we did with attack this summer. If that’s the plan then maybe we are better off saving the money for two blockbuster CM signings next summer than getting a stop gap.
That's a 10 second 100m so not too shabby.As he’s been recorded as running at 36.24km/h, I’d suggest you correct the post you viewed,
Not saying that I’m correct, just my impression. But I’d need to watch a bunch of Spanish league to get a full picture. I’m sure that our scouting team have a better full impression of him!Ok. /thread and lets move on![]()
Casemiro, Bruno, Ugarte and Mainoo?Doesnt seem much better than what we have
Doesnt seem much better than what we have
35m can't remember if that was sterling or euros.does this chap have a release clause?
That's a positive, mind you people on this thread keep on commenting about how slow he isHe's a totally different profile to anything we have in deep-lying midfield
Doesnt seem much better than what we have
Bailly and Martial stuff all broke from foreign sources before it reached the usual Utd ones , so remains to be seen whether this has any legs
Are you thinking of Marcos Senna from Villarreal?
I've convinced myself the story has legs. Does Agoume have legs? Unclear.
speed is definitely a requirement for a CM in the modern game ESPECIALLY when you have only 2 in there defensively for large periods of the game
not sure but athleticism and speed are one in the same for me
Amorim would seem to disagree, as he specifically cited the lack of pace in midfield as an issue during pre-season:
Yeah exactly why it makes a lot of sense because can provide us with flexibility depending on opponentsCan’t speak to his speed, but he seems a more well rounded CM - can do a bit of everything. Would make him a useful partner to different types of CMs and someone who could step in for Wharton or Baleba after we buy both next summer![]()
Seems to have good all round skillsetThe real question is would he be a good partner to Bruno? As he is seemingly undroppable and whoever we bring into CM would need to be able to handle the midfield on their own
Is his lack of pace a real thing ? I have been googling and can't find any stats beyond what was posted here.
Could be fake news.
Not gonna do that unless we look like signing himI read that myself and lost all interest. I am going to watch him on YouTube and make up my own mind.
The real question is would he be a good partner to Bruno? As he is seemingly undroppable and whoever we bring into CM would need to be able to handle the midfield on their own
I thought this too but the midfield 2 of Bruno & Case did really well v ArsenalPlaying Bruno in any 2 is suicide. He'd work in a 433 so would Mount but not in this formation.
Long shorts, I presume?Oh god, that’s a blast from the past. The caf was full of turning a corner jokes.
Videos suggest otherwise, he looks more than capable of outrunning other players, he’s not exactly at van de Ven or Mbuemo at top speed but how many midfielders are? He’s fast enough, strong and a good passer.Is his lack of pace a real thing ? I have been googling and can't find any stats beyond what was posted here.
Could be fake news.
that's funny bc Ruben completely disagrees with that and made those feelings quite clear at the beginning of the window....he clearly said we need more pace and athleticism in our midfieldNope. Its a position surrounded by bodies taking up space. Its the outfield position speed is least impactful. On the sides you have space to run down, up front you need to run in behind the defence, in defence you need to track runners running in behind you. In midfield you are the most obstructed from running at full speed, especially if the opponents are pressing you.
Not gonna do that unless we look like signing him
Have we? Because like you said we’ve never had speed so how can we be obsessed with it. However Amorim as pointed this out to be an attribute he would like in his midfielder for this system. Amorim wants us to press like mad and speed in midfield would help this and also help track back… a 2 man midfield is dangerous anyway But I noticed against arsenal he wants Mbeumo to stay forward which would help if we had the right sided cm who was pacy and can get about. Casemiro was very good but he won’t always be.I think too many people have gotten obsessed with speed in midfield. I mean it's great to have but it has never been a necessity, the wide majority of great midfielders historically have never been pacey. You don't want a midfielder that's too slow either but as long as he's not that type of liability, and he knows how to read the game at an advanced level & how to use the ball, those should be the priorities. I haven't seen this guy play but his stats certainly hold up well and suggest that he can both defend & use the ball well.