Nickelodeon
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 20, 2015
- Messages
- 2,324
Wonder how long before a thread titled 'What does John Murtough do?' is created?
That means nothing. Woodward has already specifically said he plays no part in transfers other than signing off the money. He’s still CEO and still oversees all large expenditure. His role in transfers will stay the same, minimal.Saw this line in an article I read. That’s good enough for me. Apparently Murtough scouted Mejbri.
Murtough is now the second highest football man at the clubWho knows whether these guys are up to the job? Certainly nobody on the caf.
What we do know though is that we have now introduced an extra layer of football expertise (in the form of a former player/coach and a former sports scientist/head of performance) at the level above management. I struggle to see how that can be a bad thing.
Well 2014 would still include the majority of the dreadful post-Fergie transfers. But I’d imagine LVG and Jose asked for specific players and were arrogant enough to ignore whatever internal advice was being provided.Seems like he's done the job in truth since 2014. And he's clearly done a decent job - our recruitment record is much better. So hopefully it will continue in that vein.
Edit: this, presumably, is just to allow him to get more info the public eye and deflect criticism of our processes which are clearly more robust than "Ed Woodward is God and decides everything"! (And I love Ed, so I'm definitely in the tiny minority there ha ha)
Well, at least the position has been created. Which means if he doesn’t do the job well then we can bring someone else
My take as well. It is progress.First we have the position created and the next step is to bin this guy off for someone better. This is great progress people.
I don't know anything about him, but I'm sure more information will flood the forum soon enough. Having been with United during these years in the doldrums doesn't really promote the idea that he's the best in class. But who knows, it's been Ed and Matt running amok wasting money left, right and centre and being a complete shitshow.This forum man. Even when we get what we want we aren't happy.
The guys been around since 2014 and we want "someone better" aka, someone we've heard of.
Lord give me strength
Judge just went from reporting to Woodward to reporting to Murtough, so he is one step down the ladder.so it all people from within whove been there years anyway. I assume Judge gets a payrise for his 'new' role aswell
DOF’s don’t get carte blanche anywhere. They all report into someone.What’s his actual football background? He still reports to Woodward, I’m not sure an actual director of football at other clubs would do that.
What actually is Fletcher's qualification for the role of technical director beyond being affiliated with the manager? This isn't like throwing on a sub for the final 2 minutes of a match. Remember how green Woodward was in his first summer at the club.Who knows whether these guys are up to the job? Certainly nobody on the caf.
What we do know though is that we have now introduced an extra layer of football expertise (in the form of a former player/coach and a former sports scientist/head of performance) at the level above the manager. I struggle to see how that can be a bad thing.
Id give it a good 24 hours.Too early to say if its a good or a bad thing.
created another management layer to shield themselves from criticism. well done Ed!
Most of that is already happening.Id give it a good 24 hours.
no doubt this place will start going into meltdown.
looking forward to the forensic analysis and character dissection of a man we don’t know. Won’t stop some...
Waiting for
“can he play right wing”
“Woodward’s puppet”
“State of this club”
“Embarrassing”
There would not be a single Football Club where Director of Football would be top most in Organisational Hierarchy . Off course they would report to Ceo or equivalent position directly or Indirectly.What’s his actual football background? He still reports to Woodward, I’m not sure an actual director of football at other clubs would do that.