criticalanalysis
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 12, 2015
- Messages
- 10,224
Can't wait for him to score, cup his ears and then point to his temple 
All of this is true, although it has to be remembered that the wages of most (probably all) of our players go up 25% due to us being in the CL again. So it's not quite as easy as removing the wages of the players we've gotten rid of and adding the extra money we get from being in the CL (none of which we've actually got yet).He hasnt lived up to expectations we had and is nowhere near the player we had in 2023, but he has shown in glimpses at Barca and with England he can still be valuable PL level player.
The press briefing his wages are stopping us spending money is complete BS.
Casemiro gone with his ~£300k p/w wages off the wage bill
Sancho wages are finally off the books
Bayindir/onana wages are being covered on loan
Grasping at straws but even ugarte wages are mostly covered by FIFA this season due to WC injury
We ve added Santos and Tielemans combined wont be much more than £300k but saving almost £1m a week from departures, thats at least ~£25m a year wage savings. On top of that UCL money and can funds from Hoijlund sale as well.
And they still using Rashford wages as excuse for their poor planning. You can only say Rashford staying has impacted our LW option and our pursuit of Summerville. But this doesn't affect CM, LB signings.
I think his best seasons were under Ole actually. Despite him scoring more goals under ETH that one season.Who did the best season of his career come under again?
Agreed, it's been obvious with his performances and also that quote about him and Steve McClaren.Do you think the structure we played in ETH’s first season was anything like his second? I don’t recall the donut midfield being a feature in season 1. We also purchased Hojlund, who is just a fundamentally bad player and the worst possible type of CF to partner Rashford, and played without a genuine left back all season.
Whilst Rashford definitely takes responsibility as he didn’t play well at all for a large chunk of that season (still good in our FA Cup title run though), we couldn’t have set up more for him to fail.
The reality is that all the evidence is that if you stick Rashford in a functional team he will score and create goals at the highest level. If all around him is a complete mess, he won’t raise you consistently from the mire.
Horse has already bolted and his issues are known. It's why he'll never be a captain.So where is his accountability? He’s one of the highest paid players at the club, yet we’re happy accepting that if everyone else is playing well he’ll contribute, but not to look to him to be a senior member of the team to help pull the team out of a dearth?
The ability to look good when all around you are playing well is a commodity you can get for a lot less than £200k a week
He's never going to do any of those things.He needs to show some humility, a sense of realism and maturity.
He could pleasantly surprise us all.
If I was Carrick, I would task him to lead the line and hit 20 goals.
Get on with it.
He doesn’t like playing there. He is expected to score goals.With Sesko still recovering from injury, he is definitely an option as a CF.
We have seen him score loads of goals for us. We have seen him play at a really high level lots of times. Still at a good age. That quality should not come as a surprise.He could pleasantly surprise us all
If he does come back, the only question is how long can he be bothered to make the effort for. Even during the World Cup, the biggest stage, we saw how he would fade after 15-20 mins. Not due to fatigue or injury, but a sense he’d done enough. It’s his mindset. He’s never stopped being like that school kid who will work really hard up until he thinks teacher has stopped paying attention then he’s back to mucking around again
His workrate at a micro and macro level is dreadful. He turns it on when he feels he has to; under the microscope, impressing a new manager, angling for a new contract. He quickly slips back into the pattern of taking his foot off the gas. It’s happens in games and seasons. Even when playing for a permanent move to Barcelona, by all accounts the same demons quickly resurfaced into his game. The laziness, the thinking that pressing is for other people. I know this place was full on “wow he scored a goal - unprecedented, right?” But the denial of the reality of why they rejected him, isn’t serious.
His whole career has been purple patches of form either in-game or over the season, sandwiched between long spells where he looks disinterested. He’ll probably score four goals in the opening couple of matches of the campaign and we won’t see him so much as press for the ball until February
He's never been a good CF though. We've tried (countless times), England tried it and upon recently Barca tried it and it has never came off.With Sesko still recovering from injury, he is definitely an option as a CF.
Let's see. Maybe he can have an Indian summer and we can sell him. Letting him rot is a waste of money and may devalue him further. His contract is up soon. He knows he has to do better to avoid going the way of Sancho.He's never been a good CF though. We've tried (countless times), England tried it and upon recently Barca tried it and it has never came off.
He's a LWF and that's it.
He was quite decent when played there sometimes in the 22/23 season. But yeah, other than that he's always struggled as he doesn't have the all-round game. Simply can't hold on to the ball or win anything in the air, and the only thing he can really do is just constantly try to time runs in behind the defence every time we launch an attack. Which can be useful at certain moments, but overall it's far too limiting.He's never been a good CF though. We've tried (countless times), England tried it and upon recently Barca tried it and it has never came off.
He's a LWF and that's it.
Quite rightLet's see. Maybe he can have an Indian summer and we can sell him. Letting him rot is a waste of money and may devalue him further. His contract is up soon. He knows he has to do better to avoid going the way of Sancho.
Carrick needs to think carefully or risk the same fate as all the other Utd managers he’s played under.Could prove to be Carrick's undoing
He was on holiday. Can we leave out this scummy Sun newspaper bollocksRidiculous situation if he starts for us again. He's checked out and we want him gone. He was on the piss the other day on a yacht. He couldn't care less. You don't want that anywhere near the club.
Your posts on Rashford are always hit the mark. How could you possibly know this?If he does come back, the only question is how long can he be bothered to make the effort for. Even during the World Cup, the biggest stage, we saw how he would fade after 15-20 mins. Not due to fatigue or injury, but a sense he’d done enough. It’s his mindset. He’s never stopped being like that school kid who will work really hard up until he thinks teacher has stopped paying attention then he’s back to mucking around again
His workrate at a micro and macro level is dreadful. He turns it on when he feels he has to; under the microscope, impressing a new manager, angling for a new contract. He quickly slips back into the pattern of taking his foot off the gas. It’s happens in games and seasons. Even when playing for a permanent move to Barcelona, by all accounts the same demons quickly resurfaced into his game. The laziness, the thinking that pressing is for other people. I know this place was full on “wow he scored a goal - unprecedented, right?” But the denial of the reality of why they rejected him, isn’t serious.
His whole career has been purple patches of form either in-game or over the season, sandwiched between long spells where he looks disinterested. He’ll probably score four goals in the opening couple of matches of the campaign and we won’t see him so much as press for the ball until February
When was it though? If its an old picture its a complete no issue. If its the past couple of days its simply idiotic from himHe was on holiday. Can we leave out this scummy Sun newspaper bollocks
When was it though? If its an old picture its a complete no issue. If its the past couple of days its simply idiotic from him
Looks like he’s definitely staying
Looks like he’s definitely staying
What a ridiculous post,Ridiculous situation if he starts for us again. He's checked out and we want him gone. He was on the piss the other day on a yacht. He couldn't care less. You don't want that anywhere near the club.
Well done hes 14
superbNoiceWell done hes 14