Seij
Full Member
- Joined
- Jun 17, 2014
- Messages
- 1,398
Too bad the crucial years of his development are being wasted by a mediocre manager and coaching team.
He is having to change the way he has been told to play for the last god knows how many years...listen to Ole talk about him in interviews all along his development...it’s like he is living vicariously through Greenwood...since breaking into the first team his biggest strength has been shooting on sight, through the defenders legs, working the keeper always, getting the shot away early...if you think that wasn’t a direct instruction from the former-striker-manager then I have no idea how you explain him being given the 11 shirt and becoming a fixture in the first team if he is not executing the managers instructions?.... and while yes he needed to mature and broaden his game he has now been asked to stay wider, look for a team mate and put the ball in the box. It’s a waste. Same as having players like Sancho and Amad and DVB and Lingard and Rashford...none out and out wingers so it is ridiculous we are trying to implement a strategy where they stay wide. Salah and Mane are similar style players but Liverpool get width from the fullbacks...seeing how wide Ole has him is criminal.Going to give an unpopular opinion, I don't think he's going to be anywhere near as good as he shown in his early potential.
Not because I don't believe he has the ability, I just watch him at times and just don't feel he has the hunger or the drive for it.
I said the same about Januazj when he was breaking through years ago. I sat in Old Trafford watching Adnan walk around the pitch, hands in sleeves looking like a child playing with men. I watch Mason some weeks and it's like he'd rather not be on the pitch. He's got bags of ability, he should be putting himself about making positions for himself and demanding the ball to feet.
Instead I think he'd rather have the easy option of being out wide recycling play with the possibility of the odd cut inside shot.
Definitely agree the talent is there. We know it's there as a goal scorer and I think under the right coach he could add a lot of value from a creative perspective (not saying it needs to be a focus of his game but he can help our build up for sure). Sometimes he shows flashes of it with his ability to find a good pass in tight areas, particularly with how good he is with either foot (although does feel like he's lost some confidence in his right foot) however there's a lot to work on in terms of attitude both in terms of decision making but also his general demeanor. Still very young though so plenty of time to adjust this and I think a better manager would be able to get him there- he and Foden came on to the scene at similar times and whilst I think Foden is slightly older, I do think it's telling to see that Foden's growth feels to be on a steeper trajectory than Greenwood's and I do think coaching/managing has a big part to play in that.Have no doubts about his long term potential, he's going to be a top forward. Very clearly needs a good coach to help develop him though. As of now, he's just been too selfish of a player but is just not a wide player as his positioning and movement is all wrong for it. Should be rotated for now though.
Same. I think he will have to increase his intensity on and off the ball considerably if he stands a chance of being a regular. I admire his talent but for Manchester United the application should be a given.Actually think Rangnick could be the making or the breaking of him here. I think he could turn him into something incredible if he's willing to adapt to the style
Massively, luckily he's young enough to add that to his game - if he does, he could be a monstrous talent. If I had to stake my money on it though, I'm not hugely confident.Same. I think he will have to increase his intensity on and off the ball considerably if he stands a chance of being a regular. I admire his talent but for Manchester United the application should be a given.
He has covidWhere's he gone?
Eeks! Out for 10 days kind of covid, or bad?He has covid
The bad kind where there's no return date, unfortunately.Eeks! Out for 10 days kind of covid, or bad?
He was on the bench today so must be okay.The bad kind where there's no return date, unfortunately.
On the benchWhere's he gone?
Yes, I was talking in terms of being 100% match fitHe was on the bench today so must be okay.
That's fair. Hopefully he's okay to start vs Young Boys at leastYes, I was talking in terms of being 100% match fit
If he's got anything about him he will be learning everything he can from Ronaldo and banging Ragnick's door down to get time on the pitch. Ronaldo is here for another 18 months at the absolute maximum. The position is Mason's if he wants it enough.Greenwoord is the real victim of Ronaldo and Sancho joining, where Rashford and Martial remain off the hook coming from the left. Would prefer to play Mason ánd Sancho, but I dont think either of them is suitable to play from the left. Greenwood would be an option as striker, but yeah... Ronaldo..
Defintely.. Not writing him off or anything, he has enough to fight for.. But I was just thinking it's a bit weird for me that our most promising attacker from last season (my opinion) is the one who is affected most from our summer transfers, where Rashford and Martial are still in the same situation when it comes to playing from the left..If he's got anything about him he will be learning everything he can from Ronaldo and banging Ragnick's door down to get time on the pitch. Ronaldo is here for another 18 months at the absolute maximum. The position is Mason's if he wants it enough.
Sancho is absolute fine playing from the Left in fact it might be his best position long term , don't let his early season struggles fool you . Greenwood would have enough opportunities to stake his claim for permanent spot in team its up to him to take the chances.Greenwoord is the real victim of Ronaldo and Sancho joining, where Rashford and Martial remain off the hook coming from the left. Would prefer to play Mason ánd Sancho, but I dont think either of them is suitable to play from the left. Greenwood would be an option as striker, but yeah... Ronaldo..
Yeah I don't see why he would be any worse. He does seem to favour cutting in on his left, but he can do that on his right, plus he can then go on the outside and whip in crosses on his left foot. Also him and Sancho can swap positions during the game. Although I do wonder if the counter-pressing style we are probably about to implement means players have to be more fixed in their positions as they all have strict instructions on how to press as a team.We have never tried him on the left, I’d be up for seeing that too.
I can hardly remember seeing him play there, but it could be me. It would be awesome if he could grab that spot, making room for Greenwood from the right.Sancho is absolute fine playing from the Left in fact it might be his best position long term , don't let his early season struggles fool you . Greenwood would have enough opportunities to stake his claim for permanent spot in team its up to him to take the chances.
It's easy to say learn as a striker but instead of who? He simply is 3rd choice now at best, maybe even 4th behind Martial due to his experience.I've been saying for ages that he cannot learn his trade on the RW.
An elite talented youngster with numbers that were comparable to Rooney and other elite youth talents has been left on the RW consistently out of position. When I said this when he very first broke through I was shot down as apparently the likes of Henry learnt his trade on the wing and it's not an issue... I never bought that, if he's a striker then player him as a striker, you won't learn the trade in this league playing off the wing imo.
Yeah I agree it's not as simple as saying 'don't sign Ronaldo and Cavani and throw Greenwood up top instead.' I get that. But still, the kid imo has to learn his trade in the position he will ultimately play.It's easy to say learn as a striker but instead of who? He simply is 3rd choice now at best, maybe even 4th behind Martial due to his experience.
It wasn't great but stil in 3 PL games Greenwood scored in 2. It looked like this might have been the season for Greenwood - arguably even without players like Sancho or Rashford starting next to him and then the unplanned transfer of Ronaldo came and Greenwood got turned back in to a winger, Sancho had to play LW instead of RW and everything was more clustered up than ever before.
How has he, as a 20 year old not developed? Go on.He hasn't developed as much as he should have by now and our coaches are to blame. I hope Ralf gets him back on track.
I think he's one that can be coached in the dark arts of pressing and tactical fouling so he should do fine.Rangnick might not even think about playing this guy unless his defensive output improves. So who knows if he'll even get a chance to develop, let alone which position.