Maguire had 1 nightmare season and rest of his time here he was probably our best CB (admittedly the bar isn’t high but still)
4
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 9
- Clean sheets
- 5
- Goals
- 1
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 1
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) and Jamie (@Vault Dweller) are here to talk about United's dreadful home defeat at the hands of Big Ange's Tottenham Hotspur. Should this have been the end of Ten Hag? How long does he actually have left? And does Nik finally want ETH out?!
Looks like he has adapted to utd ways quickly..
1 nightmare season and a bunch of bad ones sums it up really nicely for Maguire.
It has begun, a Skysports headline article - https://www.skysports.com/football/...-latest-on-deals-signings-loans-and-contracts
Maybe 1 nightmare season but still had plenty of mistakes in the other seasons as all of our CBs have due to very little midfield cover.
His first season was similar to Martinez.
In fairness, that seems fairly reasonable reporting. Not often a player describes their own defending as “f***ed” after an error in one match and then proceeds to get hauled off at halftime in the next one after giving away a goal, with their manager saying that they were protecting them.
Knifes are out already for the lad, ffs getting fed up with this crap now.
I’ve literally just had this conversation with a friend, it’s absolutely ridiculous how now all of a sudden he’s a meme and laughing stock. This is how it’s going to be now with every error he makes.. and due to being on eggshells, he will make them. Maguire all over again. Playing for United just seems horrible.
More scrutiny than any other club in the world.
I love the caf, but it's become ridiculously toxic in recent times. Players get crapped on relentlessly over every little thing.
It's been decided Zirkzee is shit after......*checks notes *.....making one start for us. Already won us one match, but he had a poor game against Liverpool so that's his career written off.
De ligt has barely kicked a ball for us either, but he made some mistake in an international game so that's all the evidence that's needed - crap player, shite signing.
Ugarte is about the only player left at the club that hasn't been roundly shit on yet, but it'll happen.
The caf is just getting ridiculous, especially after a draw or a defeat. Sometimes I hate this place. What happened to: we stand behind and protect our lads? We did it with Beckham, Cantona and Ronaldo: we stood by them. Why is the modern fanbase so toxic?
I like Maguire and he’s largely underrated but this is complete nonsense. Martinez was levels above and remains so.
have the ones criticizing him even seen his "huge" mistake? its a misplaced pass in a situation where he didnt have ideal passing options and then a lot happens before the goal is scored including some questionable defending from caf darling van dyke... if anything it was 'bout to happen after the statman dave stat posted in here .. so be happy he got the jinx out of the system on internationals and not here.. stop being so negative about everything people ... its really a chore reading the caf nowadays ..
Last edited:
I avoid this place for days after a bad result, it is just relentless wallowing in misery and tearing down anyone who dares to suggest that we might be overreacting. So far as MDL is concerned, I feel bad for him that he had a crappy international break but I honestly don't care about the Netherlands national team. If he plays for us like he has for most of his club career he will do a good job.
A few comments that were made in the period that Zirkzee was on the pitch as a subsitution and before he scored his debut goal against Fullham
So i agree that it is ridiculous to write off players before they even played 10 games but im not suprised that some people already concluded that de Ligt is a crap signing.
Just to be clear, we've never seen this level again, right?
Defensively, Martínez has never been even close to Maguire's levels. His biggest value is what he provides in possession.
Yeah because he is far above him
Yawn... If it is such a struggle to read things, don't bother to. Apart from that, posts like that aren't in any way a better read than the ones slagging off players. It is what it is, whining isn't going to help with that. And if you guys really think, times have changed so much, then I recommend looking into O'shea or Brown threads from years ago.
Just ignore people who want to look knowledgable or strict or whatever by slagging off players. Just like I should do with posts like this from people who like the image of being great fans.
It is obviously idiotic to overreact after one bad scene. Spending time on explaining why thats dumb is only adding energy into something that shouldn't even be there in the first place.
Well he’s been injured. That obviously doesn’t change the fact he’s a class player.
Nonsense but Kneejerk cafe never fails to provide.
He will be fine, honestly the media destroy lads. I may be in the minority but I thought he was good against Liverpool and deserves a few games to cement his place.
I see no point in signing De Ligt or Yoro to keep playing Maguire.
I see no point in signing De Ligt or Yoro to keep playing Maguire.
I swear I read the other day that he hadn't made an error leading to a shot in years...I'm guessing he's been bitten by the United bug too!
He needs a performance to quieten media down
Martinez is not that good tbf, and as injury prone as De Ligt.
Knives out nice and early. Not that it is a surprise, a very difficult club to come into at the moment.
Both Martinez and De Ligt seem to be out of form. They can get a run of games now.
He barely moved here and played less than 90 minutes with us, why would he need "a performance"? The british media will try to destroy any United player, especially if he's foreign. It's up to fans whether to listen to the ridiculous over the board criticism or not. He didn't play that bad, he started the game against Liverpool very well.
It’s social media culture. Everyone’s a keyboard warrior and wants to create memes and get likes. Easy money after a defeat.
I actually don’t mind the caf in the sense of letting fans vent after a bad match, at least it’s more insular, whereas Twitter or whatever is basically advertising criticism of our club to the world for likes etc.
And don’t get me started on the likes of United Stand and United Peoples YouTube with their incredibly clickbait videos.
Martínez has some good defensive qualities, but he's not in the same tier as Maguire. Just the physical superiority of the latter confirms it. Yes, Martínez is often good with his proactivity, has good timing, can improvise very smartly in some situations where his physicality is lacking, but overall defensively? Maguire is streets ahead but that's not a slight on Martínez. And on the ball, it's the other way around.
Are you ok?
Are you sure you've not got the names all mixed up
Yes, Harry Maguire is a significantly better centre half than Lisandro Martínez. It's not even a debate.
It‘s not a debate, Maguire moves like a tractor. Martinez is a better defender and a better passer.
Dutch, German media and Dutch supporters led the criticism after his games against Bosnia and Germany. I know the likes of Scholes, Rio and Souness chimed in with their skeptical takes before De Ligt kicked a ball for united, but what specific examples of over the top criticism from British media after his costly errors in the nation's league are you alluding to?
No white text?
You must be related to Maguire! Seriously though, Martinez is a much better overall player than Maguire. He's a calmer presence at the back, provides a better outlet to move the ball forward and hardly makes errors that Maguire is prone to and that he has been punished for time and time again. That alone makes a huge difference
Agree about United Stand, however would say United People's TV is very different, sure you aren't thinking of Utd View or Forever Utd TV
Enough of us called out his concentration issues before the transfer and that he really isn't an elite defender so this isn't something new. We shouldn't get carried away either with hype or condemnation. I hope he improves tremendously during his time here. Rio had similar issues in his early years with us, too.