Miscellaneous Reserve/Youth News

limerickcitykid

There once was a kid from Toronto...
Joined
Oct 3, 2012
Messages
14,051
Location
East end / Oot and aboot
In recent years and in the near future Chelsea will probably be producing more top flight players than us. Their depth at academy level is ridiculous so their sheer numbers compared to us is way more. While we tend to just focus on a few top talents and then it goes downhill pretty fast after them.
 

Beaucoup

Full Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2016
Messages
1,563
Pretty strange that they have gone out and said that our u13 are very good. Usually the media doesn't report much about the u15(rightly so)
I don't think Senior is associated with the club anymore, doubt the academy will be happy with this.
 

Based Adnan

Full Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2014
Messages
4,063
Mate, I've followed the academy closely for 20 years. I've seen hundreds of young players develop. By playing against the best in the world you literally just mean the same tournaments we've all followed them in.

I have no idea who you are. If you have an argument, make an argument. Claiming some sort of knowledge authority is not an argument.
The guy you're debating with is actually a youth scout in Holland for a Premier League club. Not gonna say what club because I'm sure he will if he wanted to but yeah
 

SteveW

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2013
Messages
7,194
The guy you're debating with is actually a youth scout in Holland for a Premier League club. Not gonna say what club because I'm sure he will if he wanted to but yeah
Cool, thanks for the info. I guess that explains why he was so upset about my not seeing Chong as good enough for the first team. (he isn't)

It also explained his weird comment that you need to have watched youth football around the world to have a valid opinion. It's still a ridiculous comment but it at least explains why he wanted to pull things in that direction. So that he could claim default correctness without having to make an argument.

I actually read through some of the guys old posts at the time to figure out why held held such a high opinion of himself. It certainly wasn't due to his ability to predict which players would make the first team at united. :lol:

Either way, thanks for the info.
 

SteveW

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2013
Messages
7,194
I'll respond to you then. It is an argument that you need to have seen academy football to have an opinion on which academy generally make it in the game because how else would you have a clue, watch one game of a lad at U23 level and then give your opinion? I know many people both at the club and at other clubs who highly rate Chong and agree with me that he is definitely good enough for the first team.

Give me my old post then on my ability to predict who will make it in the game that weren't correct because other people certainly do rate me on my opinion on that topic but I'll take my losses. I do know that when I saw James Garner at 14 years old, I messaged a few people on saying that I rate him highly, same goes for Mengi and Greenwood who I saw at 13 at the same tournament.
Great let's chat. Who said I hadn't seen academy football? I said I hadn't seen it around the world. Why is that a prerequisite for an opinion? Barring scouts, who even travels the world watching youth football? Are you suggesting youth scouts who travel the world are the only people who can watch a game and tell which players are better than others? Are you saying people can't look at a 16,17, 18 year old and make an assessment on how good they become based on their visible attributes and performances in games. That's daft.

Without wanting to justify myself yet feeling I have to I can honestly say I've very rarely been wrong over the years when it's come to figuring out with U18s and reserves will actually make it or at least have a chance. Ravel, Januzaj and McTomminay are probably the only ones who have genuinely surprised me in how they've turned out. I've generally been able to tell closely enough what league pretty much every player who has been good enough for me to watch closely would end up playing in. There's probably loads of posts on here of me saying players like Josh King would end up in the premier league or which of the Keane brothers would be the better player or how much little Jesse Lingard might surprise people if he gets a bit bigger etc. You'd see much fewer posts from me about the Daehlis or Eikrems for example. And none about Aidan Barlow who would be knocking on the first team door at this stage according to you.

My point is not about any individual players though. It's that you don't have to travel around watching youth tournaments to make these distinctions. So it's a daft way to try and shut down an argument. I'd much rather have an honest respectful discussion than be talked down to by someone who doesn't know anything about me. So with that said, how about you tell me what about that post you responded to proves I know nothing about football. I responded to a poster who was wondering why none of the kids had made any real measurable impact on the first team. By the sound of things he'd been led to believe they were all ready to take the first team by storm and improve the team. I've been less optimistic about their ability to make a huge difference right now for various reasons.

I said Chong was a very average footballer. In terms of being a senior United player (which is the exact context we were speaking in) right now he is a very average footballer. Do I think he's a decent U19 player? Yes. He's got some interesting attributes. He's got lovely pace, balance and energy, he's really direct, he can see a pass when he calms himself down a bit. He's one of the players I've watched with interest since he came back from his injury and I was impressed with how he recovered and pushed himself on from it. But right now he clearly has some weaknesses that need to improve before he'll be someone who will be useful in the first team. He needs to get stronger and calm down a lot. I predicted several times on here when people were clamouring for him to start in the first team that if he did play they could expect him to run into trouble a lot, lose the ball consistently, make bad decisions and get bullied by stronger players. That's generally exactly what's happened and exactly what would happen again if he was picked for the next game against Watford. Because right now his game isn't really ready to play at that level. Right now when it comes to the standards required for first team football Chong is a very average player. If he was 25 people would be comparing him with Obertan. However he's a 19 year old who lost a year to injury and still needs to fill out so we will reserve judgement on his future for now. The next couple of years will tell a lot. I believe I'm spot on when it comes to his present level though.

I didn't even really comment on Gomes. I said Garner is a 17 year old kid who only played 3 minutes. That's true. Is there something wrong about stating a fact?

As for Mason I said he merits the hype. Do you disagree with that also?
 
Last edited:

KM

I’m afraid I just blue myself
Joined
Sep 18, 2008
Messages
49,718
@khoazany when can we expect your thread for academy squad for next season?
 

kundalini

Full Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2004
Messages
5,750
I have some questions regarding contracts:

- Has Bernard signed a professional deal with United ? I can't find any announcement but perhaps I haven't been looking in the right place. The fact that he is getting starts at U23 level suggests that he must have.

- When United announce that a non-star type player such as Tanner, McGhee, Mellor, Galbraith etc has signed their first professional contract, how many years will that deal tend to be for ?

- Do any of Buffonge, Warren, Olosunde, Whelan, Sang, Dearnley, Gribbin, Hamilton, Willock, Bohui have contracts that last beyond this summer ? I know United have +1 year options on James Wilson and Regan Poole, should they wish to keep them.

- I seem to recall that Indy Boonen, Whelan, Hamilton and Dearnley all had offers from United around May/June time last year. Are there any current players aged 19 (or about to turn 19) whose deals end this summer ? I suppose this question is related to my earlier 2nd question.

Thanks in advance.
 
Last edited:

lysglimt

Full Member
Scout
Joined
Jun 1, 2008
Messages
15,109
Great let's chat. Who said I hadn't seen academy football? I said I hadn't seen it around the world. Why is that a prerequisite for an opinion? Barring scouts, who even travels the world watching youth football? Are you suggesting youth scouts who travel the world are the only people who can watch a game and tell which players are better than others? Are you saying people can't look at a 16,17, 18 year old and make an assessment on how good they become based on their visible attributes and performances in games. That's daft.

Without wanting to justify myself yet feeling I have to I can honestly say I've very rarely been wrong over the years when it's come to figuring out with U18s and reserves will actually make it or at least have a chance. Ravel, Januzaj and McTomminay are probably the only ones who have genuinely surprised me in how they've turned out. I've generally been able to tell closely enough what league pretty much every player who has been good enough for me to watch closely would end up playing in. There's probably loads of posts on here of me saying players like Josh King would end up in the premier league or which of the Keane brothers would be the better player or how much little Jesse Lingard might surprise people if he gets a bit bigger etc. You'd see much fewer posts from me about the Daehlis or Eikrems for example. And none about Aidan Barlow who would be knocking on the first team door at this stage according to you.

My point is not about any individual players though. It's that you don't have to travel around watching youth tournaments to make these distinctions. So it's a daft way to try and shut down an argument. I'd much rather have an honest respectful discussion than be talked down to by someone who doesn't know anything about me. So with that said, how about you tell me what about that post you responded to proves I know nothing about football. I responded to a poster who was wondering why none of the kids had made any real measurable impact on the first team. By the sound of things he'd been led to believe they were all ready to take the first team by storm and improve the team. I've been less optimistic about their ability to make a huge difference right now for various reasons.

I said Chong was a very average footballer. In terms of being a senior United player (which is the exact context we were speaking in) right now he is a very average footballer. Do I think he's a decent U19 player? Yes. He's got some interesting attributes. He's got lovely pace, balance and energy, he's really direct, he can see a pass when he calms himself down a bit. He's one of the players I've watched with interest since he came back from his injury and I was impressed with how he recovered and pushed himself on from it. But right now he clearly has some weaknesses that need to improve before he'll be someone who will be useful in the first team. He needs to get stronger and calm down a lot. I predicted several times on here when people were clamouring for him to start in the first team that if he did play they could expect him to run into trouble a lot, lose the ball consistently, make bad decisions and get bullied by stronger players. That's generally exactly what's happened and exactly what would happen again if he was picked for the next game against Watford. Because right now his game isn't really ready to play at that level. Right now when it comes to the standards required for first team football Chong is a very average player. If he was 25 people would be comparing him with Obertan. However he's a 19 year old who lost a year to injury and still needs to fill out so we will reserve judgement on his future for now. The next couple of years will tell a lot. I believe I'm spot on when it comes to his present level though.

I didn't even really comment on Gomes. I said Garner is a 17 year old kid who only played 3 minutes. That's true. Is there something wrong about stating a fact?

As for Mason I said he merits the hype. Do you disagree with that also?
Pretty much agree with you

Greenwood and Garner look mature in the way they play football - Gomes and especially Chong, don't. But they are all very talented and every one of them could go on to be regulars in the P.L. But at the moment, I rate Garner and Greenwood at least one level ahead of the other 2
 

SteveW

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2013
Messages
7,194
Pretty much agree with you

Greenwood and Garner look mature in the way they play football - Gomes and especially Chong, don't. But they are all very talented and every one of them could go on to be regulars in the P.L. But at the moment, I rate Garner and Greenwood at least one level ahead of the other 2
Gomes is such a hard one to nail down. Loads of nice little touches, reverse passes etc. He's very entertaining to watch when on his game. There's clearly bags of talent there but he doesnt impose himself enough on games. His lack of size or speed is an issue despite what people would have you think. His game isnt expansive either, he seems to lack the natural power to pass it over longer ranges or to shoot effectively at senior level. I cant even figure out what a good loan for him would be. Couldn't see a PL team feeling hes worth the risk.

My hope for Chong is that as he gets stronger some of the rough edges come off his game. Being able to hold players off and have better control of his body might make him more effective. His pace and balance are great attributes. If forced to bet on it I'd say he wont make it here though.

I like Garner but need to see more of him. Greenwood is a baller and will make it here.
 

limerickcitykid

There once was a kid from Toronto...
Joined
Oct 3, 2012
Messages
14,051
Location
East end / Oot and aboot
Another lad we released was banging them in for the u18/23s of Blackburn or Burnley or something in the past couple years. What was his name again? Wonder if he ended up breaking through at whatever club it was.
 

AltiUn

likes playing with swords after fantasies
Joined
Apr 29, 2014
Messages
23,494
Another lad we released was banging them in for the u18/23s of Blackburn or Burnley or something in the past couple years. What was his name again? Wonder if he ended up breaking through at whatever club it was.
Possibly Ben Brereton? He gained a reputation for himself over the last couple of seasons, he played for us briefly and is currently at Blackburn having previously played for Forest.
 

cj_sparky

Full Member
Joined
May 15, 2008
Messages
8,124
Another lad we released was banging them in for the u18/23s of Blackburn or Burnley or something in the past couple years. What was his name again? Wonder if he ended up breaking through at whatever club it was.
Dwight McNeil, 16 appearances for Burnley this year scoring 3 goals.
 

Class of 63

Sourness
Joined
Aug 15, 2017
Messages
9,028
Location
Going through the Desert on a Horse with no Name
The guy named after Zidane is probably more proud than the guy who was named after Ameobi :)
And probably less embarrassed as well, it may well be unisex but until he came on the scene in the early noughties I'd always thought of Shola as being a girls name, maybe he should have stuck with Foluwashola Ameobi just to be on the safe side.
 

NickyT

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jul 7, 2015
Messages
106
The guy named after Zidane is probably more proud than the guy who was named after Ameobi :)
I think Shola means 'The Blessed One' and the way he's been progressing this season, he's living up to it, so fingers crossed he keeps pushing all the way up to the first team.
 

James0911

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Apr 11, 2019
Messages
1
Supports
Leicester City
A United scout watched Leicester U18s vs Brighton U18s recently. A few gems on both sides, including Leicester's Terell Pennant. He's a regular in the U18s despite still being an U16. He's the nephew of former Liverpool winger, Jermaine. Could be one to keep a close eye on in the future. Terell has previously been linked with a move to Arsenal so I wouldn't be surprised if United were also interested.

More info here: https://foxeshub.com/manchester-united-scout-watches-leicester-under-18s/
 

jb8521

Full Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2007
Messages
4,526
Some of next years intake for the 18s, can anybody put names to faces, Dodgson is there(front left), and i'd imagine that its Zidane Iqbal(centre), other that that i'd be guessing....

From the left it's Owen Dodgson, Charlie Savage, Calen Gallagher-Allison, Dermot Mee, Zidan Iqbal, Will Fish, Charlie Wellens, Alfie Hughes, Iestyn Hughes. As far as I know Mipo Odubeko, Deji Sotona, Martin Svidersky & Noam Emeran have scholarships as well but not there for some reason
 

Class of 63

Sourness
Joined
Aug 15, 2017
Messages
9,028
Location
Going through the Desert on a Horse with no Name
From the left it's Owen Dodgson, Charlie Savage, Calen Gallagher-Allison, Dermot Mee, Zidan Iqbal, Will Fish, Charlie Wellens, Alfie Hughes, Iestyn Hughes. As far as I know Mipo Odubeko, Deji Sotona, Martin Svidersky & Noam Emeran have scholarships as well but not there for some reason
Cheers @jb8521, I knew you wouldn't let me down.
 

AltiUn

likes playing with swords after fantasies
Joined
Apr 29, 2014
Messages
23,494
Not sure if this belongs in here, Nicky Butt's been arrested today on suspicion of assault.

 

TwoSheds

More sheds (and tiles) than you, probably
Joined
Feb 12, 2014
Messages
12,741
Well that is sad. Hope his family are alright.
 

AltiUn

likes playing with swords after fantasies
Joined
Apr 29, 2014
Messages
23,494

First year scholars for next season, from what I can gather the ones to watch are Charlie Savage (who I think is Robbie Savage's son), Deji Sotona, Mipo Odubeko, Martin Svidersky and there was quite a bit of hype around Noam Emeran when we first signed him. If anyone's got some insight on any of them it'd be good to hear.
 

khoazany

Full Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2012
Messages
6,502
Location
Singapore

First year scholars for next season, from what I can gather the ones to watch are Charlie Savage (who I think is Robbie Savage's son), Deji Sotona, Mipo Odubeko, Martin Svidersky and there was quite a bit of hype around Noam Emeran when we first signed him. If anyone's got some insight on any of them it'd be good to hear.
Iestyn Hughes and Will Fish are the picks of defenders, although the other 2 are also good.
 

JJ12

Predicted Portugal, Italy to win Euro 2016, 2020
Joined
Mar 30, 2016
Messages
10,841
Location
Wales
I thought there was a lot of fuss around Shoretire? Or isn't he eligible for scholarship
 

Beaucoup

Full Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2016
Messages
1,563

First year scholars for next season, from what I can gather the ones to watch are Charlie Savage (who I think is Robbie Savage's son), Deji Sotona, Mipo Odubeko, Martin Svidersky and there was quite a bit of hype around Noam Emeran when we first signed him. If anyone's got some insight on any of them it'd be good to hear.
Emeran apart (I've not seen him play), that's a pretty uninspiring group of players for a club of our stature.
 

Adnan

Talent Spotter
Joined
Oct 5, 2013
Messages
29,865
Location
England

First year scholars for next season, from what I can gather the ones to watch are Charlie Savage (who I think is Robbie Savage's son), Deji Sotona, Mipo Odubeko, Martin Svidersky and there was quite a bit of hype around Noam Emeran when we first signed him. If anyone's got some insight on any of them it'd be good to hear.
Emeran was using the aid of crutches last I heard from Jb.