Next Manager Poll

Who should manage us next?


  • Total voters
    1,923
CM, DM, LWB and I would presume backup ST, do we know if Ancelotti even wants to leave after World Cup
Anderson/Wharton/LWB (or even RWB imo..)/Thiago (instead of Zirzkee). Thiago and Sesko as our striking options would not be bad at all, would it? In terms of midfield, if we can get those two, we're sorted for a decade with Casemiro, also, on a reduced wage (and Maino) ensuring good competition and rotation options. The LWB is an interesting one. I would have said RWB (or RB who can go forward, more than anything) is the issue.

But the thing is, and people neglect it, we need that above quality in said positions regardless of which manager comes in next. Everyone knows it, and with that kind of quality I outline above, even if we can't get or or two of them and switch it out, we really are looking like a title challenging club. We're really not that far off. Squad depth, lack thereof, and some instant improvements in key areas, plus a world class manager, is all that's holding us back here.
 
I might go
1. Tuchel or Ancelotti



.....
2. Iraola, Poch, or Glasner.
I like Tuchel, but he irritates me a bit too. Nonetheless, I don't doubt his quality. With Ancelotti, I think he's among the greatest managers alive.

Within this tier, you also have Enrique and controversially for some I'd add Emery.

Now of those four, it would be Carlo/Enrique/Emery for me and in terms who can realistically be got, Carlo stands out.

To go from that caliber to the other names would feel like a kick in the teeth to me. Poch ain't up to it, Glasner has zero place at this club, and so on and on.

Moreover, you get Carlo/Enrique in, and players just want to fecking play for them. Serial winners and reputations which everyone respects. They are assuaged of the direction of the club and given our targets this summer, this counts a lot. We really ought to be tapping these people up now if we're not on it already and have it ready to announce when we try transfer dealing qua players and agents.
 
If we're going Italian, I'd prefer Conte to Ancelotti. Both are proven winners, but I'd say Conte has a habit of taking sleeping giants to the top -- Juve in his first stint, Inter, Napoli, even Chelsea to an extent. He's hungry, a workaholic and won't put up with nonsense from players or club. He can certainly steady the ship.

I think Ancelotti is great, without a doubt, but I have a feeling if he were to manage us it'd be more Everton than Madrid in terms of success. Just my 2 cents
 
Conte or Tuchel would have a heart attack at United within a month. Just not a good idea
 
Outstanding that Southgate has 8 votes. Its 8 more i expected but thankfully, a very rare anomaly at the bottom.

Conte, tuchel and ancelotti are possibly the safe options. Not for me personally. Ancelotti is a stabiliser but not forward thinking. He would do a great job, the football would be okay. Conte is always a no thanks for me, I despise 3 at back. Tuchel, well, would need time. Could be incredible but at same time, could be a total flop. Huge risk in my eyes.

Maresca would be am easy option but I feel unsure about the fact he spoke with city during his time at Chelsea. Otherwise, I would have him in from now. My number one choice is Mckenna, something draws me to him.he knows the club, has a few years of management under his belt now, is a United fan. The thing I like most, he is a coach and his foundation is getting the best out of what he has. At United he will have money and I just feel that could spur him on. He comes across calm and structured, no drama. I would also love a Brit here.

I would steer clear of Emery, not sure United structure is for him and im not a fan of his style, he gets results though. Luis Enrique is a great manager, but the pass pass pass, its not for me. Second for me would be Glasner under the assumption he comes in and plays 4 at the back, which I believe is his preferred way.

Either way, I think Amorim could have been a mini success but his temperament gave the impression he was above the club. We need a humble, strong, assertive guy, who can coach and manage through a bit of mess.
 
I like Tuchel, but he irritates me a bit too. Nonetheless, I don't doubt his quality. With Ancelotti, I think he's among the greatest managers alive.

Within this tier, you also have Enrique and controversially for some I'd add Emery.

Now of those four, it would be Carlo/Enrique/Emery for me and in terms who can realistically be got, Carlo stands out.

To go from that caliber to the other names would feel like a kick in the teeth to me. Poch ain't up to it, Glasner has zero place at this club, and so on and on.

Moreover, you get Carlo/Enrique in, and players just want to fecking play for them. Serial winners and reputations which everyone respects. They are assuaged of the direction of the club and given our targets this summer, this counts a lot. We really ought to be tapping these people up now if we're not on it already and have it ready to announce when we try transfer dealing qua players and agents.
Yeah, Tuchel is a bit of a cnut, but I think he's better than most other realistic options.

I listed only Tuchel and Ancelotti as they can come here for free (and that was the premise in the post I quoted). I'd probably prefer Enrique over them, and Emery is a good option too, but I think they are both unrealistic.
 
Then why wait until summer? Go get him now if that is who they want. Doesn't make sense. Think they want a WC manager.
1. They may be afraid of running into the same narrative as the Amorim case/excuses of not getting a full pre-season etc. 2. They are probably even more penny-pinching than we think or our finances are really so bad that we "need" to wait.

But I really hope you're right as I would have no faith in Glasner.
 
I think

Tuchel
Pochettino
McKenna

Might be a final 3. I want Nagelsmann but if its true they want Prem experience it rules him out. Enrique is not coming here even if he was leaving. Glasner is awful, and plays negative football why would the club even entertain this guy.
 
I'm not sold with Fletcher as the caretaker till the end of the season. Defensive set up is EXTREMELY shakey.
 
Bring in the caretaker already.

We need some organisation in this team.

Carrick might be able to get us to keep a clean sheet.
 
Theres absolutely no way it will happen.

We cannot afford to give someone with zero experience the reins again. It would be mental.
I wouldn't mind the idea of Enzo Maresca till the end of the season, then re-assess from there.
 
He probably doesn’t want to tank his reputation like Amorim did over the next 5 months probably.
Hes tanking his reputation going out of the cup to a non league side and having a really poor league campaign with palace
 
1. They may be afraid of running into the same narrative as the Amorim case/excuses of not getting a full pre-season etc. 2. They are probably even more penny-pinching than we think or our finances are really so bad that we "need" to wait.

But I really hope you're right as I would have no faith in Glasner.
I think that would be more specific to the manager. If there's someone who thinks he could get a tune out of the current set of players in a short time frame, then you have to have a look at that. Even Carragher commented that he thinks there's probably a few managers who probably think they could get a tune out of these players.

What happened about Glasner, a few months ago, many here were saying they love him here?
 
Why do you think its vital when the leagues most successful managers came in with zero pl experience- Pep,Klopp,Jose, Arsene, Conte. Sir Alex hadn't manged in England. Even your pick Tuchel came to Chelsea with no pl experience
Because we can't afford that freedom anymore, we need someone to steady the ship and having PL experience is a massive bonus that we e can't ignore.
 
I’m sorry but everyone that keeps mentioning experience.. have a look at Brighton’s manager. 32 years old, got them playing good football.
 
Sure as shit isn’t going to be fletcher what the fecking hell is he thinking
Yoro short of confidence, heaven full. So starts yoro
Ugarte having a poor season, casemiro having a good season, so plays Ugarte
Just stupid decisions
 
I think an interim appointment, regardless to who we bring, is absolutely going to wreck our season.

We really need a good manager who can get the best out of this group, and I have serious doubts that they're going to put much effort for someone who's leaving soon.
 
I think an interim appointment, regardless to who we bring, is absolutely going to wreck our season.

We really need a good manager who can get the best out of this group, and I have serious doubts that they're going to put much effort for someone who's leaving soon.
The problem is that this group has no effort aside from a few.
 
I’m sorry but everyone that keeps mentioning experience.. have a look at Brighton’s manager. 32 years old, got them playing good football.
He may be 32, but he has a decade of coaching experience behind him already. One of those weirdos like Mourinho who always wanted to be a manager rather than a player.
 
I don't know who but let's take forever like this caretaker shit. Maybe just wait until next season is about to start. Shit let's wait past that.
 
He may be 32, but he has a decade of coaching experience behind him already. One of those weirdos like Mourinho who always wanted to be a manager rather than a player.
So as everyone we’ve had after Fergie. This job is far more than just experience…. You need to have guts and be tactically flexible
 
I'm going to say something and then probably get a load of stick.

I think Gareth Southgate might be the best option for interim. Solid, unspectacular. Never won anything with England but they didn't embarrass themselves either.

Then get Enrique in the summer.
 
I'm going to say something and then probably get a load of stick.

I think Gareth Southgate might be the best option for interim. Solid, unspectacular. Never won anything with England but they didn't embarrass themselves either.

Then get Enrique in the summer.

He wouldn't take it but he'd be better than the united lads obviously.
 
We better do everything we can to get either Tuchel or Conte. I am fecking done with the "talented" may be good enough managers. We need someone to sort us out defensively.
 
I'm going to say something and then probably get a load of stick.

I think Gareth Southgate might be the best option for interim. Solid, unspectacular. Never won anything with England but they didn't embarrass themselves either.

Then get Enrique in the summer.
I said the same a while back about Southgate.

I think he'd be a decent choice to see us through a transitional period and get us back to basics
 
I'm going to say something and then probably get a load of stick.

I think Gareth Southgate might be the best option for interim. Solid, unspectacular. Never won anything with England but they didn't embarrass themselves either.

Then get Enrique in the summer.

Ia actually agree. And if we cant get Enrique get Tuchel or Conte. Don't think Southgate would join for a mere interim job though
 
Best option is probably Conte for the short term if we want to turn things around quickly