Ole Gunnar Solskjær | Permanent manager

Majima

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
2,151
Location
Kami's Lookout
No, Moyes was our hodgson. Dalglish was Liverpool legend who took over, produced some very good football in half a season and then in the full season it was shit. Same with Ole, played some very good football in initial 2-3 months and in the full season it was shit.

There was no reason for Liverpool fans to stay loyal to Hodgson, juts like ManUtd fans didn't have for Moyes. Even when Dalglish was shit, Liverpool fans wanted him out but respected for what he achieved as a player and manager before, same with Ole. Fans want him out but he is respected for what he achieved as a player.

Comparing Liveprool fans treatment to Hodgson to ManUtd with Ole doesn't make sense considering Hodgson contributed feck all to Liverpool history.
I am not insulting towards Solskjaer but i don't blame people who are because of the situation right now. I hold no sentimentality towards his past achievements as a player. Precisely because he is the manager right now. The only thing i care about is his managerial performances.

Whilst he is manager, who really cares what he achieved as a player? All i care about right now is that he's got us in our worst position since SAF retired. A few weeks back we were 16th! We're now 10th 10 points behind top 4 after 11 games already. By definition of results, he is our worst manager since SAF. None of the previous managers had us this low. Not even Moyes. So how is Solskjaer not our Hodgson?

I posted Dalglish's results. You call him shit in the full season, but he won their first trophy for 6 years and narrowly lost another in the same season he left. I know i would happily take those 'shit' results right now.
 

roonster09

Correctly predicted France to win World Cup 2018
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
20,828
You misunderstand. I am not insulting towards Solskjaer but i hold no sentimentality towards his past achievements as a player. Precisely because he is the manager right now. The only thing i care about is his managerial performances.

Whilst he is manager, who really cares what he achieved as a player? All i care about right now is that he's got us in our worst position since SAF retired. A few weeks back we were 16th! We're now 10th 10 points behind top 4 after 11 games already. By definition of results, he is our worst manager since SAF. None of the previous managers had us this low. Not even Moyes. So how is Solskjaer not our Hodgson?

I posted Dalglish's results. You call him shit in the full season, but he won their first trophy for 6 years and narrowly lost another in the same season he left. I know i would happily take those 'shit' results right now.
I'm comparing the individuals legacy as that was the discussion and the reply was to this point "Let me ask you, did Liverpool fans love Roy Hodgson when he was sinking them down into the abyss?"

It wasn't a valid comparison. Liverpool fans didn't love Hodgson just like ManUtd fans didn't love Moyes. There was no history between these managers and club. When it comes to Dalglish and Solskjaer, there is plenty of history.

What you are talking about is completely different argument and going by the records, Dalglish is by far the better manager than Ole.
 

Ancient Of Days

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 4, 2019
Messages
188
I think Ole identified both as bad apples and was keen to get them out. Though I appreciate the argument that he should have been able to bring them back in from the cold once it was clear we weren't getting replacements I can also appreciate that I don't know how bad the dressing room was nor do I know the intricacies of their situations this summer. I'd be surprised if Ole had carte blanche to cancel those deals whenever he liked and I doubt whether he'd have been minded to have two disgruntled players return to his squad after they'd hoped to be at Inter.

Ole is not absolved of blame by any means but in my view the situation was more complex than a naive manager making a misjudgement, I think he was between a rock and a hard place.
There's this myth peddled that Lukaku and Sanchez were bad apples.

On what basis? Lukaku had weight issues and was subsequently kicked out of the club.

Doesn't Shaw battle with weight issues and have bigger problems performing consistently? What's the difference?

Didn't Lukaku help land Ole the job by scoring twice in the famous PSG victory?

He scored in 3 games in row. 2 goals against Palace, 2 goals against Southampton and 2 goals against PSG.

After PSG we played against arsenal and he didn't perform and was promptly dropped and Ole made it clear Rashford was his favorite and that's when Lukuku and his agent started releasing stories about his desire to move to Italy.

Rashford knew he was no 1 and his place was secure hence the Gold Rashy chain he treated himself to shortly after Lukaku got marginalized


Sanchez himself didn't start to badly under Ole either scoring in the 3-1 win against Arsenal. Then was dropped in favor of Lingard who was given umpteenth amount of chances to prove himself even when doing nothing but being a passenger on the field.

It had to take a huge fans backlash during pre season and the start of this season for Jesse to be dropped and that was partly due to his off the field clownery

Yet you can be damn sure Ole is in no rush to kick him out of the club like he did with Lukaku or Sanchez

Sanchez during his time here was always hard working and a model professional. In the media the only time you'd see his social media is when he was posting videos of him working out in the gym or showing off pictures of his dog.

So ask where this this stuff about these two players being bad apples come from?
 

roonster09

Correctly predicted France to win World Cup 2018
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
20,828
There's this myth peddled that Lukaku and Sanchez were bad apples.

On what basis? Lukaku had weight issues and was subsequently kicked out of the club.

Doesn't Shaw battle with weight issues and have bigger problems performing consistently? What's the difference?

Didn't Lukaku help land Ole the job by scoring twice in the famous PSG victory?

He scored in 3 games in row. 2 goals against Palace, 2 goals against Southampton and 2 goals against PSG.

After PSG we played against arsenal and he didn't perform and was promptly dropped and Ole made it clear Rashford was his favorite and that's when Lukuku and his agent started releasing stories about his desire to move to Italy.

Rashford knew he was no 1 and his place was secure hence the Gold Rashy chain he treated himself to shortly after Lukaku got marginalized



Sanchez himself didn't start to badly under Ole either scoring in the 3-1 win against Arsenal. Then was dropped in favor of Lingard who was given umpteenth amount of chances to prove himself even when doing nothing but being a passenger on the field.

It had to take a huge fans backlash during pre season and the start of this season for Jesse to be dropped and that was partly due to his off the field clownery

Yet you can be damn sure Ole is in no rush to kick him out of the club like he did with Lukaku or Sanchez

Sanchez during his time here was always hard working and a model professional. In the media the only time you'd see his social media is when he was posting videos of him working out in the gym or showing off pictures of his dog.

So ask where this this stuff about these two players being bad apples come from?
:lol:

Lukaku was injured in that PSG match and then made it worse in the Arsenal game.

Lukaku injured a foot during United’s Champions League win over Paris St-Germain and aggravated the problem in last Sunday’s 2-0 defeat at Arsenal. He has been receiving treatment all week and will be assessed again on Friday but seems unlikely to play at this stage. Although Lukaku will be expected to report for international duty with Belgium on Sunday for further assessment, he is a doubt for the games against Russia and Cyprus.

Lingard and Herrera have been out since being substituted with hamstring injuries in the 0-0 draw against Liverpool on Feb 24 but both have returned to training. Herrera has more of a chance of being involved against Wolves than Lingard but Solskjaer wants to assess the likely match fitness of both.
 

AneRu

Full Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2019
Messages
649
There's this myth peddled that Lukaku and Sanchez were bad apples.

On what basis? Lukaku had weight issues and was subsequently kicked out of the club.

Doesn't Shaw battle with weight issues and have bigger problems performing consistently? What's the difference?

Didn't Lukaku help land Ole the job by scoring twice in the famous PSG victory?

He scored in 3 games in row. 2 goals against Palace, 2 goals against Southampton and 2 goals against PSG.

After PSG we played against arsenal and he didn't perform and was promptly dropped and Ole made it clear Rashford was his favorite and that's when Lukuku and his agent started releasing stories about his desire to move to Italy.

Rashford knew he was no 1 and his place was secure hence the Gold Rashy chain he treated himself to shortly after Lukaku got marginalized


Sanchez himself didn't start to badly under Ole either scoring in the 3-1 win against Arsenal. Then was dropped in favor of Lingard who was given umpteenth amount of chances to prove himself even when doing nothing but being a passenger on the field.

It had to take a huge fans backlash during pre season and the start of this season for Jesse to be dropped and that was partly due to his off the field clownery

Yet you can be damn sure Ole is in no rush to kick him out of the club like he did with Lukaku or Sanchez

Sanchez during his time here was always hard working and a model professional. In the media the only time you'd see his social media is when he was posting videos of him working out in the gym or showing off pictures of his dog.

So ask where this this stuff about these two players being bad apples come from?
People will believe anything just to avoid facing the uncomfortable truth that our beloved legend simply isn't good enough and that the club has made another big, expensive mistake.
 

VP89

Pogba's biggest fan
Joined
Dec 6, 2015
Messages
13,131
There's this myth peddled that Lukaku and Sanchez were bad apples.

On what basis? Lukaku had weight issues and was subsequently kicked out of the club.

Doesn't Shaw battle with weight issues and have bigger problems performing consistently? What's the difference?

Didn't Lukaku help land Ole the job by scoring twice in the famous PSG victory?

He scored in 3 games in row. 2 goals against Palace, 2 goals against Southampton and 2 goals against PSG.

After PSG we played against arsenal and he didn't perform and was promptly dropped and Ole made it clear Rashford was his favorite and that's when Lukuku and his agent started releasing stories about his desire to move to Italy.

Rashford knew he was no 1 and his place was secure hence the Gold Rashy chain he treated himself to shortly after Lukaku got marginalized


Sanchez himself didn't start to badly under Ole either scoring in the 3-1 win against Arsenal. Then was dropped in favor of Lingard who was given umpteenth amount of chances to prove himself even when doing nothing but being a passenger on the field.

It had to take a huge fans backlash during pre season and the start of this season for Jesse to be dropped and that was partly due to his off the field clownery

Yet you can be damn sure Ole is in no rush to kick him out of the club like he did with Lukaku or Sanchez

Sanchez during his time here was always hard working and a model professional. In the media the only time you'd see his social media is when he was posting videos of him working out in the gym or showing off pictures of his dog.

So ask where this this stuff about these two players being bad apples come from?

Sanchez was not a bad apple in my opinion. All reports suggested he trained hard and had a good work ethic.

Lukaku was a bad apple. Its not just the weight issues. He flirted with Serie A long before he left openly while contracted to us. Then he name dropped Conte and went on to publish confidential fitness info on his peers using social media.

He was completely a bad apple. It doesn't matter how many he scores or how over critical we were of his performances. That type of professionalism has no place in our club.
 

roonster09

Correctly predicted France to win World Cup 2018
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
20,828
Sanchez was not a bad apple in my opinion. All reports suggested he trained hard and had a good work ethic.

Lukaku was a bad apple. Its not just the weight issues. He flirted with Serie A long before he left openly while contracted to us. Then he name dropped Conte and went on to publish confidential fitness info on his peers using social media.

He was completely a bad apple. It doesn't matter how many he scores or how over critical we were of his performances. That type of professionalism has no place in our club.
Everyone is a good apple when they play every game no matter how shit they are, all the talk about being the soldier and all that nonsense. When they are not guaranteed starting spot, then you see their real professionalism.

Not talking about Sanchez btw, I barely remember him as ManUtd player.
 

Amir

Full Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2000
Messages
22,189
Location
Rehovot, Israel
A smarter manager keeps Lukaku onside until he knows he no longer needs him, like Fergie
Exactly, it seems like Solskjaer alienated Lukaku very early on, making his sale inevitable. There was no way we could have just decided during the summer to keep him.
 

Majima

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
2,151
Location
Kami's Lookout
I'm comparing the individuals legacy as that was the discussion and the reply was to this point "Let me ask you, did Liverpool fans love Roy Hodgson when he was sinking them down into the abyss?"

It wasn't a valid comparison. Liverpool fans didn't love Hodgson just like ManUtd fans didn't love Moyes. There was no history between these managers and club. When it comes to Dalglish and Solskjaer, there is plenty of history.

What you are talking about is completely different argument and going by the records, Dalglish is by far the better manager than Ole.
I understand your argument but it's something i absolutely detest about football. Sentimentality & nepotism is by far the worst traits i hate in football management. Seeing someone failing over and over again, whilst you suffer, but being afraid of telling the truth and calling it out are things i wish didn't exist.

With the results right now, of course people are going to be angry, when they see him with a smile on his face in press-conferences, with the current captain Young spouting '"it's like having the boss back"!, when if we sink any lower we will be in a relegation battle.

Can they be any more detached from reality? It just shows a loser's mentality and gives the impression they don't care about the fans suffering. That might not be true but it's what it comes across as.

No but they still loved Dalglish when he looked out of his depth, saying he should move on but were respectful to their legend.
My original reply was based on this not being a totally accurate comparison also. Dalglish produced good results at the time, like you agree, so the fans had no reason not to be respectful towards him. Surely you can't expect all the fans to treat Solksjaer the same way with the results he is producing right now?
 
Last edited:

Amir

Full Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2000
Messages
22,189
Location
Rehovot, Israel
Sanchez's loan is entirely on Ole. Glazers have nothing to gain from Sanchez deal as there is no fee and we are still paying 50% of his wages. Its not a significant saving for them anyway. It was just sheer stupidity from Ole after the window had closed.
Did Sanchez have something to offer, though, based in his 18 months with the club?

There was talk of dressing room unrest caused by Sanchez's arrived. Maybe Solskjaer looked at that and his performances and thought there would be no value in keeping him.
 

Ancient Of Days

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 4, 2019
Messages
188
Sanchez was not a bad apple in my opinion. All reports suggested he trained hard and had a good work ethic.

Lukaku was a bad apple. Its not just the weight issues. He flirted with Serie A long before he left openly while contracted to us. Then he name dropped Conte and went on to publish confidential fitness info on his peers using social media.

He was completely a bad apple. It doesn't matter how many he scores or how over critical we were of his performances. That type of professionalism has no place in our club.
It doesn't have any place in our club yet Rashford flirted with Barcalona in the summer holding the club to ransom to get a new contract and is still here and rewarded with superstar level wages?

What about Pogba what is he still doing here if that ''type of professionalism'' has no place in our club?

Didn't he, his agent and brother more or less beg for Real Madrid to come and pick him up?
 

VP89

Pogba's biggest fan
Joined
Dec 6, 2015
Messages
13,131
Everyone is a good apple when they play every game no matter how shit they are, all the talk about being the soldier and all that nonsense. When they are not guaranteed starting spot, then you see their real professionalism.

Not talking about Sanchez btw, I barely remember him as ManUtd player.
Sanchez has been well received by the manager for his attitude a couple of times if I'm not mistaken. He also kept quiet about exits publically and said he regrets nothing (even if he did from a footballing perspective).

It doesn't have any place in our club yet Rashford flirted with Barcalona in the summer holding the club to ransom to get a new contract and is still here and rewarded with superstar level wages?

What about Pogba what is he still doing here if that ''type of professionalism'' has no place in our club?

Didn't he, his agent and brother more or less beg for Real Madrid to come and pick him up?
Rashford never publically went out and spoke about Barcelona. How is this in any way comparable to Lukaku?

Pogba is a good example. I really am not a fan of Pogba the player but his professionalism was highly commendable, even though he's a far bigger brand than Lukaku. Yeah he said he wanted a new challenge but that's hardly disrespectful. He never openly spoke about Real Madrid and wanting to play in La Liga that summer. Lukaku did the opposite. He literally said he wanted to go to Serie A and he wants to play for Conte that summer. Then he started pissing off teammates before being forced to train in Belgium.

You're clutching at straws if you want to compare professionalism from Rashford and Pogba to Lukaku.
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
38,970
Location
France
It doesn't have any place in our club yet Rashford flirted with Barcalona in the summer holding the club to ransom to get a new contract and is still here and rewarded with superstar level wages?

What about Pogba what is he still doing here if that ''type of professionalism'' has no place in our club?

Didn't he, his agent and brother more or less beg for Real Madrid to come and pick him up?
I probably missed it but when and how did he flirt with Barcelona?
 

romufc

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
2,259
It doesn't have any place in our club yet Rashford flirted with Barcalona in the summer holding the club to ransom to get a new contract and is still here and rewarded with superstar level wages?

What about Pogba what is he still doing here if that ''type of professionalism'' has no place in our club?

Didn't he, his agent and brother more or less beg for Real Madrid to come and pick him up?
It is very hypocritical from Ole. The one thing Ole has lost from a personal point of view is his credibility. I can't talk for every fan but myself because all he has done is contradict himself at every given chance.

There is plenty of examples I can give you but I will mention Pogba because it is related.

Ole came out and said, we don't want people who do not want to be here.. that's why Lukaku went. Why is Pogba still here? He gave the interview in Hong Kong about a new challenge, his agent came out and said the club know what the player wants. His brother was came out and more importantly Pogba himself has not performed.

So why the different treatment?
 

Judas

Open to offers
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
11,919
Location
Where the grass is greener.
It doesn't have any place in our club yet Rashford flirted with Barcalona in the summer holding the club to ransom to get a new contract and is still here and rewarded with superstar level wages?

What about Pogba what is he still doing here if that ''type of professionalism'' has no place in our club?

Didn't he, his agent and brother more or less beg for Real Madrid to come and pick him up?
:lol: what's this crap.
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
38,970
Location
France
Think some paper or other said Barcelona fancied him, not that Marcus was after a move. Typical newspaper rumour mill.
I know but he said that Rashford flirted with Barcelona, maybe I missed it but Rashford never commented on transfer rumours?
 

roonster09

Correctly predicted France to win World Cup 2018
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
20,828
I understand your argument but it's something i absolutely detest about football. Sentimentality & nepotism is by far the worst traits i hate in football management. Seeing someone failing over and over again, whilst you suffer, but being afraid of telling the truth and calling it out are things i wish didn't exist.

With the results right now, of course people are going to be angry, when they see him with a smile on his face in press-conferences, with the current captain Young spouting '"it's like having the boss back"!, when if we sink any lower we will be in a relegation battle.

Can they be any more detached from reality? It just shows a loser's mentality and gives the impression they don't care about the fans suffering. That might not be true but it's what it comes across as.

What do the fans get for hiding their feelings? A slap across the face.


My original reply was based on this not being a totally accurate comparison also. Dalglish produced good results at the time, like you agree, so the fans had no reason not to be respectful towards him. Surely you can't expect all the fans to treat Solksjaer the same way with the results he is producing right now?
Dalglish team scored 47 goals in the league, outscored by Fulham, as many point as Fulham (52). League cup won't change anything and just 2-3 seasons ago they pushed us all the way till last 2 weeks for league title.

Ole isn't good enough but I will never understand why people will compare him with Hodgson and how Liverpool treated him. It's always Dalglish who is good comparison considering how he was crowd favorite but looked out of depth managing the club.

You argument is completely different and again players/manager saying something positive in PC doesn't mean they are blind and can't see how far we have fallen.
 

Ancient Of Days

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 4, 2019
Messages
188
Sanchez has been well received by the manager for his attitude a couple of times if I'm not mistaken. He also kept quiet about exits publically and said he regrets nothing (even if he did from a footballing perspective).
That didn't stop him from being unceremoniously kicked out of the club at the end of the window did it. So what is your point?


Rashford never publically went out and spoke about Barcelona. How is this in any way comparable to Lukaku?
No he just got his agent to do it for him which is even more snide.

What difference does the method of which they declare their interest in leaving make? If they do it nicely it's ok, but if they do it in a back handed way it's more respectable?

Pogba is a good example. I really am not a fan of Pogba the player but his professionalism was highly commendable, even though he's a far bigger brand than Lukaku. Yeah he said he wanted a new challenge but that's hardly disrespectful. He never openly spoke about Real Madrid and wanting to play in La Liga that summer. Lukaku did the opposite. He literally said he wanted to go to Serie A and he wants to play for Conte that summer. Then he started pissing off teammates before being forced to train in Belgium.
Now tell me what is so disrespectful and different from Lukaku praising Juve and saying one day he'd like to play in Italy, to Pogba's comments about needing a new challenge as if he's won all there is with the club?

Let's compare

Lukaku;

''Juve have a great project in place and they just keep going. Every year they try to get stronger.

"Without doubt, Juve are one of the two or three best teams in Europe. They've got a great coach on the bench and extraordinary players in every area of the team.

"Cristiano Ronaldo stands out, but watch out for the others too. Paulo Dybala is already impressive and getting stronger, while I love Douglas Costa''

Pogba while contracted to club as you stressed with Lukaku;

''For me I have been for three years in Manchester and have been doing great; some good moments and some bad moments, like everybody. Like everywhere else.

“After this season and everything that happened this season, with my season being my best season as well... I think for me it could be a good time to have a new challenge somewhere else

You're clutching at straws if you want to complain professionalism from Rashford and Pogba to Lukaku.
So because Pogba said he rather a challenge some else but United, that's more respectful than Lukaku praising a team in a different league?

I think it's you that's clutching at straws trying to put levels on how a players declares their intention on leaving for another club when while acting as if Lukaku crossed a line when praising Conte, failing to mention Pogba actually met up with Zidane, but that's ok because he's a bigger star so he's not unprofessional in your eyes.

And it's ok for Rashford because he did it through his agent :rolleyes:
 

Baneofthegame

New Member
Newbie
Joined
May 15, 2019
Messages
305
His comments about potentially no signings in January is slightly worrying.

We need at least two players in January to have a hope at top 4, it’s all well and good potentially having Pogba and Shaw back, but we are a couple of injuries again from being paper thin even at full strength.
 

12OunceEpilogue

Full Member
Scout
Joined
Oct 2, 2016
Messages
8,691
Location
Wigan
There's this myth peddled that Lukaku and Sanchez were bad apples.

On what basis? Lukaku had weight issues and was subsequently kicked out of the club.

Doesn't Shaw battle with weight issues and have bigger problems performing consistently? What's the difference?

Didn't Lukaku help land Ole the job by scoring twice in the famous PSG victory?

He scored in 3 games in row. 2 goals against Palace, 2 goals against Southampton and 2 goals against PSG.

After PSG we played against arsenal and he didn't perform and was promptly dropped and Ole made it clear Rashford was his favorite and that's when Lukuku and his agent started releasing stories about his desire to move to Italy.

Rashford knew he was no 1 and his place was secure hence the Gold Rashy chain he treated himself to shortly after Lukaku got marginalized


Sanchez himself didn't start to badly under Ole either scoring in the 3-1 win against Arsenal. Then was dropped in favor of Lingard who was given umpteenth amount of chances to prove himself even when doing nothing but being a passenger on the field.

It had to take a huge fans backlash during pre season and the start of this season for Jesse to be dropped and that was partly due to his off the field clownery

Yet you can be damn sure Ole is in no rush to kick him out of the club like he did with Lukaku or Sanchez

Sanchez during his time here was always hard working and a model professional. In the media the only time you'd see his social media is when he was posting videos of him working out in the gym or showing off pictures of his dog.

So ask where this this stuff about these two players being bad apples come from?
Fair enough on Sanchez, labelling him a bad apple in terms of his conduct is unfair but the huge deficit in wages v performances was possibly too hard to ignore. That whole transfer was a terrible mistake by the club, but to be fair I would blame neither Sanchez nor Ole for how it ended.

Lukaku was in my view simply not prepared for the task we have on our hands at United. His conditioning being off, whinging to the press when he lost his place and sending love letters to Milan was all hugely irksome last term, notwithstanding a couple of streaks of goals and a key performance in the PSG game. I was fan of Lukaku's performances in his first season even when he wasn't scoring but he was a lump for most of last year and I backed Ole when he phased him out.

It may be homegrown bias on my part but I'm not half as bothered by the Rashy and JLingz stuff as I was by Lukaku's conduct last year. I agree Ole put misguided faith in Lingard to carry out the plan/stay in shape without the ball when he has been dire for months with it, but he's been right to persist with Rashford who has shown himself capable of playing with high energy and intelligence on the left or in a two with James (not enough it must be said, though much of that is down to the shortcomings of the entire team).

Your insinuation is that I've been propagandised by the club and by Ole, but my verdicts on the four players you've mentioned are:

Sanchez - Not a bad apple as I previously said, but damaged goods owing to the insane wages we gave him + age catching up with him. Glad he's gone but wish he'd been replaced.
Lukaku - Unable to get his head and body straight at United, keen to play elsewhere. Glad he's gone but wish he'd been replaced.
Rashford - Good player, not a centre-forward but an asset on the left or in a split pairing running channels in a 352. Glad he's here.
Lingard - Utterly bereft of confidence and form and deservedly dropped, but even on his best form not a starter here. Ambivalent about him going or staying.

There are many factors at play in the formation of those opinions, of which I'm sure briefing from United is one, but I don't feel I'm far off. I'm firmly of the belief that it's possible to have doubts about Ole's management, doubts about the quality of the squad and specific players but also be glad the likes of Rashford are here while Lukaku and Sanchez are out.
 

VP89

Pogba's biggest fan
Joined
Dec 6, 2015
Messages
13,131
That didn't stop him from being unceremoniously kicked out of the club at the end of the window did it. So what is your point?
That Sanchez wasn't a bad apple. Do you read my posts?
No he just got his agent to do it for him which is even more snide.
Bullshit. They both actually hit out at the media for spreading lies at the time Barcelona rumours were there.
What difference does the method of which they declare their interest in leaving make? If they do it nicely it's ok, but if they do it in a back handed way it's more respectable?
Both are bad but coming out as a player contracted to the club and saying it outright is far worse. Obviously.
Now tell me what is so disrespectful and different from Lukaku praising Juve and saying one day he'd like to play in Italy, to Pogba's comments about needing a new challenge as if he's won all there is with the club?

Let's compare

Lukaku;

''Juve have a great project in place and they just keep going. Every year they try to get stronger.

"Without doubt, Juve are one of the two or three best teams in Europe. They've got a great coach on the bench and extraordinary players in every area of the team.

"Cristiano Ronaldo stands out, but watch out for the others too. Paulo Dybala is already impressive and getting stronger, while I love Douglas Costa''

Pogba while contracted to club as you stressed with Lukaku;

''For me I have been for three years in Manchester and have been doing great; some good moments and some bad moments, like everybody. Like everywhere else.

“After this season and everything that happened this season, with my season being my best season as well... I think for me it could be a good time to have a new challenge somewhere else
You're looking at the wrong Lukaku quotes, although hilarious you found yet another example of him flirting with another club. My reference was actually when Lukaku came out and said he wanted to play under Conte during the preseason with Man Utd. That's way fecking worse than Pogba wanting a new challenge and keeping vague.

Oh, and you have completely ignored the lack of loyalty to teammates and unprofessionalism in spilling fitness information about his peers. He went on to train away from the team for a reason, you know.
So because Pogba said he rather a challenge some else but United, that's more respectful than Lukaku praising a team in a different league?
He didn't just praise a team in a different league. He said he wanted to move to Serie A and even name dropped the manager he wants to go to. You're really struggling here.
I think it's you that's clutching at straws trying to put levels on how a players declares their intention on leaving for another club when while acting as if Lukaku crossed a line when praising Conte, failing to mention Pogba actually met up with Zidane, but that's ok because he's a bigger star so he's not unprofessional in your eyes.
Lukaku publically said he wants to play on Serie A and for Conte. That's not just praising. Pogba may have met Zidane but it means feck all in comparison to Lukaku basically wearing a "SOS" sign and a fecking address on it. And you say he wasn't a bad apple? Take a walk.
And it's ok for Rashford because he did it through his agent :rolleyes:
That didn't happen.

You've basically ignored what Rashford and his brother (agent) actually did, which is publically shut down rumours to Barcelona when it was reported. All before he signed the contract too.

I think you need to revisit the time line and Google, his agent and himself put out insta stories and statements saying the media "were making it up as they go along" when they reported Barcelona interest.
 

Andycoleno9

Full Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
8,836
Location
Croatia
No but they still loved Dalglish when he looked out of his depth, saying he should move on but were respectful to their legend.
So one person is more important than club? Why i must still love someone who is doing damage to something what millions and millions people around the world love? And he is not bloody Dalglish or Cantona or Giggs or Maldini ffs. He was good servant of this club and nothing else. But this club gave him everything in return. Last 2 or 3 years he was payed for not playing because he was injured. He scored goals for us and i thank him for that but my God, he really used his every goal ( and still doing it) for leeching on this club. He was payed last 2 or 3 seasons for doing nothing, got job as a coach in this club in academy, got job as first team manager and finally ruining this club with smile on his face and romantic fans like you defend him because he is a "legend".
He was legend but now he is a leecher and nothing else. Am i harsh? Yes. Am i plastic fan? Some like you will say yes, but i don't care. For me it is club》》》》》》》》》》legends.
 

Andycoleno9

Full Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
8,836
Location
Croatia
Not sure how you got that from my post.
You said that Liverpool fans still love and respect Kenny because he is a legend. I presumed that you think that about Ole. And i disagree with that. Legend status you get by doing good things for your club. Ole deserved that in his playing career. But when you start doing bad things for your club and you keep doing it, you lose "legend" status protection.

Yes, i know, i am cold bastard( not true fan as some say) and i have no respect to our legends. Sorry, but Ole is doing serious damage to this club and i am really pissed because of that.
 

roonster09

Correctly predicted France to win World Cup 2018
Scout
Joined
May 10, 2009
Messages
20,828
You said that Liverpool fans still love and respect Kenny because he is a legend. I presumed that you think that about Ole. And i disagree with that. Legend status you get by doing good things for your club. Ole deserved that in his playing career. But when you start doing bad things for your club and you keep doing it, you lose "legend" status protection.

Yes, i know, i am cold bastard( not true fan as some say) and i have no respect to our legends. Sorry, but Ole is doing serious damage to this club and i am really pissed because of that.
Even if Ole loses next 5 games he will still be a legend, he will be a shit manager but legend at ManUtd.

And yeah, I love Ole and respect him forever, doesn't mean I want him to continue as manager. It's not hard to differentiate between all these.
 

Kush

Full Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2010
Messages
2,610
Enjoyed that performance, but it still changes nothing with regards to Ole.
 

el3mel

Full Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2016
Messages
29,095
Location
Egypt
It's Norwich mk2. Great win against crap opposition but we shouldn't look any further than that. At least it's a comfortable night today.
 

dove

Full Member
Joined
May 15, 2013
Messages
4,628
This was a game we could have won 3-0 without a manager, Partizan were shite.
 

Majima

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
2,151
Location
Kami's Lookout
Good win, happy to see confidence lifted a bit.

But i'm under no illusions, there was still stagnant movement ahead of the ball carrier in midfield throughout tonight. Too much sideways passing and touches on the ball. Our build-up play was again atrocious.

Partizan were just that bad, that we could damage them that easily. I wonder whether they even are pro level.

Let's see what our build-up is like vs a deep defence this weekend vs Brighton.

If we play the same failing 4231 with a No.10, i'm not going to be impressed.
 

ash_86

Full Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2013
Messages
5,327
Good win for us today and good that Ole tried an interesting front 3. Add Pogba to the mix and we have a very good front 6 :

Rashford ------- Martial -----------Greenwood

---------------Pogba--------------------

-----------Fred ---------- Scott------------
 

Flexdegea

New Member
Newbie
Joined
May 28, 2013
Messages
137
Good win, happy to see confidence lifted a bit.

But i'm under no illusions, there was still stagnant movement ahead of the ball carrier in midfield throughout tonight. Too much sideways passing and touches on the ball. Our build-up play was again atrocious.

Partizan were just that bad, that we could damage them that easily. I wonder whether they even are pro level.

Let's see what our build-up is like vs a deep defence this weekend vs Brighton.

If we play the same failing 4231 with a No.10, i'm not going to be impressed.


Did you watch the same game as everyone else :houllier:
 

Majima

Full Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
2,151
Location
Kami's Lookout
Did you watch the same game as everyone else :houllier:
And you are?

It was Partizan, not Barcelona. I'm more interested in what we're like vs Brighton at the weekend.

Considering we've struggled to break down deep defences since eternity and i saw plenty of warning signs tonight to not get carried away by tonight's result.
 

sweetmgd

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jan 29, 2019
Messages
68
Good win for us today and good that Ole tried an interesting front 3. Add Pogba to the mix and we have a very good front 6 :

Rashford ------- Martial -----------Greenwood

---------------Pogba--------------------

-----------Fred ---------- Scott------------
For Greenwood, of course now in order to give him game time and develop his body, we can play him at RW, but if you see in the match, Greenwood was very quiet most of the time. I think his long term best position is striker, since his skill set and speed remind me of VPS.