I’m not sure either of those assertions are true tbh. If Pogba didn’t get injured all of two games ago, I don’t think at that point anyone would have been saying Scott is having a better season than him. His form has been quickly forgotten though, as has Scott’s poor form earlier this season. What nobody will ever forget, of course, is that Pogba started the season badly and had 4 poor games.No point judging players by their ceiling, when we very rarely see Pogba's.
McTominay is more consistent, and has been the better of the 2 for us this season.