[Borys]

Defensively suspect in the first half but the whole defence was shambolic so not that worried. He is not there yet but he links up very well, offers some threat on the right side. Deserves another start IMO.

Thought he was awful in the first half. I can't believe LVG favours him over Rafael. I've yet to see that he has the potential to make it here. His only really good game came against a League 2 side.

It seems van Gaal has given up on Rafael and he’s looking for other solutions. What is a sensible idea.

 

[iBoss]

Did alright. Potential there to at least be a squad player.

 

[ChaddyP]

I like his passing. Looks a threat going forward too.

 

[MyOnlySolskjaer]

Didn't look too out of place as a right back, it's clear he has too much technical ability to be deployed as a center back, this may well be his future position, he reminds me alot of Coleman.

It's nice to see a variation of passes from a fullback rather than the generic "Run byline, stutter, stutter, deliver a poor cross" from Valencia.

 

[Wednesday at Stoke]

I think he'll be a very good defensive mid, which is likely where he plays for the U21s.

 

[limerickcitykid]

I think he'll be a very good defensive mid, which is likely where he plays for the U21s.

I can't say I recall him ever playing DM for the u21s. Think he could be good there though, hes a smart player and very good on the ball. Been very impressed with him stepping up to the first team. Just needs to get better at dealing with pacey attackers, should try drop off sooner to get the extra step on them and be able to block them off getting in behind or to jockey them wide.

 

[Dante]

Thought he looked very promising. I hope he's retained as our second choice (at least) right back next season.

His first touch is excellent and his passing is properly impressive. The kid never shies away from the ball.

I know he's a very different kind of player to Evra, but there's a similar air of leadership from fullback about him. We used to build a lot of our attacks from the back through Paddy because he was so reliable and so willing to take on responsibility. I see that same willingness in McNair. I hope he can build on it.

 

[Insanity]

Both him and Rojo were too far up the pitch in the first half and were getting found out. Burnley wingers/backs were able to put crosses in the box with considerable ease.

I like McNair, he is good with the ball at his feet and can defend when in the right position. His lack of pace is what bothers me.

 

[Swaters16]

Both him and Rojo were too far up the pitch in the first half and were getting found out. Burnley wingers/backs were able to put crosses in the box with considerable ease.

I like McNair, he is good with the ball at his feet and can defend when in the right position. His lack of pace is what bothers me.

I thought he's shown some good moments of pace. Especially against Cambridge, getting forward he looked reasonably quick. I think his issue might be positioning and reacting to situations in an unfamiliar position more than anything.

 

[Nighteyes]

He looks far better as a RB than he ever did as a CB. Pace might be an issue but there's definitely something to work with.

 

[Dr Fink]

He was my MOTM last night by a country mile as energetic and positive as RVP was lazy and lacklustre. Head and shoulders above everyone else bar DDG. Great positioning, decent passing, good vision and he can cross it unlike "Shins" Valencia. This guy is a great find and warrants a starting place every game. Playing him with Evans might jeopardise his confidence and his career though.

 

[Decotron]

I think he'll be a very good defensive mid, which is likely where he plays for the U21s.

Id love to see him in that role as well. Maybe a league cup match next season or something. I think it would really suit him...

 

[Stobzilla]

I thought he's shown some good moments of pace. Especially against Cambridge, getting forward he looked reasonably quick. I think his issue might be positioning and reacting to situations in an unfamiliar position more than anything.

Yeah, you can sense the wheels turning before he reacts sometimes, but that comes with playing time.

 

[Decotron]

He looks far better as a RB than he ever did as a CB. Pace might be an issue but there's definitely something to work with.

In his long career as a centre back you mean?

 

[Roboc7]

I think his most likely role in the first team is as a utility player in the John O’Shea mould, he doesn’t really possess the ability to be a top fullback, centre back or midfielder (unless there is dramatic improvement ) but he is good on the ball and has a good temperament so I think he is someone who could plug gaps in those positions.

 

[Nighteyes]

In his long career as a centre back you mean?

Exactly what I meant.

 

[Elliott]

Id love to see him in that role as well. Maybe a league cup match next season or something. I think it would really suit him...

Ditto. Wouldn't be too surprised to see him eventually end up in midfield.

 

[DanNistelrooy]

Decent on the ball but I've yet to be impressed with any of his defending since the West Ham/Everton period.

 

[jb8521]

The best thing about him and the thing which I think Van Gaal will be most impressed with is how quickly he learns and adapts to new roles and positions and his development over the past year has been fantastic. He's still growing as well which might explain to a degree why he sometimes looks a lot quicker than other times, the same happened with Welbeck around the same age. He's beginning to add some muscle to his frame now so he could be very powerful in a year or 2.

 

[pseudo_canadian]

Looks pretty comfortable at RB for the most part. Good at passing to feet and isn't afraid to get up field.

My only gripe with him from yesterday was that there was a point where he lost his man and the player ran in behind him off his back and almost got in on goal. But that just comes down to simple positional sense that he doesn't have yet as a RB. He'll be fine though.

We potentially have a great RB option on our hands. Happy for the lad.

 

[Walters_19_MuFc]

Does anyone know how tall McNair is? It's saying 1.72M on wiki and a lot of other sites, which is only 5ft7. Surely this isn't true.

 

[Jev]

Very ordinary player. Should never start ahead of Rafa and Valencia.

 

[Fergies Formula]

He is Bob Basic

 

[Brwned]

He's a much better passer than either of them which given our style of play counts for a lot. Atrocious marking from corners today though.

 

[kps88]

I'd like to see a proper winger play ahead of him. Valencia or Young instead of Herrera would look better to me.

 

[Jev]

He's a much better passer than either of them which given our style of play counts for a lot. Atrocious marking from corners today though.

He misplaced a lot of passes in that half, despite only passing to the nearest man. Don't think he's any better than them.

 

[drdoityourself]

He should be more advanced when we have the ball, he is usually not there when we have space on the right.

 

[Roman Bellic]

He has been trash today, it happens... hope LVG brings on Valencia

 

[DevilRed]

Not having the best of games. Can't blame him as he probably has never played as a right back since the last month or so.

Makes you wonder whether Rafael would be the better choice? Mcnair is a fantastic prospect but Rafael is clearly more experienced and gives us a lot more pace and width on the right flank.

 

[DWelbz19]

Yeah, poor game thus far.

 

[Mciahel Goodman]

Decent game for the young lad (nothing exceptional), thought he was ok. Like I said, this is a game where I think Valencia would be a better option.

 

[goin4glory]

He has no options in possession. We don't have a natural winger as Herrera is central and neither RVP/Rooney are running the channels. I don't think he's a future RB anyway but the set up of this team is terrible.

 

[Sam]

Mental decision to start him in a game like this. Utterly mental. LVG is an idiot.

 

[Kag]

He's a much better passer than either of them which given our style of play counts for a lot. Atrocious marking from corners today though.

Valencia's passing is rock solid so I wouldn't agree with that.

 

[Classical Mechanic]

Thought that he was pretty awful in that half. I don't think that he got a single cross in because he isn't good enough to attack his full back. I mean he ran the ball out of play once. He was caught on his heals for passes from Hererra a couple of times and his marking from corners is far from good enough.

And he doesn't look pacey at this level at all.

 

[charleysurf]

He's a CB not a RB. I said that even after the Cambridge game. Valencia is far more suited to the role

 

[Bojan11]

It's stupid decision to start him. But this formation without a RM doesn't suit him. Atleast Shaw has Di Maria on the left.

 

[Brwned]

He misplaced a lot of passes in that half, despite only passing to the nearest man. Don't think he's any better than them.

Absolute nonsense. He's played nice, tidy passes into the feet of van Persie, Rooney and Fellaini rather than doing Valencia's usual thing of recycling the ball backwards to Blind or Herrera.

 

[Solius]

He lets the ball run across him too much and that stops him having a better angle for the pass or cross.

 

[izec]

Absolute nonsense. He's played nice, tidy passes into the feet of van Persie, Rooney and Fellaini rather than doing Valencia's usual thing of recycling the ball backwards to Blind or Herrera.

i agree. His forward passing is very good, risky but i like that more than passing the ball back a la Valencia.