Park Ji-Sung asks United fans to stop singing his chant
- Thread starter Tom Van Persie
- Start date
The fact there are some fans trying to justify it when the man himself comes out to say he finds it offensive truly boggles the mind. Just grow up and find something else to chant about. Morons.
Inappropriate Content
Donny, Donny, wherever you may be
Warming the bench next to Phil Jonesy
But it could be worse
You could be Park
Pretending your breakfast never used to bark
Park: Please don't use the strereotype about Koreans eating dogs anymore it is offensive
Supposed fan: How about this even more offensive version.....
Back in 2017 I had the chance to meet Vidic and Silvestre, they were going to make an appearance in an exhibition in my city.
Like an idiot I taught my non football friends the Nimanja chant and and we sang it when he walked in. It was only later I found out that he didn't like it. He still smiled and waved at us, then spoke to me like a gentleman when I went to him to take pictures.
I feel so stupid now.
Like an idiot I taught my non football friends the Nimanja chant and and we sang it when he walked in. It was only later I found out that he didn't like it. He still smiled and waved at us, then spoke to me like a gentleman when I went to him to take pictures.
I feel so stupid now.
Doesn't rhyme
Now this is a racist post.
You clearly think you're super funny, but it's just pure racism.
Surely you can see, when a Korean player asks fans to stop and says it is a racial insult to the Korean people, doubling down and writing a new rhyme saying Park eats dogs for breakfast is a 100% racist response.
I wasn’t referring to acceptance, I was talking about relevance. That song tends to be sung during the Liverpool games and in the run up to them.Well that's ok then
Not as much as I used to.
And I don't doubt it and I could probably live with keeping it that way.
Park life
Victor Victor, Wherever you may be
You’re meant to tackle in this country
But it could be worse, you could be scouse
Playing for them and being a mouse
You’re meant to tackle in this country
But it could be worse, you could be scouse
Playing for them and being a mouse
Fun fact, domesticated dogs are not the only animals that bark. I have not mentioned anything about dogs unlike you as Park has specifically asked us not to do this.
How didn't this become a thing?
I’ve googled both. Fact check says they do eat dogs in parks country. Scousers don’t eat rats.
so, the chant is fine...but as park doesn’t like it maybe we need a new one. Or insert make it more factual and change the line to “you eat about 1 million dogs in your own country”
Yes silly me, you've outwitted me with your clever argument clearly you were insinuating he eats seals instead, I'm sure he'd thank you for it.
Just take it out of the repertoire like with Lukaku's chant.
The kimchi suggestion is so cringey.
The kimchi suggestion is so cringey.
Isn’t it more of an issue because of the sensitivity around the eating of dogs, rather than being racist? Is saying dogs are eaten by Korean people more racist than saying fish and chips are eaten by English people or french people eat snails and frogs legs....or anything less mainstream that is known to be eaten in certain countries.
We’re in danger of just not being able to consider social grouping at all as a concept, which in some ways can be positive but in other ways forms identity and is basic human nature.
I get that if Park finds it offensive we should stop singing it. It’s quite an offensive song in any case but was always intended to be as an insult to our scouse friends. So we stop singing about Park...it would’ve happened years ago anyway but for the song having a dig at scousers.
We’re in danger of just not being able to consider social grouping at all as a concept, which in some ways can be positive but in other ways forms identity and is basic human nature.
I get that if Park finds it offensive we should stop singing it. It’s quite an offensive song in any case but was always intended to be as an insult to our scouse friends. So we stop singing about Park...it would’ve happened years ago anyway but for the song having a dig at scousers.
Yeah it's really simple. Just don't sing it. Even if you genuinely don't think it's racist for some reason, the guy clearly doesn't like it so why sing it and insult one of our own? Because epic bantz?
Park actually explained it.it's used as a common insult towards asians in occidental countries, that's why Korean people are annoyed by it.
People really need to get out of the habit of telling people they shouldn't be offended by something. If the man himself is saying it then think about it from his perspective, he's not trying to be a dick about it for the sake of it. You could sing the exact same song at an opposition player and it would work as a song trying to wind a player up, it's not a supportive chant.
It is slightly different though because drinking tea isn't seen around the world as a horrible thing to do. And haggis is also different to dog meat because haggis tastes fecking disgusting.
Well of course it’s a bit of a jibe. Eating dogs in the west is frowned upon. Maybe it’s offensive but it’s certainly not racist.
Singing it is a bit stupid now though as he doesn’t like the chant.
This is getting silly. Koreans who eat dogs are in the minority, it is not widely practiced. Probably happens in poorer/rural areas. The fact is the song tells Park he eats dog because he is Korean. He has probably never eaten a dog in his life. He doesn't like the song so don't sing it.
I have lived in Korea and I never eaten dog or seen one on the menu.
I have lived in Korea and I never eaten dog or seen one on the menu.
Unless hes a vegetarian, in which case I will apologise profusely.
Has anyone ever considered the scousers feelings on a song about them eating rats or if they like being named after a stew?
Park Park wherever you may be
We hate scousers in this country
But it could be worse, you could be scouse
Saying “La” in your council house
We hate scousers in this country
But it could be worse, you could be scouse
Saying “La” in your council house
Park Park wherever you may be
Parking costs a fortune in this country
But it could be worse you could be scouse
With the stolen car outside your house
Parking costs a fortune in this country
But it could be worse you could be scouse
With the stolen car outside your house
Sure thing Park. If thats his wish so be it. But I think as a society we reached the pinnacle PC culture and it's getting tiresome
kleba kleba wherever you may be
You brought your wife, she was only a teen
But they let her stay, even in your bed
Whilst we watched you playing football, worse than Fred
You brought your wife, she was only a teen
But they let her stay, even in your bed
Whilst we watched you playing football, worse than Fred
Are you calling me a racist?Epic bantz mate
Still at lest another racist poster is outed.
Here’s a time travel machine, why don’t you go back to the 70s then where you feel more at home
I wasn't even born in the 70s but thank you for confirming my statement
Park Park wherever you may be
You eat Kimchi in your home country
But it could be worse, you could be scouse
Eating microwave meals in your mortgaged house
Respectful and acknowledges Scousers can indeed purchase their own homes.
You eat Kimchi in your home country
But it could be worse, you could be scouse
Eating microwave meals in your mortgaged house
Respectful and acknowledges Scousers can indeed purchase their own homes.
Well you started it fella saying basically that it’s gone too PC when players tell that what you’re singing is absolutely offensive. So why don’t you listen to the expert (Park in this case) and stop making it bigger than what it is
This member has now been banned for a history of racist remarks. So to answer his question, yes.
Park says please don't sing that and clearly says it is a racial slur...
When someone says please stop that, it is a racial slur used to discriminate against Asians and Korans , it is clearly racist to then incorporate the same slur into another rhyme and post it in a public forum as your response.
@Adcuth's response
Yes I am.
When someone says please stop that, it is a racial slur used to discriminate against Asians and Korans , it is clearly racist to then incorporate the same slur into another rhyme and post it in a public forum as your response.
Thank you