Don't buy the Vidic/midfield cover excuse. Fact is Evra knows we're missing Vidic and don't have a Flectcher in the team. With this in mind, he should be even more focused and determined not to leave his flank exposed. Its extremely bizarre because its not like he's repeatedly getting skinned by his man, he just refuses to be disciplined enough to ensure we don't get caught out. Can't be too hard to fix either. Just tell him to make sure your man doesn't have acres of space on the left because you're caught up field.
I can only imagine SAF isn't too bothered about it.
SAF has said that Evra is vital to our attack, and much of Young's contributions at the beginning of the season were down to Evra providing support and giving him space. In other words, it seems that Evra is allowed to go a little gung ho in attack.
He has 6 assists this year, which is quite good, but how many attacks hasn't he orchestrated with his drive forwards? Although some of his pace has gone, his drive hasn't! When everyone else is on their back foot, Evra always seems willing to attack - against City too much so.
Once Evra goes missing, I think we will see what his contributions to our team really is! Sure, his defending has deteriorated. I seem to remember a time where only Lennon was able to get past him, but now he is caught on the wrong foot too often!
However, most fullbacks are caught out quite a bit. As I've watched some Liverpool games I've seen that Enrique is caught out a lot more than Evra, mostly due to his complete lack of agility. Ashley Cole is certainly no better than Evra; Everton should praise themselves lucky that Baines were out against us because Baines would have had no chance against Valencia like Distin did, who was to be honest properly raped second half.