PL Team of the Season 2019 20: In before the restart

Mr Smith

Full Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2015
Messages
4,020
Location
Australia
With the premier league set to come back in a few weeks, I thought it would be good to have a record of the team of the season to date. There always tends to be a recency effect with these, so I thought it would be a fascinating thought experiment to see how much (if at all) our picks change between now and the remaining games of the season. Here's mine; I had this shortly after the suspension in the anticipation we might not get a restart:

GK - Dean Henderson: You could argue there hasn't been a standout GK this season, but if you had to give it to one player, I'd make it our young lad on loan. He's made an amazing start for his first full Premier League season and there's been whispers of an England call-up. Honourable mention for Martin Dubravka, who's kept Newcastle in games virtually on his own at times this season.

RB - Trent Alexander-Arnold: Hard to go past the man who I'd argue is the best full-back in the world right now, and who could genuinely be pointed to in the future as the man who permanently changed the role of the modern fullback (though the true influence really should be considered to be Phillip Lahm). Has an incredible influence on his side's tempo and playing style. Honourable mentions to both Wan-Bissaka and Ricardo Pereira, who have both had strong seasons.

CB - Virgil Van Dijk: Has maintained last season's form and is easily the most consistent defender in the PL at this point. Also the true leader at Liverpool and (regrettably) reminds me of Ferdinand at times.

CB - Jonny Evans: Tight call between him and Soyuncu who was the standout defender in the league early on, but his form took a real dip after December. Evans meanwhile has been an extremely consistent performer for Leicester, and doesn't appear to have missed a beat after losing his partner in Maguire (who would be my other honourable mention for stabilising our defence).

LB - Jack O'Connell: OK I'm cheating here; O'Connel is a CB. But in Chris Wilder's system with overlapping CB's, O'Connel might as well be a fullback, or at the very least could play there. Frankly all of Sheffield's CB's have been great this season, but O'Connell has particularly impressed me for both defensive and attacking contributions, and is the best fit for the side here. No obvious honourable mentions for me; really don't think there's been an outstanding left back this season.

CM - Wilfred Ndidi: Sometimes the sign of an important player is how much you notice him when he's not there. And it didn't seem a coincidence that Leicester's early season form seemed to dip around the same time Ndidi was out through injury. I don't think Leicester's "free 8's" system works without him, and he has a Kante-like influence when he's fit.

CM - Jordan Henderson: Now to be clear; I'm not one of the people who things Henderson is a player of the year candidate. But he has probably had his best professional season to date, and has been the most consistent performer in Liverpool's otherwise quite interchangeable midfield, so fair play. Youri Tielemans, and maybe even Fred (my United player of the year) deserve a shout for their consistency this season too.

CAM - Kevin De Bruyne: Probably my player of the season. By far City's most consistent performer in an off-year for the rest. You could argue City's reliance on De Bruyne has increased significantly this year, being played as more of a traditional #10 rather than one of two attacking midfielders in previous seasons. Honourable mention to Jack Grealish for almost single-handedly keeping Villa's heads above water for most of the season.

RW - Adama Traore: I actually feel the tag of "most improved player" has done Traore a disservice this season. He's been one of the most dangerous players in the league and his combination of speed, strength, and vastly improved decision making has been almost unplayable at times. Honourable mention for Moh Salah, who's had a very good year and feels like he's gone somewhat under the radar.

LW - Sadio Mane: I really can't believe how good Mane has become. I felt we missed the boat somewhat when Liverpool signed him, but I never thought he would turn into one of the most productive players in the league that any club in the world would be happy to have. 14 goals and 7 assists in the league may only seem like a respectable return, but the fear he incites in defences is palpable. Don't really have an outstanding honourable mention here, unless you consider Grealish a hybrid left-winger.

ST - Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang: The hardest position to pick this year, and probably the most likely to change in the remaining 8 games. Vardy and Abraham both started really strong and faded, while Ings and Jimenez started slowly but have increased in prominence as the season has progressed. I personally think Firmino has been outstanding whenever I've watched him, but I have it from a Liverpool-supporting mate that he misses an insane amount of chances and should be on 20 goals this season. Aubameyang however has been Arsenal's sole light this season, and has bailed them out with Van Persie like frequency. 17 goals playing for a team in 9th is a hell of an achievement.

Manager - Chris Wilder: I know Klopp is set to lead Liverpool to the most comfortable league win ever; I don't care. Sheffield United's achievements this season have been more impressive given the relative resources.

So no United players, but perhaps the likes of Rashford, Fred, or Maguire could sneak in if we have a great finish to the season and get fourth. Full team:

----------------------D. Henderson------------------

T.A.A.-------Van Dijk-----Evans-------O'Connell

---------------Ndidi------------J.Henderson
----------------------De Bruyne
Traore---------------------------------------------Mane
--------------------Aubameyang

Thoughts?
 

BobbyManc

Full Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2012
Messages
7,750
Location
The Wall
Supports
Man City
Traore has been good but I think his inclusion is based too much on his level compared to his previous standard. Ultimately, Salah has undoubtedly been better, as has
Mahrez. Son as well, possibly. It’s a fair inclusion though.

TAA is getting a lot of praise too, much which is merited but it seems a lot of people are forgetting about Dani Alves’s peak years at Sevilla and Barcelona. Could make a strong case for Marcelo too.

My main objection would be Auba up top. Aguero has been far better. He has only one less goal and two more assists in over 900 minutes less time on the field. The difference in quality between them is significant. I’d have Vardy and Jimenez ahead of Auba as well.
 

Paul_Scholes18

Full Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2014
Messages
13,891
I think Chilwell or Robertson deserve the left back spot. Traore is very much up and down. Would go with Rashford for him or Salah if wanting a pure right winger.
Vardy might deserve the forward spot too.
 

paraguayo

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Jun 24, 2019
Messages
1,339
Supports
neutral
Liverpool are like a million points ahead, they deserve few more players in there. Namely Alisson, Robertson etc
 

Stacks

Full Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2015
Messages
10,905
Location
Between a rock and Gibraltar
Traore has been good but I think his inclusion is based too much on his level compared to his previous standard. Ultimately, Salah has undoubtedly been better, as has
Mahrez. Son as well, possibly. It’s a fair inclusion though.

TAA is getting a lot of praise too, much which is merited but it seems a lot of people are forgetting about Dani Alves’s peak years at Sevilla and Barcelona. Could make a strong case for Marcelo too.

My main objection would be Auba up top. Aguero has been far better. He has only one less goal and two more assists in over 900 minutes less time on the field. The difference in quality between them is significant. I’d have Vardy and Jimenez ahead of Auba as well.
agreed except Son. Also Vardy has fired his team to an unlikely top 3.
 

padr81

Full Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2015
Messages
11,933
Supports
Man City
Alisson
TAA
Van Dijk
Evans
Robertson
Ndidi
Henderson
KDB
Salah
Aguero
Mane

For shits and giggle heres my bench.
Henerson gk, Pereira, Soyuncu, Rashford, Fernandes, Sterling, Vardy

Maybe could have squeezed another Liverpool player in there but that's it for me. Feels bad leaving out players from Sheffield United and Wolves but imho they've genuinely been the best in their positions. The Aguero one being most debatable but he's averaging 88 minutes a goal in the PL, ridiculous consistency (as always).

7 Liverpool players reflects their dominance of the league imho. Every member of my team is made up of the top 3 who have been miles ahead of the rest so far this season. I was undecided on Fernandes given the little we've seen of him but put him in because he seems to have completely transformed Uniteds midfield in the way many expect Pogba to.
 

Mr Smith

Full Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2015
Messages
4,020
Location
Australia
I think Chilwell or Robertson deserve the left back spot. Traore is very much up and down. Would go with Rashford for him or Salah if wanting a pure right winger.
Vardy might deserve the forward spot too.
Chilwell really hasn't had that great a year. He started well but has had some shocking games against the big sides, and has by and large been very ordinary since November. I'll concede Robertson has probably been the PL's best LB, I just really wanted to get one of Sheffield's outfield players in.

Would concede Salah probably deserves a place too, and I expect he'll be in the official team. But I've been so impressed with Traore, I do really think he's become one of the league's most dangerous attackers. For me its splitting hairs between Vardy and Aubameyang, I almost put Vardy in. As I said in my OP, it's probably the position most likely to be determined by the last 8 games.
 

Web of Bissaka

Full Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2017
Messages
8,553
Location
Losing to Comeback Winning!
2019/20

Alisson
TAA
Van Dijk
Evans
Robertson
Ndidi
Henderson
KDB
Salah
Aguero
Mane
This,
( 7 Pools : 2 City : 2 Leicester ) is just right, fits table and performances.
Alisson
TAA -- Evans -- VVD -- Robertson
Henderson -- Ndidi
KDB
Salah -- Aguero -- Mane​

Henderson (GK) is really close as does Soyuncu, Auba and Vardy.

Manager is like OP's -- Chris Wilder.. or Brendan Rogers.
 

Mr Smith

Full Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2015
Messages
4,020
Location
Australia
2019/20


This,
( 7 Pools : 2 City : 2 Leicester ) is just right, fits table and performances.
Alisson
TAA -- Evans -- VVD -- Robertson
Henderson -- Ndidi
KDB
Salah -- Aguero -- Mane​

Henderson (GK) is really close as does Soyuncu, Auba and Vardy.

Manager is like OP's -- Chris Wilder.. or Brendan Rogers.
Do we really think Alisson deserves it this year? From my recollection he's had a decent chunk of the season out through injury.
 

Dancfc

Full Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2016
Messages
7,406
Supports
Chelsea
I think Henderson should be in ahead of Alisson given the latter has missed a fair chunk of the season but beyond that you couldn't really complain if the team was full of Liverpool players.
 
Last edited:

Dumbstar

We got another woman hater here.
Joined
Jul 18, 2002
Messages
21,244
Location
Viva Karius!
Supports
Liverpool