DDG - 5 - Unfortunately, he's made too many mistakes this season and it's time for a change. Doesn't do enough of the things he is said to do well, and also has too many limitations.
Victor Lindelöf - 6.5 - Solid when called upon. He's a good number 3/4 option. But a definite step down from top tier Martinez and Varane.
Harry Maguire - 4 - Can't wait for him to go.
Lisandro Martínez - 8.5 - LOVE him. Exactly the calibre of player we need.
Tyrell Malacia - 6 - Thought he was great when he first came, but has dropped off a little since then. Still has a lot to learn.
Raphaël Varane - 8 - Brilliant player, but I have question marks over the amount of injuries/niggles he picks up.
Diogo Dalot - 5.5 - He'll do for now, but definitely upgradeable.
Luke Shaw - 8 - He's got better and better has the season has gone on. Really looks like the player we thought we signed years ago.
Aaron Wan-Bissaka - 7 - He's grown on me. I do still find him too frustrating in attack.
Bruno Fernandes - 7.5/8 - he's our most important player, imo. Still frustrating at times, but he can pop up and do something even when he's having a quiet or bad game.
Christian Eriksen - 6 - Good against teams that sit back, but crumbles when he has to be more aggressive or when he has less time. Think he is definitely upgradeable, but I do think he has
a place in the squad, for sure.
Marcel Sabitzer - 6? - Quite like him, tbh. He's a good option to come off the bench or for rotation.
Fred - 6.5 - he's useful and is a decent squad option, but I do think we need more from someone in his positon.
Casemiro - 8 - he's a class player but his form after injuries/suspension does worry me. Seems to need a lot of games to hit his stride. That's a little frustrating. When he's on form, he is on another level to what anyone else can do or offer.
Facundo Pellistri - to be honest, we have not seen enough of him to make a judgement. Doesn't get game time.
Donny van de Beek - 3.5 - he's invisible. Hasn't worked out for him, needs a different club/league.
Scott McTominay - 5 - Useful...ish. Need more from a player in his position.
Kobbie Mainoo - not seen enough of him to make any judgements this season.
Anthony Martial - 4 - Can't stand the guy. He's injured, he comes back and looks good for a few games, he then looks disinterested and off the pace, then he gets injured again. We should expect more from a striker at Man Utd.
Marcus Rashford - 8 - Unreal season from him. Glad to see that fire in him and that willingness to score goals. A large part of me does think that this is an outlier of a season rather than what we can expect as the norm.
Antony - 6 - I can't decide whether I like him or not. He is very limited with what he can do, and he telegraphs that 'trick' he does where he comes inside and shoots on his stronger foot. A bit too one-footed and slow for my liking. There's no denying it, we have clearly overpaid for what we're getting. Hope he shows a lot more in his next season.
Jadon Sancho - 3 - Too frustrating. Too weak, too slow, too wimpish, not brave enough to make an impact on games. My general feeling is that this club is too big for him. He doesn't do enough, which then puts pressure on others to do more. We need and should expect more from someone in his position and with his overall cost.
Wout Weghorst - 1. Awful and hideous player who never, ever should have been allowed to come anywhere near this club. A striker who cannot and does not want to score goals.
Anthony Elanga - 3.5 - honestly can't remember the last time he played, so I'm going with the score off memory. Needs moving on.
Alejandro Garnacho - 7.5. A young, ballsy player who wants to take others on, and who wants to score goals. We need much more of this attitude in the squad.
Ten Hag - 8. He's exceeded expectations this season. Great work from him to get us back into the champions league, winning one trophy and getting into the final of another. At the same time, we've also taken some big and painful batterings this season...so there's still a lot of work to be done. Trying not to get too carried away. However, there's no denying that we have a really mixed ability squad, with some absolute duds in there, so to do as well as we have done this season is impressive.
Best player overall: Martinez. He's looked the absolute real deal when he's played.
Worst player overall: Weghorst. An abysmal player and questions do need to be asked over why he was ever allowed to come here.
Biggest surprise: Garnacho. A complete revelation.
Biggest disappointment: Sancho. Had Sancho not existed, Antony would take this prize. But, the level of disappointment I feel for Sancho is different to Antony. At least Antony can offer or do something when he has the ball, and he has something about him. Sancho should expect more of himself and should be offering a lot more as a Man Utd player.
