The problem with evaluating Poch is quiet simple: everything you say against him can be written down to the structure at PSG, not his managerial ability. You can't really make am honest observation, because everything can be written off as an excuse. For example:
He won't win the CL - Even Pep who spent billions hasn't won it, so it's unfair to use this metric to judge Poch
It's almost been a year since he was appointed, yet we don't see any semblance of a playing style - You can't imprint a playing style because the players are unmotivated and Leonardo picks the team anyways
Most players haven't improved since Tuchel left. As a matter of fact you could make a case that some of them regressed - Mbappe wants to leave and most PSG players are mercenaries who don't give a hoot about being better.
In a lot of ways this reminds me of Ole's time here, constant excusing for poor performances running down to the Glazers and Woodward.
Should we pick the next United manager based on current excuses or current successes and competences. Well, the answer is obvious.
Let's break that down.
He won't win the CL - Even Pep who spent billions hasn't won it, so it's unfair to use this metric to judge Poch
Pep at least won league titles, consistently challenged, and has dominated the Premier league in comparison to other managers. Winning the league semi-consistently is a bigger challenge to me than winning the CL once, although he did it twice with Barca.
It's almost been a year since he was appointed, yet we don't see any semblance of a playing style - You can't imprint a playing style because the players are unmotivated and Leonardo picks the team anyways
I've got my issues with Leonardo, but he doesn't pick the team. You can certainly imprint some patterns of play, certain discipline in positioning in a year. If a manager can't do that in 11 months, it's a problem. I'm not buying the players aren't motivated either, you can clearly see they are when they're playing. They're not emotionless just looking to cash the next check, but they're out there looking lost, not indifferent.
Most players haven't improved since Tuchel left. As a matter of fact you could make a case that some of them regressed - Mbappe wants to leave and most PSG players are mercenaries who don't give a hoot about being better.
You're talking out of your ass, there isn't a player in PSG aside from maybe Icardi that I would consider someone who doesn't give a hoot about being better, these are all elite players and it comes with the mentality of always wanting to be the best. As far as Mbappe, he was always going to leave eventually, I think it's unreasonable to ask a guy who's been playing in Ligue 1 since 17 and has the world at his feet to stay at the same club forever.