Think the fact that we started and ended the game with 5 central midfielders, 4 of which are primarily used for defensive duties says everything about our game.
We were facing a team that has won just once at their home this calendar year, and we decided to play 3 defenders, 5 Central midfielders. What kind of joke is that. And it's not like a CM of Jorginho's or Gundogan's ilk, 3 of those 5 are technically poor. Even if his reasoning was that we were looking to be a force in air in attacking set pieces,
1. they have Vestergaard- the tallest player in the league and
2. Relying on set pieces to score against Southampton! Really!!!
The defence is all over the place, 23 league goals conceded already and the 6th worst defensive record (just the bottom 5 have it worse). The players have no idea who to mark and their position is horrible.
The less said about our attack, the better. We seemed a better side in October, when we were not playing with Lukaku in the side. Had Rashford and Sanchez and Martial and Lingard and Mata and Pogba feeding the ball to them. The game was acceptable in more cases than none as well. So, what's the point of shifting back to these tactics? Now, I'm not saying that Lukaku shouldn't ever play, but let him come on the same wavelength with the team in training and then put him in the side. These guys have been playing together for 1.5 years and they still don't seem to know the strengths and weaknesses of their team mates.
But the biggest problem is the manager. The manager has the best view of the football in terms of players position, how high or deep they are. In the 2nd half, their defensive line was nearly at the halfway line. When you are having players like Rom and Martial/Rashford on the pitch use the fecking space behind their line to launch attacks. Instead of playing grounded passes, play an aerial ball over their defence. With the pace we are having, we are going to end up in a 1vs1 situation there. And in this aspect we missed Poba's form, and Mata and maybe Fred.
Finally there are those substitutions. Like for Like subs is just asking for fans to abuse you. Get Matic/McT off and get in an additional attacker instead of removing Rom and Rashford, especially. Get in Mata as Pogba was having a poor day and we needed a neat passer of the ball. Play a counter attacking football if you think its the best way, but have a clear idea, which we haven't had in any game this season
/rant