Racism incident in PSG v Istanbul match

hobbers

Full Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2013
Messages
28,128
But he wasn't exactly far away, and he was pointing right at him anyway


I was under the impression he says the offending words on the headset when the ref isn't nearby. And when the ref gets next to them Webo has already started shouting about being called a negro.
 

Chesterlestreet

Man of the crowd
Joined
Oct 19, 2012
Messages
19,524
Yeah, fair point. There’s something about using it in earshot of the person you’re describing that feels wrong.

How about if you and your friend were describing a new guy at work who shares a name with someone else of a different ethnicity.

“Have you met Paul yet? He’s a nice lad.”

“Which Paul? The black guy?”

Would that bother you at all? Would you think less of your friend for describing Paul in that way?
Hm.

I think I'd be more comfortable if the second guy said:

Which Paul? The guy with somewhat more melanin than the other Paul? Not that there's anything wrong with more - or even less - melanin...in fact, forget what I said. What I meant was: the guy who's slightly taller than the other Pau...no, wait - scratch that. I meant the guy who sometimes wears a black...I mean, not black...possibly very dark blue coat...no, wait, by "very dark" I mean not very light...not that light is better! Just...I mean, no - sorry, who is Paul? And what do you mean by "lad"? How do you know he identifies as a "lad", you prejudiced twat (not that there's anything wrong with twats or prejudice...)
 

Pogue Mahone

The caf's Camus.
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
133,779
Location
"like a man in silk pyjamas shooting pigeons
I shortened the proposition because even in that format it is too much to bear for most Turks.

As for Germany, even Germans agree, let alone foreigners with little knowledge of the country's history beyond WW2.

No qualms saying Turkey has changed for the better, although recent foreign policy actions suggest otherwise. Even if so, definitely not enough to take the moral high ground on racism issues.
You’re going on a bit of a tangent here but the idea that a country with a history of dubious foreign policy can’t call out racism is one of the dumber ideas in a thread full of dumb ideas. Should the English national team have kept quiet about the monkey noises aimed at their black players because of England’s colonial past?
 

Fener1907

Full Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2014
Messages
3,102
Location
Istanchester
I shortened the proposition because even in that format it is too much to bear for most Turks.

As for Germany, even Germans agree, let alone foreigners with little knowledge of the country's history beyond WW2.

No qualms saying Turkey has changed for the better, although recent foreign policy actions say otherwise. All in all it is not enough to take the moral high ground on racism issues.
Asking for elaboration on as bold a statement as "Turkey is one of the most racist countries out there" isn't tantamount to wanting to earn the moral high ground on racism issues.

And nothing that a few chest-beaters do to stoke their support base in times on economic uncertainty can even begin to truly undermine the legacy given to this country by its founder.
 

Nani Nana

Full Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2009
Messages
5,656
Supports
Whoever won the game
You’re going on a bit of a tangent here but the idea that a country with a history of dubious foreign policy can’t call out racism is one of the dumber ideas in a thread full of dumb ideas. Should the English national team have kept quiet about the monkey noises aimed at their black players because of England’s colonial past?
The theatricality does bother me. Rio Ferdinand was on the money when he refused to take part in Kick it Out campaigns and spoke out on England having to do their homework before lecturing other countries.

Anyone is free to denounce racism but there are instances when it does sound a bit rich and/or incoherent.

In this instance, credit to Basaksehir for employing a black assistant coach in the first place. Can't think of many out there.
 

Harry190

Bobby ten Hag
Joined
Apr 18, 2010
Messages
7,616
Location
Canada
It was the lino all along and the other guy got the whole thing in his face. Amazing.
 

Shane88

Actually Nostradamus
Joined
Jan 12, 2011
Messages
35,173
Location
Targaryen loyalist
Hm.

I think I'd be more comfortable if the second guy said:

Which Paul? The guy with somewhat more melanin than the other Paul? Not that there's anything wrong with more - or even less - melanin...in fact, forget what I said. What I meant was: the guy who's slightly taller than the other Pau...no, wait - scratch that. I meant the guy who sometimes wears a black...I mean, not black...possibly very dark blue coat...no, wait, by "very dark" I mean not very light...not that light is better! Just...I mean, no - sorry, who is Paul? And what do you mean by "lad"? How do you know he identifies as a "lad", you prejudiced twat (not that there's anything wrong with twats or prejudice...)
 

Cheimoon

Made of cheese
Scout
Joined
Jun 22, 2020
Messages
14,334
Location
Canada
Supports
no-one in particular
I’m genuinely curious here because we have posters like @Cheimoon saying they’re raising their kids never to mention the colour of someone’s skin in any circumstances. Which seems absolutely ludicrous to me. Do we need a new name for the Black Lives Matter movement?!?
Not never in any circumstances. My oldest daughter has friends with different skin colours, and of course she mentions that in relevant contexts, and of course it's visible when she draws her friends. We are not raising them to be colourblind: from research I've read, this does not reduce racism, and is in fact counterproductive. (In particular: if you don't notice race, you also can't notice racist behaviour in others.)

I just don't want my kids using race as an identifier. While there are many non-white people in my community, the majority is white, and so we would likely only single out non-white people by their skin colour. That way, we are implicitly confirming their otherness, and I don't want that. To my knowledge, that connects to how racism works from an unconscious bias point of view.
 

Olly Gunnar Solskjær

Marxist bacon-hating kebab-dodging Tinder rascal
Scout
Joined
Jan 26, 2008
Messages
36,895
Location
dreams can't be buy
Ok, let’s assume there are two new guys called Paul!

I’m genuinely curious here because we have posters like @Cheimoon saying they’re raising their kids never to mention the colour of someone’s skin in any circumstances. Which seems absolutely ludicrous to me. Do we need a new name for the Black Lives Matter movement?!?
I don't think anybody has said that the word "black" should never be used in any way and I assume @Cheimoon doesn't think that, but when in the context it's used seems unnecessary.

Like if I refer to a Caf poster saying something, "Let's listen to xxx because being black they've experienced it in real life before more than white people", I don't think they'd have a problem, whereas if I said "Let's hear what xxx, the black bloke, has to say." it would be a different story.
 

Pogue Mahone

The caf's Camus.
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
133,779
Location
"like a man in silk pyjamas shooting pigeons
The theatricality does bother me. Rio Ferdinand was on the money when he refused to take part in Kick it Out campaigns and spoke out on England having to do their homework before lecturing other countries.

Anyone is free to denounce racism but there are instances when it does sound a bit rich and/or incoherent.

In this instance, credit to Basaksehir for employing a black assistant coach in the first place. Can't think of many out there.
I just think lumping everyone of a specific nationality in together, in terms of their morals, is bordering on racism in itself. Turkey may be a country with lots of problematic ideoogies but for all we know the individuals involved are progressive, decent people. As you say, credit where it’s due for hiring a black assistant manager in the first place.
 

Amar__

Geriatric lover and empath
Joined
Sep 2, 2010
Messages
24,087
Location
Sarajevo
Supports
MK Dons
I think what that referee did is wrong, but I always found it far more offensive when people here compare Bale with monkey. It's definitely far worse insult than something like calling Demba Ba a black guy in that situation, but yet for some reason that's completely acceptable here, and in England by the looks of it.
 

Pogue Mahone

The caf's Camus.
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
133,779
Location
"like a man in silk pyjamas shooting pigeons
Not never in any circumstances. My oldest daughter has friends with different skin colours, and of course she mentions that in relevant contexts, and of course it's visible when she draws her friends. We are not raising them to be colourblind: from research I've read, this does not reduce racism, and is in fact counterproductive. (In particular: if you don't notice race, you also can't notice racist behaviour in others.)

I just don't want my kids using race as an identifier. While there are many non-white people in my community, the majority is white, and so we would likely only single out non-white people by their skin colour. That way, we are implicitly confirming their otherness, and I don't want that. To my knowledge, that connects to how racism works from an unconscious bias point of view.
That’s interesting but now how I’d approach it. I want my kids to acknowledge and discuss different ethnicities and help them learn and use the correct language when discussing something potentially sensitive like this. I don’t think ignoring or trying not to mention race when discussing their friends and peers is the best way to deal with it. I could be wrong though. I’m far from an expert and we’re all just muddling along here!
 

SER19

Full Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2008
Messages
12,567
Why does nobody seem to care that somebody from the bench called Romanians gypsies. Why are Istanbul not tweeting about this issue, why is Mbappe not? Genuine question.
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
65,597
Location
France
Why does nobody seem to care that somebody from the bench called Romanians gypsies. Why are Istanbul not tweeting about this issue, why is Mbappe not? Genuine question.
If it happened I care and Webo should be sanctioned but the issue is that the journalist that reported it was busy tweeting all night long and came up with that one today.
 

Sayros

Full Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2015
Messages
6,006
Supports
Paris Saint-Germain
Why does nobody seem to care that somebody from the bench called Romanians gypsies. Why are Istanbul not tweeting about this issue, why is Mbappe not? Genuine question.
Because it got completely swept under the rug for the most part, I doubt they even know about it. I wouldn't have known if I wasn't on this thread as I didn't hear it live, it's actually a worse offense than what happened with the Romanian referee.
 

Cheimoon

Made of cheese
Scout
Joined
Jun 22, 2020
Messages
14,334
Location
Canada
Supports
no-one in particular
That’s interesting but now how I’d approach it. I want my kids to acknowledge and discuss different ethnicities and help them learn and use the correct language when discussing something potentially sensitive like this. I don’t think ignoring or trying not to mention race when discussing their friends and peers is the best way to deal with it. I could be wrong though. I’m far from an expert and we’re all just muddling along here!
I know, right! At some point, I thought colourblindness would be a good thing - only to be corrected soon after. I read about racism whenever I come across stuff, but it's hard to know everything - plus insights change anyway. I think the most important thing, though, is to be very conscious and to try and get it right. That's anyway pretty much all you can do, short of becoming a racism specialist yourself. (Only so much time in life!)

I agree that those conversations are super important. We've also had chats about racism, and what it means and what she could do when she sees it. Similar for white privilege. (My youngest is too young for that; and my eldest is also below 10 - so they're not super deep discussions.) But I don't want to stress them out with the subject either, especially since my daughter has lots of non-white friends (to be clear, I'm saying non-white because they have different skin colours; I'm not trying to avoid the word 'black' at all costs), and she shouldn't worry about them unduly or start bothering them with it. Still, I do want her to be conscious of this - especially since she apparently tends to take on leadership roles in class, so she can make a difference. It's a fine balance!

Urgh, so much to consider as a parent. :houllier:
 

mancan92

Full Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2011
Messages
10,211
Location
Loughborough university
Why does nobody seem to care that somebody from the bench called Romanians gypsies. Why are Istanbul not tweeting about this issue, why is Mbappe not? Genuine question.
Clearly people care but my guess is most don't know since that's not what the press have reported about. I and many here have said that it's horrible and whoever said it should be in trouble
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
65,597
Location
France
Because it got completely swept under the rug for the most part, I doubt they even know about it. I wouldn't have known if I wasn't on this thread as I didn't hear it live, it's actually a worse offense than what happened with the Romanian referee.
In the video that I heard, it's not Webo's voice. Someone said in my country roumanians are gypsies though, I think that it's the one who said, "it's champions league, not Romania."
 

UweBein

Creator of the Worst Analogy on the Internet.
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
3,729
Location
Köln
Supports
Chelsea
....To keep using your logic, is Germany one of the most racist countries out there?
Yes, yes and yes.
Most people don’t know, but Germany (post WW II) had former nazis serving as chancellor and as a head of a federal state. Lot‘s of nazis had a successful career in the legal sector (many judges and state prosecutors), in the industry (anyone driving a VW?)... unfortunately the cold war got in the way of a proper punishment of a lot of nazis. Helmut Kohl was in my eyes a cold blooded racist - chancellor of Germany for 16 years until 1998. It got better since, there are many positive developments even among conservatives now. But, there is still racism in Germany. Sorry, for sidetracking the thread ;-)
 

SER19

Full Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2008
Messages
12,567
If it happened I care and Webo should be sanctioned but the issue is that the journalist that reported it was busy tweeting all night long and came up with that one today.
Its very very clear on the video assuming the video isn't doctored which it doesn't seem to be.
 

Valencia's Left Foot

New Member
Newbie
Joined
May 19, 2017
Messages
562
Supports
Austin FC, USMNT, Three Lions
Not never in any circumstances. My oldest daughter has friends with different skin colours, and of course she mentions that in relevant contexts, and of course it's visible when she draws her friends. We are not raising them to be colourblind: from research I've read, this does not reduce racism, and is in fact counterproductive. (In particular: if you don't notice race, you also can't notice racist behaviour in others.)
This mindest is Critical Race Theory - 101. Sounds like you just finished reading "White Fragility".
 

hobbers

Full Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2013
Messages
28,128
Why does nobody seem to care that somebody from the bench called Romanians gypsies. Why are Istanbul not tweeting about this issue, why is Mbappe not? Genuine question.
Because it hasn't been widely reported and because the other angle is far more inflammatory in todays hypersensitive climate.

But if Webo really was calling the entire referee team gypsies from the get go, then his crimes are by far the worst and deserving of sanctions.
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
65,597
Location
France
Its very very clear on the video assuming the video isn't doctored which it doesn't seem to be.
But it doesn't sound like Webo, it does sound like the guy that was just next to the fourth referee though and that guy said other weird things. I posted the video but don't know if people can see it, he sounds like a proper weapon.

PS: I'm not saying that Webo didn't, just that in the videos I saw it was someone else.
 

Cheimoon

Made of cheese
Scout
Joined
Jun 22, 2020
Messages
14,334
Location
Canada
Supports
no-one in particular
This mindest is Critical Race Theory - 101. You must have just gotten done reading "White Fragility".
I did read it, but it's not that helpful in my view. But if you're trying to make a bigger point or have suggestions for how I can do better, I'm always interested. :)
 

SER19

Full Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2008
Messages
12,567
But it doesn't sound like Webo, it does sound like the guy that was just next to the fourth referee though and that guy said other weird things. I posted the video but don't if people can see it, he sounds like a proper weapon.
But if people's primary concern is racism it doesn't matter if it was Webo or not. How are high profile people and associations getting away with this utter hypocrisy, its a disgusting comment and patently offensive
 

Pogue Mahone

The caf's Camus.
Joined
Feb 22, 2006
Messages
133,779
Location
"like a man in silk pyjamas shooting pigeons
I know, right! At some point, I thought colourblindness would be a good thing - only to be corrected soon after. I read about racism whenever I come across stuff, but it's hard to know everything - plus insights change anyway. I think the most important thing, though, is to be very conscious and to try and get it right. That's anyway pretty much all you can do, short of becoming a racism specialist yourself. (Only so much time in life!)

I agree that those conversations are super important. We've also had chats about racism, and what it means and what she could do when she sees it. Similar for white privilege. (My youngest is too young for that; and my eldest is also below 10 - so they're not super deep discussions.) But I don't want to stress them out with the subject either, especially since my daughter has lots of non-white friends (to be clear, I'm saying non-white because they have different skin colours; I'm not trying to avoid the word 'black' at all costs), and she shouldn't worry about them unduly or start bothering them with it. Still, I do want her to be conscious of this - especially since she apparently tends to take on leadership roles in class, so she can make a difference. It's a fine balance!

Urgh, so much to consider as a parent. :houllier:
:lol: Yeah, it’s tough. I’m optimistic that it won’t be too big a deal for my kids. The best way to avoid being racist is to grow up with an ethnically diverse peer group. And the difference in terms of diversity between Ireland now and my own childhood in the 1980s is enormous. So if I managed to find a way to be a reasonably sensitive and tolerant person I don’t have too many worries about my kids achieving the same.
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
65,597
Location
France
But if people's primary concern is racism it doesn't matter if it was Webo or not. How are high profile people and associations getting away with this utter hypocrisy, its a disgusting comment and patently offensive
If you read the thread you will realize that it's not people primary concern and that information only came out after most people had already posted. But it's clear that you are trying to create your own outrage.
 

Fener1907

Full Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2014
Messages
3,102
Location
Istanchester
Yes, yes and yes.
Most people don’t know, but Germany (post WW II) had former nazis serving as chancellor and as a head of a federal state. Lot‘s of nazis had a successful career in the legal sector (many judges and state prosecutors), in the industry (anyone driving a VW?)... unfortunately the cold war got in the way of a proper punishment of a lot of nazis. Helmut Kohl was in my eyes a cold blooded racist - chancellor of Germany for 16 years until 1998. It got better since, there are many positive developments even among conservatives now. But, there is still racism in Germany. Sorry, for sidetracking the thread ;-)
Atatürk's one demand on his deathbed was that Turkey wouldn't join WWII. Anything I've ever read about it, this included, will forever make me thankful to him for that alone.
 

Cheimoon

Made of cheese
Scout
Joined
Jun 22, 2020
Messages
14,334
Location
Canada
Supports
no-one in particular
:lol: Yeah, it’s tough. I’m optimistic that it won’t be too big a deal for my kids. The best way to avoid being racist is to grow up with an ethnically diverse peer group. And the difference in terms of diversity between Ireland now and my own childhood in the 1980s is enormous. So if I managed to find a way to be a reasonably sensitive and tolerant person I don’t have too many worries about my kids achieving the same.
Yeah, that too. Diversity will be completely normal for my kids, and 'interracial' couples are also super common (which it wasn't where and when I grew up). They'll probably be better people than me without even trying. :cool: (Well, in this regard. I'm sure I'll claim my moral superiority on most other things when I'm of boomer age. ;) )
 

Nani Nana

Full Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2009
Messages
5,656
Supports
Whoever won the game
Yes, yes and yes.
Most people don’t know, but Germany (post WW II) had former nazis serving as chancellor and as a head of a federal state. Lot‘s of nazis had a successful career in the legal sector (many judges and state prosecutors), in the industry (anyone driving a VW?)... unfortunately the cold war got in the way of a proper punishment of a lot of nazis. Helmut Kohl was in my eyes a cold blooded racist - chancellor of Germany for 16 years until 1998. It got better since, there are many positive developments even among conservatives now. But, there is still racism in Germany. Sorry, for sidetracking the thread ;-)
None of them came close to Adenauer the great Kölner ;)
 

Acheron

Full Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2016
Messages
2,871
Supports
Real Madrid
I guess it varies from country to country but “black” is a perfectly acceptable word to use as a descriptor in lots of countries. Provided there is a reasonable context for using it. Obviously, using it unnecessarily is a dick move. African-American only gets used in America (and always seemed a weird one to me, as though being black means you’re automatically American!) so what other words could he have used?
I think when you say the 'black guy' or something like 'the black one' it makes it impersonal and thus rude if it's an environment you're expected to be more formal and/or educated. You could describe someone as the man/person/gentleman with black skin and that makes it a lot less likely to be interpreted as something derogatory. Anyway I wouldn't qualify anyone for being racist just from those lines but in language and communication there are more variables when you deliver the message like voice tone, attitude, overall demeanor, etc. and like you pointed out it's also varies depending on the country and language.

Anyway this whole thing definitely blew out of proportion and in a case like that where someone gets upset because of you refering to him as the 'black one' I would consider offering a sincere apologize would be more than enough to solve the issue. So it's crazy how everything escalated like it did.
 

TrustInOle

Full Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2019
Messages
2,467
Location
Manchester
So I agree they should all be more careful and I hope they've learned to be more sensitive. Next time better to avoid this in such a setting.

I feel this topic just like the Cavani topic has a bit of a feeling of enforcing cultures because the english term n** is related to other non-abusive words that just sound similar and also that the Anglo American (or western liberal worldview) is enforced upon others who maybe dont share this view. Maybe in Romania, russia, Poland or japan it's perfectly fine to describe people as black white yellow... so theoretically we could also ask you or black americans or black brits to understand that in the wider world people in Romania or japan just refer to black people as black, not? Who's right who's wrong? But obviously you'll think you are right.

To go further to make the point, not that I advocate for it. The n-word and the taboo of using racial markers is mainly in the liberal west... go to asia and some people will use the n-word (and not some local translation but literally the n-word). They dont mean anything bad and have nothing to do with police brutality or slavery. So why not also understand this wider world.
You've completely lost me and clearly not read any other posts I've made in this thread?

What am I thinking I am right about? That if someone goes into a different cultural setting professionally they should at least have education and respect towards that culture? I would say the same thing to someone going to Poland, Russia, Japan or Romania.

So what's you point against me exactly?
 

calodo2003

Flaming Full Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2014
Messages
41,743
Location
Florida
Yeah if the ref would come out and explain and apologize I'd be fine with it.
I absolutely understand that Ba or wome were fuming. It's just no need for social media to pile on the official and crucify him for sth he didnt intend to do.


Shouldn't use a racial description in the face. I would mind if my colleague told another colleague "the asian guy will handle this" or if my boss said "hi asian guy come over". But if a colleague tells the delivery guy "yeah the asian guy there" just to be efficient I wouldnt mind and even if I did I can also understand why he described me like that. but then again it's a football pitch not a business setting.

So I agree they should all be more careful and I hope they've learned to be more sensitive. Next time better to avoid this in such a setting.

I feel this topic just like the Cavani topic has a bit of a feeling of enforcing cultures because the english term n** is related to other non-abusive words that just sound similar and also that the Anglo American (or western liberal worldview) is enforced upon others who maybe dont share this view. Maybe in Romania, russia, Poland or japan it's perfectly fine to describe people as black white yellow... so theoretically we could also ask you or black americans or black brits to understand that in the wider world people in Romania or japan just refer to black people as black, not? Who's right who's wrong? But obviously you'll think you are right.

To go further to make the point, not that I advocate for it. The n-word and the taboo of using racial markers is mainly in the liberal west... go to asia and some people will use the n-word (and not some local translation but literally the n-word). They dont mean anything bad and have nothing to do with police brutality or slavery. So why not also understand this wider world.
Mostly agree, but it is the official’s business setting. It’s not a Sunday pub league, it’s a multi billion dollar company showcasing its product.
 

SportingCP96

emotional range of a teaspoon
Joined
Feb 17, 2014
Messages
9,873
Supports
Sporting Clube de Portugal
Why does nobody seem to care that somebody from the bench called Romanians gypsies. Why are Istanbul not tweeting about this issue, why is Mbappe not? Genuine question.
Because you can’t be racist towards people who’s skin color is white. According to society at least.
 

Jippy

Sleeps with tramps, bangs jacuzzis, dirty shoes
Staff
Joined
Nov 19, 2009
Messages
57,366
Location
Jet fuel doesn't melt steel beams
I feel like its much more difficult for kids today to be at ease with friends and other social circles. When I was a kid, we friends used to call each other names (on appearance, weight etc), and it was all in good fun without any malicious intent. We dint have to carry the weight of being politically correct all the time.

Im not saying that racism or discrimination isnt a serious problem, but nowadays people like to make a mountain out of a molehill. It isnt wrong to identify a person based on their skin colour, if there is not intent to discriminate against that person. But people like to feel good about themselves by jumping on an easy target, rather than actually doing anything constructive. Case in point being Mbappe-he plays for a club that is owned by a country that practices modern day slavery (Qatar). He has nothing to say about that, which shows me that he only cares as long as the money isnt affected.
Even if people of different skin colours are telling you that they find it offensive?

Also are you saying Mbappe can't object to racist abuse because PSG has Qatari owners? That's utter drivel even for this thread.
 

Nr.7

New Member
Newbie
Joined
May 27, 2017
Messages
341
I thought they walked off the pitch yesterday in support of Luka Doncic who got called a “bithc ass white boy” without any sanctions for the player that said it.