What he does with Austria is irrelevant. Moyes did well with West Ham. Still not suited for top clubs.
Ralf Rangnick | Austria manager
- Thread starter Livewire1974
- Start date
Blinkers
Anti-ralfers quaking in their boots
Es kommt nach Hause (aber mit österreichischem Akzent)
Es kommt nach Hause (aber mit österreichischem Akzent)
Not sure why these threads are still going in the United forum. Any chance of moving Rangnick and Austria to the FF mods? @Solius
Good shout.
Thanks! see I’m future mod material clearly
I'll put in a good word!
I mean obviously none of this assessing or whatever the feck people thought Ralf was doing the last 6 months instead of his official job was actually happening but hypothetically Carrick could have filled ETH in on whatever he thoguht he needed to know. We didn't need to miss out on top 4 to pass some notes about the squad onto the next manager.
Because some people don't like speculative fan fictions. Ralf wasn't and isn't doing any of that shit.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing.That post is over a month old!
(not sure if serious)Not sure if serious.
Not a case of hindsight though. Been reading similar for months and saying for months that he was simply just the manager and that's it. There was no grand plan, no bigger pitcure, no assessments, no audits, no dossiers. Just a bad Interim hire that people created a fanciful narrative around.
I am sorry for not being Nostradamus. Feck me Rangnick lives rent free in some of your minds.
I think it was fair for people to assume there was more to it, because of how incredibly stupid the other option was. He is known for building clubs and is among the best in the world at it, meanwhile he is known to only work as a manager in long term projects.
So with all the talk from United of a rebuild etc, the idea that they would get Rangnick, of all people, to come in only to be a interim and with a group of players that pretty much are the antithesis of his playing style, simply seemed to clueless and daft to be true. Yet here we are.
I don't think so. This whole idea that United's DoF would hire Rangnick to basically do his own job, but on a consultancy level was always bordering on delusional.
I might be remembering it wrong and be wide of the mark but wasn’t that exactly what the club said his role was? Maybe believing anything the club says is delusional at this point though I suppose!
Read the rest. Hiring Rangnick only as a stop gap was so incredibly stupid of an idea that it seemed mad.
When you have the options "stupid" and "completely illogical" for an explanation, then "stupid" almost always wins.
Bang on
I had to laugh when I was hearing or reading people say he was there to give notes on the players to ETH
The problem with this speculation and most of the Rangnick 'support' here is that it required ignoring lots of stuff, actual statements made by people, reports in the press, etc.
Rangnick said he was hired because United were conceding too many goals, and his main goal as interim was to stop that. He said that for him to be successful they'd have to get top 4 and push far in the cups. It was reported earlier this year that consultancy plans were on hold so that he could focus on coaching, that the club asked him to focus on coaching and getting top 4. It was reported early on that he was the one who sought the consultancy, not United. It was reported that the details of the consultancy hadn't been figured out, and if I recall, Rangnick confirmed that he hadn't talked to the club about what this consultancy would entail.
There's no way to reconcile these statement with a 'Rangnick is hired to rebuild the club' narrative unless you claim he's just lying for no reason.
This plus the fact all of those statements and reports were routinely posted to counter the speculation and those posters were ignored too (or belittled and basically told they were stupid and didn't understand football/ see the bigger picture).
I'm pretty sure you were pointing it out for months (amongst others).
It was mass delusion based on willful ignorance for the most part.
The likeliest scenario was always that "the consultancy" was just a guaranteed paycheck for Rangnick, so he wouldn't be at risk of ending up unemployed after quitting his job for a few months at United.
Well he was certainly living in the minds of many on here the last 6 months with the amount of fan fictions people created about what he has been doing and what he will be doing based on feck all.
Not really, people didnt pay attention and let their imaginations run away from them.
When we were initially linked with him the reports said he'd only leave Moscow if he had a guaranteed longer term role to replace the one he was leaving (eg £££), couple that with United only confirming he would be a ''consultant'' in the official statement when he was hired. And it was obvious the consultancy only existed to get him on board as Interim manager and would likely not amount to much or peter out (as it has). Yet on here you had people thinking he would be the de facto DOF, he was rebuilding the club from the ground up, audits, assessments, dossiers. Nonsense repeated often enough that it became fact for some.
Last edited:
No when he was hired the official statement only stated he would be a consultant, but other than that his future role was pretty vague.
Thank feck for that. An end to that damn awful thread. Now they can focus on drooling over his Austria performances.
The first time I posted in the other thread (because I don't really care that much about Ralf).
Was in response to this post.
"The consultancy thing - as reported at the time - was a sweetener to get him to leave his long term contract at Lokomotiv. Also, as reported at the time and since, nobody has any idea what Rangnick's "upstairs" gig will actually entail.
Rangnick himself has publicly stated that he has no idea what his consultancy role will involve or what his day-to-day will be, or how much weight his words will have. We'll more than likely be paying him 6 figures to pick up the phone twice a month a thousand miles from Manchester.
The idea that we got him as a consultant first and an interim second is not at all supported by reports, reason or Rangnick himself. And yet its the people who have paid attention to the reports and to reason and to Rangnick himself that "don't get it." "
https://www.redcafe.net/threads/ral...ger-does-anyone-rate-him.467305/post-28768693
That was in late April but certain posters continued to ignore all sense (and reports and evidence to the contrary) to push their own fantastical narrative FOR WEEKS while simultaneously telling anyone who opposed their agenda that they were basically stupid.
Yeah it got pretty nasty at times if you didn't drink the Rangnick kool-aid and dared suggest he won't have much of a role beyond the season. You'd like to think some of those posters now realize they were actually the ones being a bit thick but I doubt it.
Which makes the decision even more baffling. Why go to such length to get him for this job, when he is a terrible fit for that job. Anyone with any knowledge of German football would know his strengths AND especially his weaknesses.
Makes Murtough seem completely clueless.
Fantasy: Rangnick is exposing all these players for the useless crap they are.
Reality: Rangnick saying he can see McTominay being United's captain in a few years.
Reality: Rangnick saying he can see McTominay being United's captain in a few years.
Yeah it took a while for it dawn on some of them that it was all nonsense.
They couldn't see the forest for the bigger picture.
So over the past decade, Rangnick spent, what, 2 years in a coaching job? And the rest he spent in a front office job, building up Hoffenheim and then the Red Bull monstrosity. By last winter he'd been a coach for like 2 months in the last, what 9 years? How exactly did United think this was the guy to rescue this season? The whole point of hiring him should have been the consultancy gig, whatever form that took - if United were smart, that's shadow DoF - instead they hired literally an EX manager to be only a manager?
He once shook the hands of Klopp, Tuchel and Nagelsmann though.
As I've said in other threads, if you think of things in a United States business sense, Rangnick was brought in as a hatchet man: figure out what role everyone has, how competent they are in it, and whether it's possible to improve it. And then fire everyone obsolete/underperforming before the next guy comes in, so that the air is clear for them and they can move forward and they then hire a nicer, more encouraging manager to try to get things moving in the right direction. Look at who was fired, and who "left" their roles over the season. It's pretty obvious what Rangnick did for us.
Sounds strange but this is United were talking about
Like I said, baffling and makes one wonder if Murtough is completely clueless.
If you look at who left a role, you'll find the name of one Ralf Rangnick, who left his job as consultant before it even began.
You don't think all the structural changes had more to do with the new DoF who only really started in the last year and the new CEO who only started in what February?
It's been reported by a few reliable sources now that Rangnick had very little if any input on changes upstairs. And why would he he was simply the first team manager and nothing more.
After the abysmal season we just had it looks like Arnold and Murtagh decided to clean house and get rid of anyone who's underperformed in their role which of course included Rangnick.
Murtough was the one who wanted Rangnick. Clearly he didn't do any homework .
Or he thought (wrongly) that Ralf would keep himself in check for 6 months, even Mourinho would have done that ffs
Nobody thinks hiring Rangnick wasn’t a mistake, it’s righted now let’s scrub him from memory. It’s what he deserves