brilliant postLast 6 games:
Liverpool - 5 offsides
Burnley - 0 offsides
Watford - 0 offsides
City - 2 offsides
Villa - 1 offsides
Wolves - 1 offsides
It was only really the Liverpool game. And just looking at them:
From Pogba at 9' - Pogba could have released it earlier. But, equally, Rashford could have anticipated the extra touches.
Bruno at 35' - Couldn't see on the TV clearly how far offside he was, but this one was probably Rashford's fault because the pass was one touch
Pogba at 39' - Good pass by Pogba, probably wrong to be given offside
AWB at 40' - AWB delayed the pass unnecessarily
Pogba at 84' - Just a bit unlucky
Sure, Rashford could have done better. But this is what happens sometimes when you try to play close to the edge.
Rashford's job was to stretch the play and force Liverpool's high backline back by about 5 or 10 yards. And you know what? He achieved it. 4 of the 5 offsides happened in the first half. Klopp visibly dropped his defensive line back to stop the threat.
Rashford and the offside conundrum
- Thread starter RashyForPM
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran hold a long overdue conversation about United's awful league form with 1 win in 7. They discuss a disappointing draw at Bournemouth, a not so disappointing draw against Liverpool and a crushing defeat at Chelsea - Is time nearly over for Erik Ten Hag?
Then in a special second half of the pod, Nik welcomes Natalie ( https://twitter.com/natalie_17) to discuss the fortunes of Manchester United Women as they booked a place in the FA Cup Final after a historic first ever win vs. Chelsea.
The offsides worry me less than his general inability to control the football and pass it to a teammate
Even if rashford was onside for every breakaway he gets he'd still find a way to loose control of the ball or run it into a blind alley.. oh and the rare chance he does get a shot off?? Hes blasting it at the keeper for an easy save.
Yeah - just the 21 goals from 39 starts last season. And just the 14 goals from 29 starts this season.
But our 23-year-old who is the best striker to EVER come through our academy in 140-years always 'loses control of the ball and runs into blind alleys.' Caf logic.
Last edited:
I concur, the abuse he gets is ludicrous. Its almost as if unless a striker is scoring a goal a game they must be useless.
And the offside flag was incorrect.
This is seriously not a problem or a flaw in his game, it’s a major asset of his that he’s on the move and looking to get in behind so often.
You really saying rashford has been clinical this season? Hes squandered so many easy clear chances and he creates so many oppertunities.. those stats you listed are decent on paper.. but watching the games? He should be putting upway better numbers. Hes been terrible in the final third for a while now
We are always a better team - a much better team - with Rashford on the pitch.
For me the whole thing where if Rashford touches the ball ANYWHERE in the final third then all other team mates immediately become redundant 95% of the time is my biggest problem with his game
Regardless of how people rate him he is nowhere near good enough to justify such a high level of selfishness. Yes he is capable of scoring but I think the team might create more without him in the team
Regardless of how people rate him he is nowhere near good enough to justify such a high level of selfishness. Yes he is capable of scoring but I think the team might create more without him in the team
Does that say a lot about our team or Rashford ? We obviously are better and he is a very good player but even when he’s having a stinker he rarely stands out because other players are worse.
Anyway back to the topic of the thread he is not offside that much and is obviously a lot better on the left than the number 9 so his timing of his runs aren’t the best but on the left he doesn’t have to worry about it as much
Someone teach him the fecking offside rule.
He must be averaging the most offsides per game in Europe for the past couple of years?
He just seems out of sync completely
Lag.
Let's hope he can get it fixed and have 1000 Mbits up and running.
He was shocking again
Because he's become complacent knowing he'll play every game and his work-rate is astonishingly poor.
He needs benching for a while.
Greenwood right now is a better option and in my opinion already a better player then Rashford. As a professional player I’ve never seen someone be offside so much I just expect it every time the ball is played out to him.
I would drop him even behind Martial. Greenwood should start over him and I would rather see Martial get some minutes before resorting to Rashford. He's been so poor in general play for so long, its crazy how many chances he gets.
It's quite ironic to say he has been so poor in general play for so long, then say Martial should play ahead of him.in current form. his starting place role days are numbered
No its not. Hes been worse than Martial in general play this season.
Pretty much. He's just not on it at all currently. Totally off the pace. I wouldn't be starting him right now, bring him in off the bench, it's not like we don't have other options.
Still wouldn't be rushing to play Martial of all people in his place though.
I want Martial out ASAP. Maybe Newcadtle would be desparate enough to take him and his salary.
Martial does not even have a 'general play' much this season..
I’d rather the minutes went to Mason or Elanga. Martial is still a better player than both (on his top form) but he has no business starting in a pressing side. It’s just replacing one problem with another and on that kind of money you should be a nailed on starter. I’d rather we gave the minutes to players who we really believe can grow and thrive in this new set up and a cut a huge wage off the books
Nor does Rashford, and he's played more minutes. Go figure.
Go figure that Martial does not have a future here.
Rashford will be played into form and rightly so.
People seem to forget Rashford spent a very long time out with his broken back and shoulder injury, I think he'll need time, trying to say Martial should Start instead is absolutely moronic, Martial needs to be binned,
I'd have him behind so many players in our squad right now for one of the front 4 positions. Sancho, Bruno, Ronaldo, Pogba, Cavani, VdB, Greenwood, Lingard even, arguably Martial would really suit the 4222, then you've got youngsters like Diallo, Hannibal and a few others I'd like to see get some chances.
Wanting to start Martial ahead of Rashford.
An injured Rashford is twice the player as we saw last season.
He’s just really out of form and low on confidence. I’m not worried about him, give Greenwood a few starts and ease Rashford back into form.
An injured Rashford is twice the player as we saw last season.
He’s just really out of form and low on confidence. I’m not worried about him, give Greenwood a few starts and ease Rashford back into form.
Played into form? His general play has been borderline atrocious for many months. You're probably right about who has a future over the other but you don't have half a leg to stand on if you're trying to insinuate that Rashford hasn't been shite, and no better than Martial, over an extended period of time.
Rashford looks disinterested, sloppy and lacking in confidence. But at least with Rashford, he got closer the goal and gave troubles to opponents with pace at times.
Martial hardly ever got into the box anymore nowadays.
like it or not rashford will be important for the new boss as he has the physicality to make up for ronaldo. greenwood, martial, cavani dont have the same.
It’s work rate. He doesn’t do anything else off the ball right now other than attempt to run in behind.
Now that’s great having that as an outlet, especially when it’s effective. But defenders become aware that’s all he does and it makes the offside trap easier.
Needs to up his game. I mentioned in another thread lately that I hope Ralf doesn’t play guys for the sake of it. We need to rid ourselves of that mentality and keep everyone keen to fight. Sadly at the moment it doesn’t seem like Marcus has a lot of that in him.
Nope. Not even close.
This season he’s joint 7th in the Premier league. A whole load of players with the same number means the player with next fewest offsides is 12th.
Last season he had the joint fourth most offsides (with Timo Werner)
Jesus wept.
I raised an eyebrow too.
His drop in form started a long time ago, many blamed it on his injury which certainly played a part, but it’s no coincidence his off field distractions/ exploits created a different Marcus Rashford....an arrogant almost untouchable aura, which is reflected in his lack of effort and what I call walking playmaker style which doesn’t suit him.
I still think Rangnick will get the best out of him but he needs to work and focus on his game.
I still think Rangnick will get the best out of him but he needs to work and focus on his game.
He is not a very intelligent footballer sadly.