play our most inform forward on the right for 65 mins with forwards like ronaldo,elanga,van de beek !
Rashford - New contract or sell?
- Thread starter Frank Grimes
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran hold a long overdue conversation about United's awful league form with 1 win in 7. They discuss a disappointing draw at Bournemouth, a not so disappointing draw against Liverpool and a crushing defeat at Chelsea - Is time nearly over for Erik Ten Hag?
Then in a special second half of the pod, Nik welcomes Natalie ( https://twitter.com/natalie_17) to discuss the fortunes of Manchester United Women as they booked a place in the FA Cup Final after a historic first ever win vs. Chelsea.
- Status
It will be a tough sell to Rashford when Sancho is on 350k allegedly. Whether it's more like 300k, that's very high.
Giggs played a CL final on the right, he also played a few other games there from memory. He understood the position well and the requirement of it. Rashford just doesn't, becauee he's not a very inteliigent player, way too one dimensional.
Any player with a basic understanding of playing on the wing should be able to play either side if required. But as usual it's like he doesn't even bother because he doesn't want to be there.
He's getting a new deal and I'm fine with that.
I am not sure about selling him but we have a fundamental issue with wages which unfortunately he is part of. On balance I do not think his performances warrant the likely figure he will get.
This is an overall problem which needs addressing by the higher ups as it is not sustainable
This is an overall problem which needs addressing by the higher ups as it is not sustainable
Giggs was always rubbish on the right wing. We had all this back then with him playing there occasionally too. Short memories on here.
The hatred for Rashford is nothing short of Ridiculous. It's a good job he's managed to find his scoring boots this season somewhat as nobody else has.
He wasn't great there but at least he tried.
Rashford plays there like a spoilt child who thinks if he does it badly he won't be asked to do it again.
We should pay less for a week and more on performance rated as a team. You get £a weekly, plus £b if we win, or £c if we draw, £d on the title at the end of season, or £e top 4 at the end of the season, £f a cup, something like that. No individual goals, which could end up a striker always shooting when there is a better placed teammate. Play for the team to win.
He's not good enough, we should have a minimum standard that's better than him.
He offers basically nothing beyond goals and he's not doing much of that either.
He offers basically nothing beyond goals and he's not doing much of that either.
Really is bizarre to see this kind of abuse from our own 'fans'Does money warrant or excuse United players being abused the most in the league? United can and does pay players more wages than other clubs - pick your qualms with the employer and the nature of the market, not the employee.
So the club makes a series of poor decisions which leave no choice but to play Rashford through injury week in week out worsening his physical condition, and his own 'fans'
- blame him for not performing through the long term injury
- blame him for being unavailable during the time he takes off undergo surgery and recover
- label the time he takes off as a half-season holiday
- abuse the feck out of him for the club's mistakes along with his own
- abuse him further for being not being 'strong' enough to deal with the abuse by using his millions
- abuse him even further for having the audacity to speak out about the abuse he was getting
There's criticizing a player for not doing enough, and then there's this. Classic victim-blaming.
No wonder he was having some mental struggles last season
What a perfect illustration of how using numbers without context makes it easy to build a narrative.Does money warrant or excuse United players being abused the most in the league? United can and does pay players more wages than other clubs - pick your qualms with the employer and the nature of the market, not the employee.
So the club makes a series of poor decisions which leave no choice but to play Rashford through injury week in week out worsening his physical condition, and his own 'fans'
- blame him for not performing through the long term injury
- blame him for being unavailable during the time he takes off undergo surgery and recover
- label the time he takes off as a half-season holiday
- abuse the feck out of him for the club's mistakes along with his own
- abuse him further for being not being 'strong' enough to deal with the abuse by using his millions
- abuse him even further for having the audacity to speak out about the abuse he was getting
There's criticizing a player for not doing enough, and then there's this. Classic victim-blaming.
The whole posts reads like something written by Rashie's brother before he called PSG to ask for a bigger bag.
Just as much as your own narrative vs rashford. btw ronaldo is first but its rashfords pr to u.
Can I reverse my vote, he is transformed.
Who would even be able to afford him?The poll goes to show how far he sunk but he's rising right back to the top now. Close if not better than his form at LW before that back injury.
2 goals and a motm performance playing down the right too.
The poll shows something but it ain't that
The Twitter admin will be dining off that until Christmas.
Definitely sell. He's championship quality
250m from PSG
Only scores against crap teams and in big games and medium games, sell him.
New contract easy choice on current form
He is on fire. Feel dirty for doubting him last year
400k per week incoming! 
That's the big question isn't it. How many other teams could afford him ?
Should have made him sign a new deal before his stock rose again! 
Well done Marcus, well deserved!
Well done Marcus, well deserved!There we have it folks. 85% of the caf no nothing.
Including me.
Including me.
he’s really made a fool of a lot people! To those that voted sell, are there any that wouldn’t change their vote if they could?
Glad I was in the 14%.
Majority of fans just follow what mainstream media says.
Majority of fans just follow what mainstream media says.
14,8% know their stuff
TBF he was on a should be sold level for a couple of years, and this was a recurring issue with several players at the club because we were never ruthless with anyone. Now he's earning a new contract as it should be with all players.
I am such an idiot. Sorry Marcus. Should have trusted you
Some on here really would forgive and forget anything. I hope you don't make any important long-term decisions at your job
Good free-kick, I can't deny. Though where has that quality been in his last 100+ free-kicks? He's been living off that one he scored against Chelsea in the cup years ago.
Second goal mainly came down to a defensive and goalkeeping disaster.
I wouldn't get carried away against a poor Wales team. New contract on the same wage, or none at all.
Second goal mainly came down to a defensive and goalkeeping disaster.
I wouldn't get carried away against a poor Wales team. New contract on the same wage, or none at all.
Never doubted him. (actually i nearly gave up hope for him last season under Rangnick)...
but still wouldn't have voted "sell" in a million years.
but still wouldn't have voted "sell" in a million years.
Same. I am also glad you don’t make any decisions at all at United.
Just evaluate at the end of the season. We just have too many that can’t be trusted to maintain their form. I agree with your part on renewing at the same wages, but I don’t think that is going to happen, unfortunately.
Close thread. Our Rashy ain't going nowhere. Hopefully he's a worthy face of United for the next decade (amongst other stars of course).
I don't think it is the mainstream media, they tend to like him. It's just caf hipsters and I bet there's a lot of overlap with the people who don't like Bruno either.
Still want him out. Jeez it was only against Wales and Iran.
- Status