Rashford

Should we sell or reintegrate Rashford to the United squad?


  • Total voters
    656
  • Poll closed .
We came 15th last year which could easily have been 17th. And have only brought in 1 player this summer.

We're very definitely still in the pain and it won't be "short term".

But sort of agree that aside!

I meant to use present tense rather than past tense - the pain will continue for a while and the signings have to be consistently better for a period of years to get us out of this mess. By short term I mean over the span of a season or two, because the context is repeated failures over the span of a decade plus.
 
There’s zero chance he’s ever in a match day squad again. We’ve stripped him of his number 10 shirt as well. This will drag on throughout the window, can see a late loan move with us subsidising part of his wages again unfortunately.

If the idea is to pay more than half his wages while on loan, I would say no and let him rot with the academy players.
 
Can see him getting close to going to Barca with it falling through due to registration issues
Can you explain this - with them getting shunned by Nico Williams surely this opens up the door?
If the idea is to pay more than half his wages while on loan, I would say no and let him rot with the academy players.
we still need goals. I can see him as Cunhas sub and scoring for us
 
Can you explain this - with them getting shunned by Nico Williams surely this opens up the door?

we still need goals. I can see him as Cunhas sub and scoring for us
Nico Williams seems to have fallen through due to them not being able to make guarantees about his registration to the player... We're not loaning him out without full wage coverage so I doubt they can afford that

If he was actually reintegrated into the team I'd guess it'd be as a CF given how weak our options there are. Sancho also technically hasn't met Amorim yet so they might always get along .. and he does fit the inside 10 roles more than as a winger. But there's too much bad blood there
 
Obviously a lot of frustration on here that he played for a top 5 club/UCL football last season whilst the guy who banished him could only get 7 wins in 27.

The personal hatred towards Rashford is just bizarre, even scrolling his twitter comments and it’s just abuse
 
It’s far more likely than him returning to United when he doesn’t have a squad number nor a locker.

I can just picture a world where we can't find a move for him and after about a month of messages from his camp about how hard he is working/dedicated he is ect. We bring him back.
 
Barca fans seem to want him now the Williams deal is off.

But along the line of, yeah we'll take him as an option off the bench if wants to come here so much, we don't want to buy him though but want a low option inserting, and maybe Flick can get the most out of him so we can laugh at the banter club who didn't get a loan fee and are still paying a a big chunk of his wages.
 
Even the Saudi Arabia league don't want him, says it all. Loan to a Turkish club probably the most obvious option.
 
I can just picture a world where we can't find a move for him and after about a month of messages from his camp about how hard he is working/dedicated he is ect. We bring him back.
Nah I don’t see it. We’ve been quite clear on this with all of the players. Amorims style by all accounts. Did similar at Sporting.
 
I can just picture a world where we can't find a move for him and after about a month of messages from his camp about how hard he is working/dedicated he is ect. We bring him back.
He's not wanted at United, his transparent PR nonsense has no affect anymore. He'll be at a new club come the end of the window, nae doubt about it
 
Obviously a lot of frustration on here that he played for a top 5 club/UCL football last season whilst the guy who banished him could only get 7 wins in 27.

The personal hatred towards Rashford is just bizarre, even scrolling his twitter comments and it’s just abuse
Sure dude
 
If Barca come close to our valuation (£40m), then Rashford will probably be willing to join them on reduced wages, though I suspect Barca offering anything near that valuation
 
Obviously a lot of frustration on here that he played for a top 5 club/UCL football last season whilst the guy who banished him could only get 7 wins in 27.

The personal hatred towards Rashford is just bizarre, even scrolling his twitter comments and it’s just abuse
It just shows how bitter our fanbase has become. I see so many comments on here and just have to think we don't deserve to be successful with the fans we have
 
It just shows how bitter our fanbase has become. I see so many comments on here and just have to think we don't deserve to be successful with the fans we have
Agreed, I do think/did think before Amorim lead our worst ever PL season that Rashford should be sold but I’ll always root for him and never feel half the personal hatred others do for him.
 
Rashford started the rift with the fans with his bad attitude, partying and then celebrating and making gestures at his own fecking fanbase.

I hope he leaves, and I am amazed it's come to that, I absolutely loved him at one point.
 
Agreed, I do think/did think before Amorim lead our worst ever PL season that Rashford should be sold but I’ll always root for him and never feel half the personal hatred others do for him.
I hope he does well wherever he goes, but he has disrespected the club with his attitude and performances in recent times, you can understand why people might hold a grudge.

The way Rashford was playing for us, he wouldn't have changed a thing about how Amorim did.
 
We'd probably be where we are now.

What are you worried we'd have finished worse than 8th and 15th? Or we'd have lost to Spurs in the final by even more goals?

We might have even been better if we replaced him with a centre back who can actually run.

It's amazing what a last minute goal against Lyon can do for your reputation. In a game he defended poorly in no less.
Maguire was getting for turning things around long before that Lyon goal.
 
Agreed, I do think/did think before Amorim lead our worst ever PL season that Rashford should be sold but I’ll always root for him and never feel half the personal hatred others do for him.

What's one got to do with the other?
 
Obviously a lot of frustration on here that he played for a top 5 club/UCL football last season whilst the guy who banished him could only get 7 wins in 27.

The personal hatred towards Rashford is just bizarre, even scrolling his twitter comments and it’s just abuse
The fact that he does get more abuse than MG by the fanbase at large has always felt a bit OTT honestly.

It 100% hasn't worked out recently and a divorce is the best for everyone involved by far but I don't feel the need to hold any sort of real animosity or ill will towards him, Antony or anyone else that we're trying to get rid of especially after the events of this past week.

It's simply a part of football like it is with so many other jobs, nothing more nothing less.

I do feel like there's been extra toxicity within fandom in sports in general these days with advent of social media allowing everyone to have a soap box/platform and people seem to either blur the fact or refuse to consider these players we all watch are in fact human and flawed individuals at the end of the day just like the rest of us in spite of all the money and adulation they receive in their profession.

In this instance in particular it's just a regrettable situation all around for a homegrown player but I've become quite sober about perpetuating any more negativity these days towards things that are relatively quite benign in the grand scheme of things.
 
Can't remember when it was, but after one of his particular bad runs of form he actually managed to score and then ran along the Stretford end doing that yapping hand motion in response to all the stick he had been shown.
Just had to watch a video with a AI voice explain what happened because I never even knew it happened. The article it was quoting said it was in response to people questing his loyalty because he replied to a Instagram post on Sancho's page after his move to Dortmund. Seems pretty harmless.
 
Against spurs he scored in the first half and gestured to the fans be quiet, you talk too much. didnt go down well obviously, and gave an insight into his mentality of recent years
I mean that's one way to interpret it. Guess the celebration was ambiguous.