Ali Dia
Full Member
great finish!
Shocked you haven't done so a long time ago given that opposing views than your owns seem to agitate you so much. And for the record - I am posting my opinions on here just as everybody else.Your schtick of over the top petty criticism of players followed by "hey guys I'm just talking here" is incredibly boring.
Don't worry, I won't cause you the need to totally reasonably use the report function any more. I'll chuck you on the ignore list to make sure you have a nice time doing whatever it is you are doing here.
I'm jumping to logical conclusions so I won't assume anymore. How about you explain yourself more clearly then?What? Not at all. WTF?! I was noticing a celebration that I thought was out of place. Thats all.
Mate, seriously. I made an effort twice to make sure me mentioning this behaviour cannot be seen as some sort of damning verdict on the player. I didn't even call the celebration stupid. FFS. Is there a chance that some of you are so eager to get into arguments?
Thanks for telling me my feelings are ok.
Was I? Don't remember to be honest. Has nothing to do with me not liking the player or anything like that. And just for the record - I have no issue with people asking "why bro?" (even though I thought, I made a reasonable effort to give context in two posts) but the reaction was "moaning" and "jesus wept". I am sure, you see a difference, right?
Seriously? You are aware of the fact, that we are talking about a subjective impression one person (me) had when I watched the game. No idea, why you feel needed to go into some sort of interrogator role now, given that we have already established, that you had a different subjective impression. Never have I said that your position would be wrong or inaccurate or anything. I wasn't even acting as if my standpoint would be reasonable one or more reasonable or anything like that.I'm jumping to logical conclusions so I won't assume anymore. How about you explain yourself more clearly then?
By 'out of place', what do you mean by this? He shouldn't have done it?
Why did you feel his celebration was out of place?
Why do you feel it's justified to feel his celebration was out of place?
How should he have celebrated whereby you wouldn't have felt it was out of place?
Hopefully the goal increases his confidence now and he goes on and scores more.
I don't know if it is something popular from a music video or Fortnite or something. It was a gesture I know partly from Gladiator, the moment where the Imperator posts a thumb up or down, up means mercy for the defeated in a gladiator battle in a colloseum, thumb down means the defeated will be killed off by the winner. Hojlund made the thumbs down gesture and added something along the lines of slit a throat, indicating a reference for a killer I guess.
Again, nothing wrong with stuff like that. But it surely doesn't fit in the situation because he hasn't shown anything that he would be a coldhearted killer, even in a transfered sense to football. It just feels increndibly unfitting. Again, I realize that there probably was a lot of pressure falling off of him. And probably it means nothing. I still noticed it. I think others in the match thread did as well.
Seriously? You are aware of the fact, that we are talking about a subjective impression one person (me) had when I watched the game. No idea, why you feel needed to go into some sort of interrogator role now, given that we have already established, that you had a different subjective impression. Never have I said that your position would be wrong or inaccurate or anything. I wasn't even acting as if my standpoint would be reasonable one or more reasonable or anything like that.
So what do you want to achieve here? Do you want me to say sorry for voicing a personal impression?
I explained myself pretty well I think in the first post. I think, the gesture was out of place because I saw it as a reference to stone cold killer. I don't think this fits the situation given that Hojlund went more than 21 games without a goal. I also said, that it probably means nothing and that most likely a lot of pressure was falling off of him and that my impression, that this might be sign of a bit of obliviousness towards the current situation on his part might be just me having no connection to having signature celebrations and assuming potential meaning when there clearly isn't one.
All that was said in my first post. The only reason why I explained the gesture in detail is because you asked what I meant and I wasn't aware that it's been a 1:1 reference of a movie. Even in that 2nd post, I added context to make sure, that this is not me being bothered by it or considering it a big mistake.
If this is some sort of gotcha moment hunt, say it now and we can stop right away. If my posts create an emotional reaction, consider to put me on ignore just as the other guy.
That's what I thought also.Upped his game since his chat with schmeichel.
Still haven't given up on him but I'm not really sure how his hold up play can be so garbage for a guy that big. Surely you have enough strength to hold off a guy like Faes or Thomas!
Really? That’s a surprise. I’m glad you told us and sure it will help the players who think they are in daycare.As I've said, Manchester United is not a creche daycare center. Your age won't save you. Do you want to be a star or do you want a pacifier? Carve your path.
You are entitled to your view. I don't think there's anything relevant to deeply decipher in your statement.Really? That’s a surprise. I’m glad you told us and sure it will help the players who think they are in daycare.
Also happy you share that binary world view with us - I thought it was much more nuanced, but it’s so much easier if you can just divide people into two categories. Quite Trumpian, actually.
Last season he was scoring but his overall play left a lot to be desired. This season atleast the last few weeks his overall play as a 9 is much better.no wonder he scores when the team slowly begins to improve and play Amorim-ball. Yes, he needs to improve as has been evident from day 1, but he has so much potential.
Laughable to criticise his overall game last night, was really good. But following this thread it shouldn’t come as a surprise that half of the posts after what ought to be a great relief for all fans whatever you might think about him are about nick picking and finding errors or his celebration.
I felt the same btw. This poster who's gone off on one at you is the one with an issue.Seriously? You are aware of the fact, that we are talking about a subjective impression one person (me) had when I watched the game. No idea, why you feel needed to go into some sort of interrogator role now, given that we have already established, that you had a different subjective impression. Never have I said that your position would be wrong or inaccurate or anything. I wasn't even acting as if my standpoint would be reasonable one or more reasonable or anything like that.
So what do you want to achieve here? Do you want me to say sorry for voicing a personal impression?
I explained myself pretty well I think in the first post. I think, the gesture was out of place because I saw it as a reference to stone cold killer. I don't think this fits the situation given that Hojlund went more than 21 games without a goal. I also said, that it probably means nothing and that most likely a lot of pressure was falling off of him and that my impression, that this might be sign of a bit of obliviousness towards the current situation on his part might be just me having no connection to having signature celebrations and assuming potential meaning when there clearly isn't one.
All that was said in my first post. The only reason why I explained the gesture in detail is because you asked what I meant and I wasn't aware that it's been a 1:1 reference of a movie. Even in that 2nd post, I added context to make sure, that this is not me being bothered by it or considering it a big mistake.
If this is some sort of gotcha moment hunt, say it now and we can stop right away. If my posts create an emotional reaction, consider to put me on ignore just as the other guy.
I agree with both those points.I think you're reading too much into it. He's happy to get a goal and we should be happy for him. I'm not his biggest fan but the relief for him to get on the scoresheet again must be immense. Hopefully this gives him the boost of confidence he so desperately needs.
I couldn't remember seeing this celebration with him so wouldn't go along with obvious performative. But won't be a hill for me to die on.I'm asking because I'm genuinely curious how you was able to read so much from an obvious performative celebration.
Ok. I personally don't think, that workrate plays a role in this, but overall I agree.I guess my 'issue' here, is that in my opinion it doesn't matter if it was from a movie reference or not. To look at it and potentially deduct the thought of 'it seems like he's not been aware of how poor he's been playing to justify that' is bit of an over the top critique, especially when it comes to someone like Hojlund, who despite being shit on the pitch hasn't really shown attitude/work rate problems on and off the pitch (except for most recently in one game).
Correct.You've pleaded ignorance and that you've not bothered by it but the underlying problem is that he's not been playing well, so your initial impression felt his performatory celebration was 'out of place'.
It would be even more out of place or more strikingly out of place by the two players you mentioned. As I said, I would be fine if he had gone berserk celebrating like a mad man given his draught. I didn't choose to be irritated by it, it just happened, same way I noticed it when Maguires celebration looked as if he'd thought, that his critics were all wrong. I think, I remember Rashford pointing at his ears or something and Dalot is a little strange as well. As said, it probably is me looking for potential meaning where there is none.I mean I'll sort of get it, if it were about Lingard and Pogba constantly posting a lot social media but just after a striker has scored a goal following a horrific run of form? As you've said yourself, just old man shouting to the cloud type of stuff, quite bizarre.
Thanks!I felt the same btw. This poster who's gone off on one at you is the one with an issue.
Yes, he’s improving now which is uplifting, though I do think people forget that he did showed positive signs as well last season apart from the goalsLast season he was scoring but his overall play left a lot to be desired. This season atleast the last few weeks his overall play as a 9 is much better.
He’s a terrible footballer who has a fantastic shot on him. Seems like a good lad and I’m pleased for him that he scored, but we need to ship him out this summer. He’s never going to be at the level we need.
I couldn't remember seeing this celebration with him so wouldn't go along with obvious performative. But won't be a hill for me to die on.
I didn't choose to be irritated by it, it just happened, same way I noticed it when Maguires celebration looked as if he'd thought, that his critics were all wrong. I think, I remember Rashford pointing at his ears or something and Dalot is a little strange as well. As said, it probably is me looking for potential meaning where there is none.

The posts in here are ridiculous, pick your toys up and move on, load of babies whinging and whining, too much time on your hands![]()
