Redcafe's All-Time Top 20. Right backs | Results

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
  1. Cafu 876
  2. Carlos Alberto 597
  3. Javier Zanetti 565
  4. Lilian Thuram 500
  5. Djalma Santos 475
  6. Philipp Lahm 354
  7. Berti Vogts 353
  8. Giuseppe Bergomi 277
  9. Dani Alves 250
  10. Manuel Amoros 225
  11. Eric Gerets 192
  12. Tarcisio Burgnich 151
  13. Manfred Kaltz 126
  14. Danny McGrain 123
  15. Victor Andrade 115
  16. Claudio Gentile 112
  17. Gianluca Zambrotta 85
  18. Leandro 70
  19. Maicon 57
  20. Revaz Dzodzuashvili 50
  21. Jorginho 47
  22. Wim Suurbier 37
  23. Vladimir Bessonov 29
  24. Gary Neville 23
  25. Jimmy Armfield 22
  26. Willy Sagnol 20
  27. Phil Neal 13
  28. Christian Panucci 12
  29. Stefan Reuter, Mauro Tassotti, Orvar Bergmark 10
  30. Nelinho, Jocelyn Angloma, Paul Janes 7
  31. Viv Anderson 6
  32. Juanfran 5
  33. Germano 4
  34. Fahrudin Jusufi 3
  35. Luis Eyzaguirre, Bacary Sagna, Horst-Dieter Höttges, Johnny Carey 2
  36. Trent Alexander-Arnold, Antonio Benarrivo, Jenő Buzánszky 1

Post your list of 20 best right backs of all-time. I'll close the thread on the 6th of August (unless we decide to extend the vote).

Note: we've decided to separate right and left backs and to put versatile players only on the list of their preferred position. I'll provide a guide on the most known cases, if you doubt whenever the player you think of prefers left or right, please post the question in the discussion thread.



Note: all discussion goes to this thread
- http://www.redcafe.net/threads/redcafes-top-20-by-position.448431/

Note: you can post less than 20 names, but not more

The list should be posted in the required format:

  1. J. O'Shea
  2. P. Jones
...

20.

NB: After careful consideration, only players that had played at least a season after the 1950 WC are eligible.
 
Last edited:

Edgar Allan Pillow

Ero-Sennin
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
41,400
Location
┴┬┴┤( ͡° ͜ʖ├┬┴┬
First impression. I'll edit some a bit later on
  1. Cafu
  2. D. Santos
  3. B. Vogts
  4. L. Thuram
  5. C. Alberto
  6. P. Lahm
  7. J. Zanetti
  8. E. Gerets
  9. G. Bergomi
  10. M. Amoros
  11. W. Suurbier
  12. C. Gentile
  13. D. McGrain
  14. M. Kaltz
  15. T. Burgnich
  16. P. Neal
  17. Jorginho
  18. G. Zambrotta
  19. C. Panucci
  20. D. Alves
 

BlackShark_80

Full Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Messages
1,169
  1. Djalma Santos
  2. Carlos Alberto
  3. Cafu
  4. Berti Vogts
  5. Javier Zanetti
  6. Manuel Amoros
  7. Phillip Lahm
  8. Dani Alves
  9. Eric Gerets
  10. Danny McGrain
  11. Victor Rodriguez Andrade
  12. Manfred Kaltz
  13. Tarcisio Burgnich
  14. Jimmy Armfield
  15. Jorginho
  16. Vladimir Bezsonov
  17. Gianluca Zambrotta
  18. Leandro Ferreira
  19. Luis Eyzaguirre
  20. Maicon
 
Last edited:

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
1. Cafu
2. L. Thuram
3. C. Alberto
4. J. Zanetti
5. B. Vogts
6. D. Santos
7. M. Amoros
8. G. Bergomi
9. P. Lahm
10. D. Alves
11. C. Gentile
12. G. Zambrotta
13. T. Burgnich
14. M. Kaltz
15. E. Gerets
16. D. McGrain
17. J. Armfield
18. Jorginho
19. V. Bessonov
20. C. Panucci
 

2mufc0

Everything is fair game in capitalism!
Joined
Jan 8, 2014
Messages
17,011
Supports
Dragon of Dojima
1. Zanetti
2. Cafu
3. C. Alberto
4. Lahm
5. Djalma
6. Thuram
7. Amoros
8. Vogts
9. D Alves
10. Bergomi
11. Gerets
12. Kaltz
13. McGrain
14. V Andrade
15. Maicon
16. Zambrotta
17. Burgnich
18. Leandro
19. Suuriber
20. G Neville
 
Last edited:

Enigma_87

You know who
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
27,634
1. J. Zanetti
2. Cafu
3. C. Alberto
4. B. Vogts
5. L. Thuram
6. D. Santos
7. P. Lahm
8. D. Alves
9. M. Amoros
10. G. Bergomi
11. E. Gerets
12. C. Gentile
13. T. Burgnich
14. M. Kaltz
15. G. Zambrotta
16. W. Sagnol
17. D. McGrain
18. S. Reuter
19. V. Bessonov
20. Jorginho
 

Šjor Bepo

Wout is love, Wout is life; all hail Wout!
Joined
Mar 29, 2011
Messages
15,624
1. Cafu
2. Zanetti
3. Carlos Alberto
4. Lahm
5. Bergomi
6. Thuram
7. Djalma
8. Dani Alves
9. Vogts
10. Amoros
11. Maicon
12. Gerets
13. McGrain
14. Burgnich
15. Zambrotta
16. Juanfran
17. Kaltz
18. Armfield
19. Suurbier
20.
 

Physiocrat

Has No Mates
Joined
Jun 29, 2010
Messages
8,959
1. J. Zanetti
2. Cafu
3. Vogts
4. Carlos Alberto
5. Lahm
6. Thuram
7. Bergomi
8. Djalma
9. Amoros
10. Gerets
11. Tassotti
12. Burgnich
13. Danny Mcgrain
14. Dani Alves
15. Kaltz
16. Maicon
17. Panucci
18. Zambrotta
19. Jorginho
20. Armfield
 

Joga Bonito

The Art of Football
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Messages
8,231
1) Carlos Alberto
2) Djalma Santos
3) Cafu
4) Lilian Thuram
5) Berti Vogts
6) Giuseppe Bergomi
7) Javier Zanetti
8) Philip Lahm
9) Tarcisio Burgnich
10) Manuel Amoros
11) Dani Alves
12) Manfred Kaltz
13) Eric Gerets
14) Victor Andrade
15) José Leandro Ferreira
16) Jimmy Armfield
17) Gianluca Zambrotta
18) Willy Sagnol
19) Stefan Reuter
20) Christian Panucci
 
Last edited:

oneniltothearsenal

Caf's Milton Friedman and Arse Aficionado
Scout
Joined
Dec 17, 2013
Messages
11,114
Supports
Brazil, Arsenal,LA Aztecs
  1. Carlos Alberto
  2. Cafu
  3. Zanetti
  4. Thuram
  5. Djalma
  6. Lahm
  7. Vogts
  8. Bergomi
  9. Rodriguez Andrade
  10. Dani Alves
  11. Gerets
  12. Amoros
  13. Maicon
  14. Nelinho
  15. Viv Anderson
  16. McGrain
  17. Bezsonov
  18. Jorginho
  19. Sagnol
  20. Leandro

  1. Carlos Alberto
  2. Cafu
  3. Zanetti
  4. Thuram
  5. Djalma
  6. Lahm
  7. Vogts
  8. Bergomi

9th (tie)
Rodriguez Andrade
Dani Alves

11th(Tie)
Gerets
Amoros
Maicon
Nelinho

15th (tie)
Viv Anderson
McGrain
Bezsonov
Jorginho
Sagnol
Leandro
 
Last edited by a moderator:

berbasloth4

Full Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2012
Messages
4,467
Location
ireland
  1. cafu
  2. zanetti
  3. thuram
  4. djalma
  5. carlos alberto
  6. bergomi
  7. vogts
  8. zambrotta
  9. amoros
  10. gerets
  11. suurbier
  12. alves
  13. andrade
  14. g neville
  15. mcgrain
  16. sagnol
  17. kalz
  18. burgnich
  19. neal
  20. alexander arnold oj viv anderson
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Invictus

Poster of the Year 2015 & 2018
Staff
Joined
Mar 22, 2014
Messages
15,255
Supports
Piracy on the High Seas.
1. Carlos Alberto
2. Marcos Cafú
3. Djalma Santos
4. Berti Vogts
5. Giuseppe Bergomi
6. Javier Zanetti
7. Lilian Thuram
8. Philipp Lahm
9. Manuel Amoros
10. Dani Alves
11. Claudio Gentile
12. Tarcisio Burgnich
13. Manfred Kaltz
14. Orvar Bergmark
15. Eric Gerets
16. Danny McGrain
17. Leandro Ferreira
18. Fahrudin Jusufi
19. Gianluca Zambrotta
20. Jimmy Armfield
 

Gio

★★★★★★★★
Joined
Jan 25, 2001
Messages
20,322
Location
Bonnie Scotland
Supports
Rangers
  1. Cafu
  2. Javier Zanetti
  3. Lillian Thuram
  4. Djalma Santos
  5. Carlos Alberto
  6. Berti Vogts
  7. Guiseppe Bergomi
  8. Victor Andrade
  9. Dani Alves
  10. Manuel Amoros
  11. Leandro
  12. Philip Lahm
  13. Eric Gerets
  14. Tarcisio Burgnich
  15. Danny McGrain
  16. Vladimir Bessonov
  17. Jocelyn Angloma
  18. Jorginho
  19. Manfred Kaltz
  20. Claudio Gentile
 

paulscholes18

Full Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2013
Messages
20,169
1 Cafu
2 Carlos Alberto
3 Djalma Santos
4 Dani Alves
5 Philipp Lahm
6 Lilian Thuram
7 Berti Vogts
8 Giuseppe Bergomi
9 Gianluca Zambrotta
10 Gary Neville
11 Javier Zanetti
12 Maicon
13 Manuel Amoros
14 Victor Andrade
15 Claudio Gentile
16 Danny McGrain
17 Jorginho
18 Willy Sagnol
19 Bacary sagna
20 Christian Panucci
 
Last edited:

BIG DUNK

Tank
Joined
Feb 9, 2014
Messages
977
Location
Europe
1 Lilian Thuram
2 Carlos Alberto
3 Djalma Santos
4 Berti Vogts
5 Cafu
6 Javier Zanetti
7 Giuseppe Bergomi
8 Philipp Lahm
9 Dani Alves
10 Manuel Amoros
11 Eric Gerets
12 Claudio Gentile
13 Tarcisio Burgnich
14 Manfred Kaltz
15 Volodymyr Bezsonov
16 Danny McGrain
17 Gianluca Zambrotta
18 Jorginho
19 Horst-Dieter Hottges
20 Antonio Benarrivo
 

Fortitude

TV/Monitor Expert
Scout
Joined
Jul 10, 2004
Messages
22,680
Location
Inside right
1. Djalma Santos
2. Carlos Alberto
3. Cafú
4. Javier Zanetti
5. Lilian Thuram
6. Berti Vogts
7. Giuseppe Bergomi
8. Victor Andrade
9. Philipp Lahm
10. Manuel Amoros
11. Dani Alves
12. Claudio Gentile
13. Eric Gerets
14. Tarcisio Burgnich
15. Danny McGrain
16. Manfred Kaltz
17. Leandro
18. Gianluca Zambrotta
19. Vladimir Bessonov
20. Jimmy Armfield
 

Indnyc

Full Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2017
Messages
4,537
  1. Cafu
  2. Lillian Thuram
  3. Carlos Alberto
  4. Javier Zanetti
  5. Philip Lahm
  6. Djalma Santos
  7. Berti Vogts
  8. Guiseppe Bergomi
  9. Dani Alves
  10. Manuel Amoros
  11. Danny McGrain
  12. Claudio Gentile
  13. Maicon
  14. Eric Gerets
  15. Tarcisio Burgnich
  16. Manfred Kaltz
  17. Jorginho
  18. Gianluca Zambrotta
  19. Willy Sagnol
  20. Leandro
 
Last edited:

Michaelf7777777

(∪。∪)。。。zzz
Joined
Aug 27, 2018
Messages
1,667
1. Revaz Dzodzuashvilli
2. Cafu
3. Berti Vogts
4. Phillip Lahm
5. Javier Zanetti
6. Leandro
7. Djalma Santos
8. Eric Gerets
9. Lilian Thuram
10. Dani Alves
11. Giuseppe Begomi
12. Carlos Alberto
13. Victor Rodriguez Andrade
14. Tarcisio Burgnich
15. Danny McGrain
16. Manuel Amoros
17. Manfred Kaltz
18. Maicon
19. Johnny Carey
20. Jeno Buzanszky
 

GodShaveTheQueen

We mean it man, we love our queen!
Joined
Oct 11, 2018
Messages
6,434
1. Thuram
2. Cafu
3. Bergomi
4. Zanetti
5. Djalma
6. Lahm
7. Leandro
8. Burgnich
9. Carlos Alberto
10. Amoros
11. Gerets
12. Vogts
13. Gentile
14. Alves
15. Andrade
16. Mcgrain
17. Kaltz
18. Bergmark
19. Maicon
20. Bezsonov
 
Last edited:

Synco

Lucio's #1 Fan
Joined
Jul 19, 2014
Messages
6,446
  1. Cafu
  2. C. Alberto
  3. Thuram
  4. Lahm
  5. D. Santos
  6. Zanetti
  7. Bergomi
  8. Vogts
  9. Dani Alves
  10. Amoros
  11. Gentile
  12. Burgnich
  13. Kaltz
  14. Gerets
  15. Leandro
  16. Maicon
  17. Jorginho
  18. Panucci
  19. Zambrotta
 

Himannv

Full Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2017
Messages
5,779
Location
Somewhere in the draft forum
  1. 1. Cafu
  2. 2. Zanetti
  3. 3. Thuram
  4. 4. Vogts
  5. 5. Djalma
  6. 6. Bergomi
  7. 7. Carlos Alberto
  8. 8. Amoros
  9. 9. Lahm
  10. 10. Alves
  11. 11. Gentile
  12. 12. Gerets
  13. 13. Kaltz
  14. 15. Janes
  15. 16. Andrade
  16. 17. McGrain
  17. 18. Bergnich
  18. 19. Leandro
  19. 20. Bezsonov
 
Last edited by a moderator:

freeurmind

weak willed
Joined
Mar 10, 2017
Messages
5,883
  1. 1. Philippe Lahm
  2. 2. Cafu
  3. 3. Javier Zanetti
  4. 4. Carlos Alberto
  5. 5. Lillian Thuram
  6. 6. Djalma Santos
  7. 7. Berti Vogts
  8. 8. Dani Alves
  9. 10. Victor Rodriguez Andrade
  10. 11. Wim Suurbier
  11. 12. Jorginho
  12. 13. Guiseppe Bergomi
  13. 14. Tarcisio Burgnich
  14. 15. Manfred Kaltz
  15. 16. Gianluca Zambrotta
  16. 17. Phil Neal
  17. 18. Germano
  18. 19. Eric Gerets
  19. 20. Gary Neville
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Moby

Dick
Joined
May 20, 2011
Messages
51,356
Location
Barcelona, Catalunya
  1. Lilian Thuram
  2. Carlos Alberto
  3. Cafu
  4. Javier Zanetti
  5. Djalma Santos
  6. Guiseppe Bergomi
  7. Phillip Lahm
  8. Berti Vogts
  9. Claudio Gentile
  10. Eric Gerets
  11. Manfred Kaltz
  12. Dani Alves
  13. Tarcisio Burgnich
  14. Danny McGrain
  15. Victor Andrade
  16. Stefan Reuter
  17. Wim Suurbier
  18. Jocelyn Angloma
  19. Gary Neville
  20. Phil Neal
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
I don't have much time, so I'll skip the first few descriptions. I can't skip the goal though:


32
. Nelinho, Jocelyn Angloma, Paul Janes 7 points
35. Viv Anderson 6 points
36. Juanfran 5 points
37. Germano 4 points
38. Fahrudin Jusufi 3 points
39. Luis Eyzaguirre, Bacary Sagna,Horst-Dieter Höttges, Johnny Carey 2 points
43. Trent Alexander-Arnold, Antonio Benarrivo, Jenő Buzánszky 1 point
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
Hmmm, video blocked by FIFA. For all their faults , they should concentrate fixing other areas
You can click and watch it on youtube — for some reason they didn't want anyone to embed it on other websites.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
29. Stefan Reuter, Mauro Tassotti, Orvar Bergmark. 10 points

Stefan Reuter had won the World Cup and the Euros with Germany and achieved significant success in Bundesliga (winning it 5 times) and CL (1996/97 winner with Borussia Dortmund). Like many of his compatriots, he had a little stint in Italy, playing for Juventus. He almost won the double there, but they ended up finishing runners up both in Serie A and in the Cup.

Mauro Tassotti had played almost 600 games for AC Milan, despite the fact that he started out in Lazio. Although his international career never took off, his club career was nothing short of amazing — he had won 5 Serie A titles, 3 Champions League, playing an important role in probably the greatest ever defensive unit in club football.

Orvar Bergmark was one of the greatest defenders in the world in late 50s - 60's. World Soccer picked him for their World XI twice (in 1960 and 1961), and he had reached the World Cup final in 1958 with Sweden. Overall he had earned almost 100 caps for his country — finishing up at 94. He tried to leave Sweden twice — once for AEK and once for AS Roma, but neither of those stints were successful, so he is mostly known for his international performances.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
28. Christian Panucci. 12 points

Before the surprising bust up in 2018, after which Christian Panucci said that Capello is dead for him now, they were pretty much inseparable. They've met at AC Milan and Capello lured him first to Real Madrid and then to AS Roma. And you can't blame him — every manager loves to have someone like Panucci around. Disciplined, talented, incredibly versatile and comfortable with the ball — he was able to fill any defensive position and to perform at a high level.

27. Phil Neal. 13 points

Phil Neal was the only player to appear in all four of Liverpool's European Cup wins of the 1970s and 1980s — incredibly, scoring in 2 of the finals. He was never the most talented, but his consistency and dependability was virtually unrivalled. He played a club-record 365 consecutive league matches from 14 December 1974 until 24 September 1983, when he suffered an injury against Manchester United that forced him to miss the following week's match against Sunderland. At some point I believe that his feet was so bloated because of the injury that he wasn't able to put on his boots. He just asked for a boot 2 sizes bigger and went on to play the game.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
26. Willy Sagnol. 20 points

After impressive everyone in France, Willy Sagnol moved to Germany — for the better part of a 2000s' he had became a stalwart in Bayern Munich defence, winning 5 Bundesliga titles and a Champions League. He was a very good defender who often played as a wingback due to his excellent crossing. For France his career was less consistent — for a time he was stuck on the bench behind Lilian Thuram, one of the greatest right backs of all-time. He shined after Thuram retired (and later came back in a central role) and had produced a wonderful performance in the 2006 World Cup that almost ended up with a win.

25. Jimmy Armfield. 22 points

Blackpool and England legend, he is considered by many to be the finest right back in England's history. He played a record 627 games over his 17 seasons at the club, with his peak being near the 60's. In 1966, he narrowly lost out to Bobby Charlton for the Footballer of the Year award and had to content himself with being Blackpool's Player of the Year — and looked well set to perform at the World Cup... but got injured. So, England had won their first and only international trophy and he wasn't there to help (although eventually he had got the medal). Matt Busby actually tried to sign him in 1957, but Blackpool wouldn't let him go — who knows, knowing what would happen in 1958 it was probably for the best.

At his 80th birthday celebrations, Stanley Matthews joked that it was “nice to see Jimmy Armfield here, because had he been playing earlier, I’d never have lived to reach this age!”.

24. Gary Neville. 23 points

(to tune of 'London Bridge is falling down')
Gary Neville is a red, is a red, is a red,
Gary Neville is a red...
He hates Scousers!

 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
23. Vladimir Bessonov (a.k.a. Volodimir Bezsonov). 29 points

When he was just coming through you knew he would become someone special. With USSR youth teams he had won the Euros in 1976 and the World Cup in 1977 — winning the tournament's Golden Ball no less. But, even though he had won numerous trophies and participated in 4 major international tournaments (finishing as a runner up in the 1988 Euros), you can say that his career didn't match his early promise. He was probably the best example of a Lobanovky's footballer — he was equally good in attack and in defence, could run all day and play in every outfield position. He had only one problem, and it was staying healthy, fans nicknamed him an "Injury-man" for his infamous injury-proneness.

Still: 6 Soviet League titles, 5 Soviet Cups, Cup Winner's Cup, Silver medal in 1988 and Ukraine's Footballer of the Year award in 1989 — not bad for a permanent crock.

22. Wim Suurbier. 37 points

Another great example of a total footballer. Wim Suurbier had been a part of both an all-conquering Ajax side appropriately nicknamed "12 apostles" and the Rinus Michels' 1974 World Cup side. As his former teammate says: "Wim was very fast and had a fantastic physique. In addition, he was merciless in the duels. If you said to Wim: I don't want to see that number eleven of the counterparty today, it happened. He also regularly joined the attack from the right, due to his enormous stamina". In his time at Ajax he had won 7 national league titles, 3 European Cups and multiple other trophies.

21. Jorginho. 47 points

Jorginho is definitely one of the best in the long list of outstanding Brazilian fullbacks. Stylistically you can probably compare him to Cafu — his successor, who symbolically replaced him in the 1994 World Cup final. He had spent a lot of time in Germany, which lived through the renaissance of the 5-men defence; those formations were perfect for him — he had additional cover at the back and was free to unleash his attacking potential.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
20. Revaz Dzodzuashvili. 50 points



Revaz Dzodzuashvili was known first and foremost as an outstanding man-marker. He successfully played against the likes of Dzajic and Lubanski, but his star moment would come in the qualifying games for the 1970 World Cup. USSR had 2 games against Northern Ireland... a team that had George Best, arguably the greatest player in the world at the time, at the peak of his powers. Dzodzuashvili studied Best for 6 months by watching the same 20-minute film over and over again, and when the time did come, he was prepared. He kept Best quiet that day, and in their next fixture Best was almost non-existent because of Dzodzuashvili’s man-marking skills. At the club level he hadn't won anything of note, although you have to understand that the way transfers worked in USSR weren't really similar to how they work today.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
19. Maicon. 57 points



Before his reputation got completely trashed by Gareth Bale (twice), he was seen by many as potentially the best right back of his generation. He performed so good that he even kept peak Dani Alves either out of the team or, at least, out of the position for Brazil. Like Cafu reincarnated, he dominated the wing on his own — strong, fast, with good technique and capable of scoring sublime goals, in 2009/10 he was simply unplayable, and even got chosen as UEFA Club Defender of the Year. Sadly, his peak was a bit short, albeit incredible, to him to be considered for a higher position in our list.

18. Leandro. 70 points



Leandro had spent his whole career in Brazil, which, perhaps, damaged his reputation abroad, but he is still well-known and well-loved by everyone who ever saw the vintage Brazilian side of the 1982 World Cup. I won't go into much detail about him, but rather provide a link to a 3-posts long essay by @GodShaveTheQueen — on Leandro and "the curious case of Brazilian fullbacks and Redcafe drafts" (go to the quoted post to read the rest).
So now I decide to do a bit of research on how well could Leandro play...
17. Gianluca Zambrotta. 85 points



Zambrotta spent his whole career alternating between left and right wing, being equally comfortable on either side. His versatility was highlighted by his performance at the 2006 World Cup (which Italy had won, as you all, of course, remember) — he began the tournament as a left back, then switched to the other side and even spent some time as a left midfielder in a game against Ukraine. It ensured not only a glorious international career — Zambrotta earned 98 caps for a country best known for their outstanding defenders, but also a hugely successful career in club football. He had won Serie A with both Juventus and AC Milan and spent 2 years at Rijkaard's Barcelona, which was one of the best sides in the world at the time.

16. Claudio Gentile. 112 points



Gentile: perhaps the most inappropriate name ever afforded to a professional footballer. The Italian defender wore his reputation as a tough, uncompromising defender, or as the more clickbait YouTube video titles would have you believe, ‘The Hardest Man in Soccer’, as a badge of honour. But there was nothing gentle about the man born in Libya and raised in Italy on a diet of Catenaccio and traditional Italian physicality. “My character was not to intimidate, it was to show I was the boss on the field. You have to be gritty and determined. At certain times you have to know ‘how’ to foul,” once said the Italian.

Best known for the brutal man-markings of Maradona and Zico during Italy's successful 1982 World Cup campaign, he spent most of his career in a slightly different role — as a right-sided defender in Zona Mista set up, mostly covering the movements of the opposition left winger. Zoff, Scirea, Gentile and Cabrini (signed last in 1976) would form the bedrock of Juve’s defence for the next seven years. Over those prolific seven years with the Serie A giants, Gentile and a revitalised Juventus team would win five Scudetti, two Coppa Italias, one UEFA Cup and one Cup Winners’ Cup. Gentile would narrowly miss out on the third UEFA trophy, the European Cup, when losing to Hamburg in the 1983 final. The four players would also be first choice starters for the national team from 1975 to 1983, competing in the 1978 and 1982 World Cups as well as Euro 80.

15. Víctor Rodríguez Andrade. 115 points



The nephew of another Uruguayan international player, José Leandro Andrade (the legendary "Black Marvel" and one of the first football superstars), had achieved a lot in his career. Most notably, he matched his famous uncle's greatest achievement by winning the 1950 World Cup — 20 years after Uruguay's first ever success. Again, no need to write anything while our resident Uruguayan already made a brilliant write up on his career — please check it out if you haven't seen it.
With Zizinho starting on his (Gambetta's — harms) side and Zizinho-to-Ademir being a proven devastatingly effective route to goal, things looked ominous. So Uruguay surprised Brazil on the day by starting Rodríguez Andrade on the right and Gambetta on the left.

Within five minutes though, the entire issue was sorted. The first or second time Zizinho gets the ball Víctor puts in one of those skeleton-busting tackles which are honest but dare you to try what dishonesty could be like. Zizinho didn't want to, and was largely anonymous for most of the game.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
14. Danny McGrain. 123 points



Danny McGrain was a boyhood Rangers fan, but he had come to fall in love with Celtic over the years and was as steeped in the history of the green as any man on the terracing. He had amassed incredible 681 performances for the club — only 4 players had more (funnily enough, places from 4 to 2 have exactly 682, 683 and 684 appearances respectively, with Billy McNeil being way ahead of the rest with 822), and won 9 Scottish League Titles and 6 Scottish Cups. His main position was as right-back but he was able to easily flit between the right-back and the left-back positions, or centre-half if and when needed. He may have been an affable gentleman off the pitch, but on the pitch he was an unforgiving tackler. Built out of granite, he never shirked a tackle and every opposing player knew his presence on the pitch. Another great facet of his game was his pace. A speedy player, it was like as if a rhino was charging up the field with the ball for crossing and passing. Any weaknesses? He was too tough for any of that, but admittedly he has said himself that he wasn't an attacking penalty box player and goal scoring wasn't his forte, feeling a bit out of place away from the defence.

Notable bits of trivia:
1) In the early 1980's the whole Scotland team on the pitch were playing for English Clubs, with one exception: Danny McGrain,
2) Danny McGrain played five times for Scotland in World Cup final games and never lost one.

13. Manfred Kaltz. 126 points



While Manfred Kaltz is not the shiniest name on the list, he has undoubtedly earned his place as one of the greatest attacking fullbacks of all-time. Kaltz was famous for his right-footed crosses, which he hit with so much spin that they curved like a banana. They were affectionately called "Bananenflanken" ("banana crosses") by the German fans. He often used this technique to set up hulking striker Horst Hrubesch, whose 96 goals with HSV included many from Kaltz crosses that Hrubesch headed into the opposing goal. Hrubesch once described their partnership when he explained one of his goals with the often quoted words "Manni banana, I head, goal".

Hamburger SV was one of the best teams in Europe at the time — Kaltz had won 3 Bundesliga titles and even the European Cup in 1983 with them. In 1979 he had finished 4th in Ballon d'Or list — an outstanding achievement for a fullback. You should not underestimate his defensive abilities though — in the dark post-Beckenbauer times he was often used as a center back and as a sweeper, even though his best role would still be as a right wingback in a back 5.

12. Tarcisio Burgnich. 151 points



During a match against Spal, an opponent, Carlo Novelli, collided with Burgnich and was knocked out on the ground. When Novelli pulled himself up, he saw his ex-teammate Picchi smiling at him: «Don’t say anything, I know how you’re feeling: you just hit a rock». From that time onwards, Tarcisio Burgnich became «The Rock».

Facchetti and Burgnich were the most admired pair of full-backs in the 1960’s and 70’s the pillars of Herrera’s Inter and Valcareggi’s Italian national team. In twelve years wearing the black and blue stripes, Burgnich had really seen it all: four league championships, two European Cups and two Intercontinental Cups. He was the man who managed to score the momentous equaliser for Italy in the «game of the century», the 1970 World Cup semi-final with West Germany. His luck would end there — in the final he would receive a thankless task of man-marking Pelé himself.

11. Eric Gerets. 192 points



Eric Gerets. The "Lion of Rekem". His nickname covers it all. Hair waving in the wind, full beard, slumped trunk: until his very last game he ran the right wing of the pitch in a style which made his reputation. The legendary full back made his debut however as … a striker.

Eric Gerets said:
As a striker I even played some games instead of p’tit Léon (Léon Semmeling, one of Standard’s legendary midfielders), but Vlatko Markovic, our coach in those days, found the ideal solution by turning me into a defender. That reconversion wasn’t that obvious, nor easy. I had to learn how to defend, jump and tackle. But Markovic learnt me the ropes and thaught me how to be a professional, and from then on I launched my long career as a full back
...
I quickly got noticed and built a strong reputation. At one given point they even compared me to Manfred Kaltz who played for Hamburg in the 70-80ies. That was such a big compliment as I shared his offensive style of play.
His career would lift of with Standard in the 80's: firstly qualifying for European football and then collecting his first club trophies (Belgian FA Cup in 1981, Belgian Supercup in 1981 and 1983, and winning the Belgian League Championship in 1982 and 1983) as well as individual trophies (Golden Boot in 1982). And who can forget the lost European Cup Winner’s Cup final from Barcelona after a very disputed game.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
10. Manuel Amoros. 225 points



Manuel Amoros had spent his whole career in France (well, in the French league) — playing for Monaco, Lyon and Marseille. Even though he had won the Champions League with Marseille in 1993, he was only a squad player for them at the time; it was his second European final with Marseille — in 1991 he had missed the crucial penalty in the series that made Red Star Belgrade the winner. Aside from that he had won 4 league titles, not a bad trophy hall but it doesn't really reflect his standing as one of the greatest fullbacks to ever play this game.

International games was his specialty. French team was arguably the best side of the 80's that reached 2 World Cup Semi-Finals (losing both to Germany) and won the Euros in 1984, playing some outstanding football. He wasn't the part of their European campaign (he only appeared in 2 games — after being sent off in the opening match he only got a few more minutes of playing time in the final), but his performances both in 1982 and 1986 were simply outstanding. He was centimeters away from becoming the hero in the 1982 semi-final — his shot hit the bar at the 89' minute; and his performances in 1986 were so impressive that he was voted 4th in that year's Ballon d'Or list and came second only to Diego Maradona in that year's vote by Onze Mondial; obviously, he got into that World Cup's Team of the Tournament and was chosen as French Footballer of the Year.

He was everything that you want your fullback to be. Incredibly strong and skilful in tackle, possessing a great crossing and shooting technique, fast and tireless. He also easily switched between the wings and was equally comfortable on the right and on the left. I don't think that I've seen many fullbacks switching flanks during the game — Amoros did it multiple times (I assume that it was a weird game-plan by his manager).
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
9. Dani Alves. 250 points



Instead of listing his awards, I'll just leave it here — he is the only football player in history to reach the milestone of 40 competition winning trophies across both national and club competitions. To be honest, I expected him to finish a bit higher, even though he has certain weaknesses in his defensive game if we're comparing him to other all-time greats. For a long time the stick to beat him with was his international career — most notably the fact that he wasn't able to get a game for Brazil at right back during his peak. A certain Maicon left him no chance. But after he had won his 2nd Copa America this summer and was chosen as that tournaments MVP (at the age of 36!), I don't think that it's applicable anymore.

I won't go much deeper into his profile as all of you've seen him. He is probably the most dangerous attacking right-back that there's ever been, with the unique combination of orthodox wing play and playmaking capabilities of a midfielder. Even at Sevilla he was already running games from the right back position, let alone his peak at Barcelona.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
8. Giuseppe Bergomi. 277 points



I've already wrote two profiles on his for two previous lists, so this one will be even shorter. Right back was probably Bergomi's best position, even though he excelled in so many different set ups, and he is the highest rated Italian in this list, which certainly says something.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
7. Berti Vogts. 353 points



More than 500 games for Borussia Mönchengladbach, 9 appearances in the Bundesliga's Team of the Season and 2 Footballer of the Year in Germany awards in the times of Beckenbauer, Müller and Rummenigge. He was the inspirational of one of the greatest club sides of the 70's — and, of course, a crucial part of the golden German generation that had won both the Euros and the World Cup. His outstanding performance in the 1974 World Cup final, when he man-marked Cruyff out of the game for 89 minutes, often gives people an unfair perception of his skillset — he was not only a brilliant defender but he also loved to support the attack and had done it with huge success over the years.
 

harms

Shining Star of Paektu Mountain
Staff
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
27,998
Location
Moscow
6. Philipp Lahm. 354 points



No-one before or since has impacted Guardiola as profoundly as the scruffy 5 ft 7 in phenomenon that is Philipp Lahm, a player Pep described shortly after becoming Bayern manager as "perhaps the most intelligent player I have ever trained in my career." Nominally a full-back, he has blurred the lines between what it means to be a defender and midfielder, and at times made our conventional views on positions seem laughably outdated.

When Guardiola began managing Bayern, Lahm was known only as a full-back, though granted he was viewed as both the best left-back and right-back in the world, thanks partly to his two-footedness and positional awareness. Guardiola changed all that, and in the August 2013 Super Cup against Chelsea, he decided mid-match to move Lahm into the pivote (defensive midfield) role, on the advice of his assistant Domenec Torrent. Bayern ended up winning the match on penalties, but all Guardiola could talk about in the weeks and months after was Lahm's metamorphosis into a midfielder. In his post-match interview, Guardiola gushed that Lahm was "at another level", and he explained that football matches are decided in midfield – so you must play your best players, namely Lahm, in that part of the pitch.

The German captained his country to victory at the 2014 World Cup in Brazil, and typically played half the tournament in midfield before moving to right-back for the final three matches to help marshall a creaking defence. With Lahm in the back four, Germany conceded just one goal, and that was a late consolation in the 7-1 semi-final win over Brazil.

In many respects Lahm is far from the archetypal modern footballer. He is not someone who can be condensed into a YouTube highlights package, or whose skills can be easily captured in a computer game, and Lord knows what his Emoji would be. Partly as a consequence he has never won the German Footballer of the Year award, let alone the more vaunted Ballon d'Or. Instead Lahm has always stood out because of his professionalism, versatility and intelligence - qualities that have stood out since he was a teenager.

The German journalist Uli Hesse wrote that the episode with Sir Alex, who tried to sign him after Shtuttgart beat Manchester United in the Champions League, "has been the story of the last 10 years: Lahm fitted in wherever you played him, hardly ever put in even a middling performance and immediately earned the admiration of anyone who knows the game." Hermann Gerland, Lahm's coach in the Bayern reserves later reflected: "Lahm was already perfect when he was 17. He could do it all, there was nothing left for me to teach him. Philipp never played a bad game for me. He is incapable of playing badly."

Hesse pointed out that Germany's fall from grace after Lahm's international retirement following the World Cup win was hardly surprising: "From one day to the next, he [manager Joachim Low] had to make do without one of the best defensive midfielders in the world, one of the best left-backs in the world, the best right-back in the world and his right-hand man on the pitch, a player whose understanding of the game is so faultless that the most famous coach in the world has called him the most intelligent footballer he's ever worked with. These four key figures are called Philipp Lahm."