christinaa
Gossip Girl
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2012
- Messages
- 11,522
- Supports
- There's only one United!
For those who saw him play it has to be George Best at number 1 .
Depends on how willing you are to overlook his private life really. Stealing, repeated drink driving offences and domestic abuse allegations don't lend themselves to making someone my favourite anything.For those who saw him play it has to be George Best at number 1 .
We're talking about favourite United 'players' here and even Pele had said that Bestie was the best player in the world.Depends on how willing you are to overlook his private life really. Stealing, repeated drink driving offences and domestic abuse allegations don't lend themselves to making someone my favourite anything.
Yes Christinaa, Georgie was the best. Christiano, Bobby, Denis, Paul , Ryan and Eric ( more or less in that order) are the next best I have seen personally, I was just too young to see 'the babes'.We're talking about favourite United 'players' here and even Pele had said that Bestie was the best player in the world.
Yep, we're talking about "favourite" United players, not "best" United players. Likability matters as much as what they did on the pitch, which is why we've had so many weird picks so far.We're talking about favourite United 'players' here and even Pele had said that Bestie was the best player in the world.
Agree with you 100% - Best was the best and is the favourite of many United supporters who had the fortune of watching him play.Yes Christinaa, Georgie was the best. Christiano, Bobby, Denis, Paul , Ryan and Eric ( more or less in that order) are the next best I have seen personally, I was just too young to see 'the babes'.
'Pele was the greatest player on earth, but George was made in heaven', a very true quote from a very famous sports journalist.
I voted for him in my top 10.Excellent Thread. Great work, really super stuff.
I wonder if Jesper Olsen makes the 100? He must. I have never seen anyone take a penalty like him.
Said already earlier on this thread if you are "old enough" and have had the pleasure of seeing Bestie in his heyday, then there is no other player you can have as no.1Agree with you 100% - Best was the best and is the favourite of many United supporters who had the fortune of watching him play.
And there he is.Excellent Thread. Great work, really super stuff.
I wonder if Jesper Olsen makes the 100? He must. I have never seen anyone take a penalty like him.
I saw Best heaps of times but, skilful as he was, he wasn't in the same class as Duncan Edwards in my opinion. Edwards simply had the lot.For those who saw him play it has to be George Best at number 1 .
How old are you to have seen Duncan Edwards? He is a near mythological player on this board. No doubt that people who saw him can rate him as one of the best ever, but since he died so young, we never what he have been. What was his skillsett. Wasn't he mostly a defensive midfielder? Could he dribble like Best? Score wonder goals?I saw Best heaps of times but, skilful as he was, he wasn't in the same class as Duncan Edwards in my opinion. Edwards simply had the lot.
Which has very little to do with being someones favourite united player. For example ruud was a great player but i never cared for him.We're talking about favourite United 'players' here and even Pele had said that Bestie was the best player in the world.
The problem with Butt is that if you have watched from that era of United, you will probably have a great affection for the lad... but ten players who you like more. His career would make him the best all time at 90 clubs in the league, here he almost becomes a footnote.Which has very little to do with being someones favourite united player. For example ruud was a great player but i never cared for him.
Sad ro see butt so far down the list. I had him in my draft top 10, can't remember if he actually made it but i've always really liked him. fecking schweinsteiger is higher. Laughable really.
It's a question of opinions and after watching Best play many times he's my favourite and greatest all-time footballer.Which has very little to do with being someones favourite united player. For example ruud was a great player but i never cared for him.
Sad ro see butt so far down the list. I had him in my draft top 10, can't remember if he actually made it but i've always really liked him. fecking schweinsteiger is higher. Laughable really.
Just wait another three years.Annoyed I never posted my list but enjoying the show.
Captain Marvel better be high up though
what was the minimum number of votes to make the list ? or did you just include anyone that was mentioned?There’s some ducking weird people at the bottom of this list.
Will try and knock them off this weekend. 102 players overall!
Anyone who was mentioned. We get some odd people but also some legends.what was the minimum number of votes to make the list ? or did you just include anyone that was mentioned?
I was going to say you should ignore those who only get 1 vote but then I suppose there is the likes of Crerand and Brown there who deserve a mention!Anyone who was mentioned. We get some odd people but also some legends.
Plus there are genuine favourites people have who are naff for United. I think it’s fun to do the “out there” players.I was going to say you should ignore those who only get 1 vote but then I suppose there is the likes of Crerand and Brown there who deserve a mention!