Rio put himself as #1 and Terry got offended that he's 5th?
Both wankers.
Both wankers.
Rio Ferdinand
- Thread starter choccy77
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran hold a long overdue conversation about United's awful league form with 1 win in 7. They discuss a disappointing draw at Bournemouth, a not so disappointing draw against Liverpool and a crushing defeat at Chelsea - Is time nearly over for Erik Ten Hag?
Then in a special second half of the pod, Nik welcomes Natalie ( https://twitter.com/natalie_17) to discuss the fortunes of Manchester United Women as they booked a place in the FA Cup Final after a historic first ever win vs. Chelsea.
This is just sad.Rio named Terry as the 5th best CB in Premier League history. Van Dijk then named Rio 1st and Terry 4th. Terry then posted this.
Rio easily the better player, anyone who says Vidic was better doesn't know what they're talking about.
Rio put himself as number 1 because it's true.
The type of pure defender that thrived in a Mourinho team but would be woefully out of place in a top team nowadays, whereas Rio set the blueprint for that. Terry was Stuart Pearce on steroids. Rio was cut from the same cloth as Maldini.
Both of them seem a bit thick but Terry is a genuine piece of work.
For context.
Rio's List:
1. Rio Ferdinand
2. Nemanja Vidic
3. Virgil van Dijk
4. Jaap Stam
5. John Terry
Van Dijk's List:
1. Rio Ferdinand
2. Vincent Kompany
3. Jaap Stam
4. John Terry
5. Sami Hyypia
Rio's List:
1. Rio Ferdinand
2. Nemanja Vidic
3. Virgil van Dijk
4. Jaap Stam
5. John Terry
Van Dijk's List:
1. Rio Ferdinand
2. Vincent Kompany
3. Jaap Stam
4. John Terry
5. Sami Hyypia
Tbf, Rio's list is quite close. My pick is Rio, Vidic, Terry, Kompany, Stam
Why is he a wanker for putting himself as number 1? He’s likely right too
What's wrong with putting himself at #1? He's right.
Hyypia.
Rio out of almost all defenders we have had in the league could have played in any generation and been still at the top. He is the best
Terry was a good defender but he wouldn't be in this City team in my opinion. His footballing ability gets overlooked for his aggression but even then, you would not pick him over Rio, Vidic, Stam or VVD. I would choose any of those 4 in my starting spots over him
Terry was a good defender but he wouldn't be in this City team in my opinion. His footballing ability gets overlooked for his aggression but even then, you would not pick him over Rio, Vidic, Stam or VVD. I would choose any of those 4 in my starting spots over him
Exactly this - he's so sensitive.
Why is no one talking about Hyypia over Vidic
Rio didn't have the luxury of Makelele and Essien in front of him in a deep defence, anyone remember Terry in a high line under AVB? He was awful wasn't he? (Although I might be misremembering, happy to be corrected)
Because VVD plays for Liverpool and had to include one of their CBs i guess. More surprised he didn't pick Carragher.Why is no one talking about Hyypia over Vidic
Ferdinand calls Terry a guy with a fragile ego advertising his own achievements. On the other hand, he puts himself at number 1. Not surprised though, if you hear Ferdinand's punditry you can tell he's thick.
Also mentions the Anton-Terry incident so he basically admits that he didn't separate Terry the player from Terry the person.
On the other side, you can see how mature and humble Virgil Van Dijk is, despite being the most complete defender you'll see.
Terry is an absolute prick but let's not deny how great a defender and captain he was. Proper warrior and great on the ball too. Chipped in with important goals too.
Also mentions the Anton-Terry incident so he basically admits that he didn't separate Terry the player from Terry the person.
On the other side, you can see how mature and humble Virgil Van Dijk is, despite being the most complete defender you'll see.
No, he isn't. John Terry is definitely better than Rio Ferdinand. People just don't like Terry because he's a crap person but he was a monster of a defender and even Roy Keane admires how good a captain he was.
Terry is an absolute prick but let's not deny how great a defender and captain he was. Proper warrior and great on the ball too. Chipped in with important goals too.
Neutral all right.
VVD also picked Sami Hyppia over Vidic, seems legit.
Edit - That’s before mentioning Campbell/Adam’s etc.
Just because I have a different opinion than yours? Ok.Neutral all right.
What does not supporting an European team have to do with an opinion on who's the better CB?
I'd have Sol Campbell as a top 5, great defender and seems right to have someone from Arsenal too.
Terry better than Rio and then you highlight his ability on the ball?
Bear in mind your own opinion on Terry will naturally be biased mate.
I rated him but a lot of people think he was vastly overrated. From my conversations with people over the years about Terry I suspect he wouldn't make a lot of people's top 5's or even top 10 as I said.
The only post I’ve read laughable so far is this one mate. Terry better than Rio? That’s hilarious.
Mentioning how thick Rio and connecting that with him putting himself as nr. 1 and why is VVD humble, cause of that list?
Terry was good on ball you say, did you ever watch Rio?
Stats really capture very little for defenders. McGrath and Stam were better than both Rio and Terry and I reckon an argument could be made for Sol too (he was basically Terry with pace). I would say that Rio was better than Terry though.
Unless I'm missing something about the rules it was noticeably classy of Van Dijk to omit himself from his own list.
Unless I'm missing something about the rules it was noticeably classy of Van Dijk to omit himself from his own list.
Jess, you guys are thick. It's okay to admit the the truth even though you are a united fan. Terry was head and shoulders above Rio. In his fifth league title at age 35, he played every single minute of that premier league campaign while Rio was being embarassed at QPR. Is it a coincidence that before the Guardiola era, terry has one of the highest win percentages? Oh and before you say that he played for a defensive Mourinho team, I must remind you that he played for about 3 years before Mourinho Joined and that was included in calculating his win percentage. We can all agree that Terry is a crap human being. But we need to take off our red tinted glasses and admit that he is one hell of a defender.
Brilliant defender but I’d argue that chelsea on average played more defensive football than Rio did at United which boosts his stats. He is top 5 but I’d take Rio, Vidic, Stam and VVD over him.
Terry better than Rio and then you highlight his ability on the ball?
Rio's ability on the ball is well known. I mentioned that about Terry because people don't talk much about that part of his game. With Rio, everyone knows how good he was on the ball.
VVD comes across as humble because he omits himself from his top 5 and even tries to stop Ferdinand when he puts VVD at 3.
Its so Pool fans dont try to burn his car.Why is no one talking about Hyypia over Vidic
Personally, I think Rio's list is absolutely bang on. Rio and Vidic are the best defenders in Premier League history hands down. He doesn't include the overrated Kompany which is correct as well. I might shuffle Terry a little higher but I think Van Dyke is the better and more complete player.
Clueless more like. It's not humble to leave yourself out for the sake of it ffs. Rio is easily the best Premier League CB ever and he rightly knows it.
He’s not better than Rio at all, in fact he wouldn’t do as great in the modern sides of the likes of Pep and Klopp, Rio would be the best defender in the world in all eras, that’s the big difference.
Forget who is better. They asked Rio for his opinion, he answered. Terry felt the need to go trawling the internet for graphics to prove he was better.
That's twatish behaviour.
That's twatish behaviour.
Mate, he placed hyppia at no 5 and omitted himself.
Not that I think omitting yourself from a greatest list is a sign of humbleness per se.
Okay fair enough, I might have misinterpreted your post. Terry was easily better than Cahill (and Stam) in that regard, but still ways off from Rio or VVD IMO.
Hyppia feck sake
It’s like having a list of your all time top forwards, then crowbarring Sinama Pongolle on the end
feck sakeIt’s like having a list of your all time top forwards, then crowbarring Sinama Pongolle on the end
He is not in the same bracket as the other defenders. He knows that himself, and Hypia instead of Vidic
Good VVD didnt add Agger on that list too.
This is now a low rent Messi v Ronaldo thread.
Rio was a pleasure to watch though.
Rio was a pleasure to watch though.