This
Roy Keane
- Thread starter MyOnlySolskjaer
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran hold a long overdue conversation about United's awful league form with 1 win in 7. They discuss a disappointing draw at Bournemouth, a not so disappointing draw against Liverpool and a crushing defeat at Chelsea - Is time nearly over for Erik Ten Hag?
Then in a special second half of the pod, Nik welcomes Natalie ( https://twitter.com/natalie_17) to discuss the fortunes of Manchester United Women as they booked a place in the FA Cup Final after a historic first ever win vs. Chelsea.
He doesn't want to know what Keane meant. He wants to protect his players. You can be 100% he doesn't care what Keane thinks or says.
Absolutely not. United never had a "how dare you criticise us" attitude.
Fergie would defend an individual player against personal attacks but he would often publicly bemoan a collective sloppiness of his players if it warranted it in order to keep standards up.
If anyone should know that it's Keane who did exactly the same thing for exactly the same reasons.
In fact, Keane's punditry is highly influenced by how he spoke in public about himself or his own team throughout his career.
He takes over the interview so no one can ask him anything he doesn't want to be asked. That's really all he is doing just picking a minor thing to make a big deal off then he walks off job done
I think he cannot be intentionally hurting if he doesn´t give it one thought can he? I think Keano isn´t being intentionally hurting or biased towards anything he just speaks from his point of view and of course normally not worrying what other people have to say about it.
Imagine being this sensationalist. How do you cope with life?
I think this looks worse on Klopp than Keane, yes his team won by a fairly convincing score in the end however they were not exactly solid either so sloppy statements could probably stick. Klopp is getting all emotional and up himself on national TV having heard 1% of a sentence from Keane, sure the scousers are lapping it up but he came across as a moron to me.
And it's not just his teeth.
Just watched it back. I was expecting something good. feckin storm in a tea-cup.
I hear my name is being used in vain?
Agreed. I really don't like him.
Can you imagine the meltdown if Solskjaer jumped on a Carragher comment like that after mishearing what he said?
I have a different recollection of events but do not really want to spend the day digging old news articles to prove a pointless argument.
I do not see any difference between Klopp's attitude and reaction and our very own SAF's approach towards media criticizing our players.
All Keane said was that Liverpool were sloppy at times while praising the shit out of them, he hardy had a go at klopp or call him crap
I am not into this specific case about who is right who is wrong. I am talking generally about how managers can be defensive toward any small hint of criticism, in a response to another poster.
This, so much hyperbole around this nothing event... people calling it box office feck me.
Ah well the looking for excuses crowd would be all over it obviously
Fair enough, I think klopp always comes across passive agressive if he doesn’t like something, quite a childish trait. Nothing to do with him defending his players
I don't want you to either!
But, the difference with Ferguson is if the media criticise Cantona, Ronaldo, Veron or De Gea, etc he would defend them to the hilt. But that's because it's against an individual player.
If Andy Gray had said their defending was sloppy he wouldn't go on a rant like that. He might agree or disagree but most likely he wouldn't give a shit.
It’s not newsworthy.
Probably would be if Ole reacted to something carragher said in a similar fashion to be fair. Just everyone already knows klopp is ok to act like this because he’s eccentric and got passion
I don’t think Klopp reacted in any particularly bad way. He got the wrong end of the stick and defended his team after a good performance.
See nothing of note whether it’s Klopp or whether it would be anyone else.
I'm a die hard united fan, and it was amusing watching Klopp show even the merest hint of a crack in his cool persona. He was right about his teams performance though, they were at it from the first minute and forced mistake after mistake from Arsenal who looked scared to death at times. Great performance, with small elements of sloppy slipped in 
A version of it, yes.
Keane could not give a shit, having watched the interview He just repeated his whole thing, including them being sloppy contrary to what Klopp what saying, and told him to rewatch the programme, to which Klopp said he would. Just two men sorting out a misunderstanding. If Fergie couldn’t intimidate Keano, Klopp hasn’t a chance.
Also, annihilated? Seriously?
He just repeated his whole thing, including them being sloppy contrary to what Klopp what saying, and told him to rewatch the programme, to which Klopp said he would. Just two men sorting out a misunderstanding. If Fergie couldn’t intimidate Keano, Klopp hasn’t a chance.Also, annihilated? Seriously?
Wow. Touchy Jurgen. Such a twitch-fiend.
In order to be a manager you have to be football obsessed. Managers don't go home after training and turn on Bake-Off and relax.
what keane said was bang on, they were sloppy in the defending, arsenal were threw a good few times, they have been the same all season, klopp comes across as extremely fake to me, if they win he usually talks about how well the other teams tactic were and if they lose then the other teams tactics were not good, like seriously what does he want all teams to play a way that suits playing Liverpool?
Seems like some of our posters think of themselves as football connoisseurs, not a mere “brute” like Keane. Hahaha armchair little shits
I think the description was apt, but there wasn’t any additional tactical insight.
I think the description was apt, but there wasn’t any additional tactical insight.
Was dissapointment Keane backed down. He ain't that type of guy.
Klopp and cool? He's as cool as a virgin in a brothelI'm a die hard united fan, and it was amusing watching Klopp show even the merest hint of a crack in his cool persona. He was right about his teams performance though, they were at it from the first minute and forced mistake after mistake from Arsenal who looked scared to death at times. Great performance, with small elements of sloppy slipped in
I think Stroppy Klopp’s understanding of what Keane said was sloppy.
Last edited:
Did I hear Klopp saying that NOTHING was sloppy in that game? Maybe he took off his glasses for Robertson’s clearance to Lacazette
He didn't back down as he was never really criticising them in the first place . He was more bemused by Klopp's reaction than anything
Keane has been complimentary of Liverpool by and large and when he sees good football he will say it how it is. It was a pretty embarrassing rant from Klopp.
He didn't. He literally told him he misheard him and that he said they were sloppy in parts and he should watch the comment back. Klopp decided to focus on that and other than tell him he's a cnut Keane couldn't say much more on TV.
Which Klopp reacted by saying there was nothing sloppy about the performance. Which Keane didn't then back up his sloppy in parts statement. He backed down.
What should he have done at that point? Ripped his shirt off? Escalated the situation further? Not entirely sure where you wanted Keane to go with someone who is clearly living in a mental place.