The cubicles were full and he’s full of shit
The cubicles were full and he’s full of shit
He just gaslit us all insteadGood luck Ruben, hope you smash it at Milan. Always want our former managers to do well, even if they were poor here..... Sure he didn't try to fail
Let's also not forget this gem:
https://www.redcafe.net/threads/ruben-amorim-sacked.490912/page-70#post-33934603
Impossible job indeed.

Is there a way to hide a thread because it’s causing you PTSD?
Go to the top of this page and choose ignore thread.Is there a way to hide a thread because it’s causing you PTSD?
At the top right of the thread above the first post of the page.
Thanks, cyaGo to the top of this page and choose ignore thread.
I disagree that it was knee jerk. He was fortunate to be kept on after losing to Spurs in the final, and should've been sacked after Grimsby. If not then, probably Everton. He had chance after chance, and would've probably still been here if he hadn't got himself sacked after throwing his toys out the pram. Like all of our previous full time managers post Fergie, we kept him on longer than we should've.The sheer hatred Amorim gets on here by a load of posters says more about the poster than it does about Amorim.
I was sad to see him go, not because he was doing a great job because he clearly was not but I'd hoped we had moved on from knee jerk decisions and then hiring a caretaker manager with very little experience.
But, here we are again and good luck to Carrick for the coming season.
But, I bet you one thing, Amorim will have a far more successful managerial career than Carrick.
Most are disagreeing with you and I think they're right. He 100% wanted the sack and was happy when he got it. The last couple or so months of his tenure he gave up and sacrificed points in order to prove a point like a child.Good luck Ruben, hope you smash it at Milan. Always want our former managers to do well, even if they were poor here..... Sure he didn't try to fail
The sheer hatred Amorim gets on here by a load of posters says more about the poster than it does about Amorim.
I was sad to see him go, not because he was doing a great job because he clearly was not but I'd hoped we had moved on from knee jerk decisions and then hiring a caretaker manager with very little experience.
But, here we are again and good luck to Carrick for the coming season.
But, I bet you one thing, Amorim will have a far more successful managerial career than Carrick.
5 at the back?
Mainoo hat trick pleaseI would love it if we fecking beat tbem!!!
The cubicles were full and he’s full of shit
I disagree - maybe at the very end, the final press conference, he was, but for the rest of his tenure, I am pretty sure he was trying - nobody goes into a job trying to fail, it's complete BS to think he was. Was he good enough, no. Was he far too stubborn with his formation, yes. I still wish him the best and hope he does well at AC Milan.I disagree that it was knee jerk. He was fortunate to be kept on after losing to Spurs in the final, and should've been sacked after Grimsby. If not then, probably Everton. He had chance after chance, and would've probably still been here if he hadn't got himself sacked after throwing his toys out the pram. Like all of our previous full time managers post Fergie, we kept him on longer than we should've.
Carrick may not succeed, but he's done a lot more to warrant optimism/patience than Amorim did.
Most are disagreeing with you and I think they're right. He 100% wanted the sack and was happy when he got it. The last couple or so months of his tenure he gave up and sacrificed points in order to prove a point like a child.
I agree with you up to the bolded part and that’s for one reason; he never thanked the match going fans. Now sure, a lot of those statements thanking fans etc are pure lip service and PR fluff, but he got way more support from the stands than his results merited. To not acknowledge the fans on leaving was really poor form and very much turned me towards “go on, f**k off. Hope you fail spectacularly, you prick”I disagree - maybe at the very end, the final press conference, he was, but for the rest of his tenure, I am pretty sure he was trying - nobody goes into a job trying to fail, it's complete BS to think he was. Was he good enough, no. Was he far too stubborn with his formation, yes. I still wish him the best and hope he does well at AC Milan.
I found that a bit of a slap in the face too. The support he was given home and away was absolutely staggering compared to what he'd experience at any other club our size if he gave them the same results and magically kept his job.I agree with you up to the bolded part and that’s for one reason; he never thanked the match going fans. Now sure, a lot of those statements thanking fans etc are pure lip service and PR fluff, but he got way more support from the stands than his results merited. To not acknowledge the fans on leaving was really poor form and very much turned me towards “go on, f**k off. Hope you fail spectacularly, you prick”
He went a year after every bad result - meaning pretty much twice a week - with some variation of "oh boy i sure am doing a terrible job here, if I were my boss I'd sack me.I disagree - maybe at the very end, the final press conference, he was, but for the rest of his tenure, I am pretty sure he was trying - nobody goes into a job trying to fail, it's complete BS to think he was. Was he good enough, no. Was he far too stubborn with his formation, yes. I still wish him the best and hope he does well at AC Milan.
Oh wow![]()
He went a year after every bad result - meaning pretty much twice a week - with some variation of "oh boy i sure am doing a terrible job here, if I were my boss I'd sack me."
For whatever reason both the fans and his bosses chose to interpret that as the guy being frank and speaking his mind and admitting his faults, so in the end he had to outright spell it out for them
I wasnt being serious, sorry man. Absolutely make your way to the San Siro especially for a derby if you can afford it. I felt an opportunity wasted after having spent a week in Milan and nearly a month in Torino to not see a match there. I did see Torino-Napoli where McTominay scored the only goal, which was a nice consolation. Nice stadium and nice fans, Torino.Thanks, good shout, but Specifically I want to see a game at the San Siro. The weekend is actually the Milan derby, but that’s going to be difficult to get tickets for.
If you read that post carefully enough, you can hear the music for Eminem’s Stan.Let's also not forget this gem:
https://www.redcafe.net/threads/ruben-amorim-sacked.490912/page-70#post-33934603
Impossible job indeed.
He didn’t go into the job trying to fail, no. He definitely gave up by the end, though, and was happy he got sacked.I disagree - maybe at the very end, the final press conference, he was, but for the rest of his tenure, I am pretty sure he was trying - nobody goes into a job trying to fail, it's complete BS to think he was. Was he good enough, no. Was he far too stubborn with his formation, yes. I still wish him the best and hope he does well at AC Milan.
He is winging it. (wing backing it?)I don't think he has any idea how to properly coach a a back 3. He is clearly so tied to it but it always looks so shaky and uncertain.
I think he said himself that he hardly ever played in one during his career.
Yeah once or twice during his miserable spell hereDid he ever have back to back wins? I honestly can’t remember.
It happened on one run....Yeah once or twice during his miserable spell here
Those were the daysIt happened on one run....
Sunderland (H)
Liverpool (A)
Brighton (H)
Likely to be staying in Como, so possibly get to a game there as well. The San Siro won’t be there much longer, and I think it’s one of the most iconic stadia in Europe, so want to see it before it’s gone. Even though not serious, the Como shoot is a good one.I wasnt being serious, sorry man. Absolutely make your way to the San Siro especially for a derby if you can afford it. I felt an opportunity wasted after having spent a week in Milan and nearly a month in Torino to not see a match there. I did see Torino-Napoli where McTominay scored the only goal, which was a nice consolation. Nice stadium and nice fans, Torino.
If he'd got 4 points out of 9 from those we'd have been about 15th.Those were the days
The truth is that no matter what you think about his tactics, his training or even the results. It's just really evident that the job was too big for him and he was absolutely shell shocked by it.If he'd got 4 points out of 9 from those we'd have been about 15th.
I honestly think he left us at his peak and he knew it. His acolytes used his exit leave position as evidence it was going well enough.
I have seen this movie too many times. Playing at the back and concede stupid goals. Morim football
The sheer hatred Amorim gets on here by a load of posters says more about the poster than it does about Amorim.
But, I bet you one thing, Amorim will have a far more successful managerial career than Carrick.
The truth is that no matter what you think about his tactics, his training or even the results. It's just really evident that the job was too big for him and he was absolutely shell shocked by it.
Another story came out the other day about the 2-2 draw against Everton in his first season. At half time we were 2-0 down and he didn't even talk to the team, he just stood bent over in the hall with his head in his hands. Fletcher had to give the teamtalk and we got it back to 2-2.
Saw it at Grimsby, saw it in the things he said and in how he ultimately got sacked. The job swallowed him up, too big for him.
I have real concerns about Carrick's level (fully backing him as he's the manager) but even with those concerns, he's comfortable in the size of it all.
get out! (I believe it too)In a way I actually feel bad for Amorim when I see these things.get out! (I believe it too)
Same re Carrick, I think you'd have to be a deluded fan to think he's some sort of managerial genius or perhaps even the man to lead Man United back to the promised land, but what we need after the last two appointments, is a manager that just doesn't do fundamentally moronic things (like Eriksen in a midfield 2 v Newcastle) or playing a system that highlights most of the teams weaknesses - and you trust Carrick on that front.
The truth is that no matter what you think about his tactics, his training or even the results. It's just really evident that the job was too big for him and he was absolutely shell shocked by it.
Another story came out the other day about the 2-2 draw against Everton in his first season. At half time we were 2-0 down and he didn't even talk to the team, he just stood bent over in the hall with his head in his hands. Fletcher had to give the teamtalk and we got it back to 2-2.
Saw it at Grimsby, saw it in the things he said and in how he ultimately got sacked. The job swallowed him up, too big for him.
I have real concerns about Carrick's level (fully backing him as he's the manager) but even with those concerns, he's comfortable in the size of it all.
Fine, go support him then?
Between the guy who by your own admission did a bad job and Carrick who worked wonders with a supposedly bad squad, you are going with the former. Despite saying we can kiss any european football goodbye and Carrick utterly proving you wrong, Amorim having a "far more successful career" is what you're concerned about right now.
Let's also not forget this gem:
https://www.redcafe.net/threads/ruben-amorim-sacked.490912/page-70#post-33934603
Impossible job indeed.


He had this "Come on man!! This all worked perfectly in my head, when I thought about it. Why is it not working on the ground?" expression.I used the word "shell shocked" which is a touch dramatic but it almost felt like that towards the end. He just looked drained.
