Pogue Mahone
In the middle.
https://www.reddit.com/r/rugbyunion/s/AewcioCcBx
Just watching this clip. England really got screwed here. Clear call of penalty advantage and only downgraded (which was a debatable call anyway) while the ball was in the air heading towards Smith, who must have already been planning to kick.
I also can’t remember ever seeing a penalty advantage downgraded like that, so long after the original call. So, at the very least, it’s a really unusual scenario. Obvious call was to blow up and award England a scrum. There’s no way Smith had the time to process such a radical change in circumstances that quickly. There was even an opportunity for a formal TMO review of the knock on to make absolutely sure it was accidental.
Whole thing was a shambles. And it handed France the 6N. Madness.
Just watching this clip. England really got screwed here. Clear call of penalty advantage and only downgraded (which was a debatable call anyway) while the ball was in the air heading towards Smith, who must have already been planning to kick.
I also can’t remember ever seeing a penalty advantage downgraded like that, so long after the original call. So, at the very least, it’s a really unusual scenario. Obvious call was to blow up and award England a scrum. There’s no way Smith had the time to process such a radical change in circumstances that quickly. There was even an opportunity for a formal TMO review of the knock on to make absolutely sure it was accidental.
Whole thing was a shambles. And it handed France the 6N. Madness.
Last edited:
