At least until widespread testing drops below 3% positive (still much higher than the levels South Korea, Australia and NZ considered safe).what was the other option Stan? Stay closed forever?
At least until widespread testing drops below 3% positive (still much higher than the levels South Korea, Australia and NZ considered safe).what was the other option Stan? Stay closed forever?
Depends what you want to achieve. If its going from 0 deaths per day, as we have had recently, to doubling the amount of infections at a rate not seen since March, then I'd say its all been a great success. Wonder how we got to 0 deaths per day?what was the other option Stan? Stay closed forever?
Fundamental problems.I'm pessimistic to the invention of an effective vaccine too, and I actually agree herd immunity is perhaps one of the most effective and quickest ways to deal with this pandemic. However there are also plenty of solid reasons why we have to respond as we do:
P. S. I'm a healthcare professional working in Hong Kong and there is a third major outbreak here right now.
- SARS CoV-2 is novel which means no one has ever been exposed to and produced antibody. It creates a huge burden to the medical system when many in the society get sick at the same time. We saw that in Italy but luckily most of the countries have taken the right measures and their systems haven't collapsed.
- There is no known, standard, established treatment for COVID-19, unlike seasonal ordinary flu which has been well studied over the years. Many of the treatments for COVID-19 right now are actually experimental and inconclusive, even including Ribavirin which appears to be the best candidate.
- The mortality rate of COVID-19 is much higher than seasonal flu, and the percentage of serious cases is also much higher.
- The transmission rate of COVID-19 is much higher than seasonal flu.
They did, but its spreading again. Things are closing again and they just had their highest ever daily case figures.Fundamental problems.
I thought HK had things under control?
I'm a doctor in USA.
Holland already had the virus though, it wasn’t imported.There are other options than" Forever"
The tests at countries borders are improving with one that looks like it can give a pretty reliable answer within an hour of the test. So test at the country you leave from and test at the country you arrive in. Contact tracing of new arrivals even after those tests for the first 12 or 14 days of their time in the country. That will reduce the need for quarantines. Prioritising the countries being opened up to, already happening. Mandating masks for new arrivals for their first 2 weeks as well is another layer to assist with opening up.
The faster countries get the virus under control the faster they can repair their economies. Essentially that means protecting its citizens first and foremost.
Have you ever “really” had zero deaths though? The increased mortality and care home data coming out of Holland says you guys are thousands short on your numbers.Depends what you want to achieve. If its going from 0 deaths per day, as we have had recently,
I dont understand how this relates to the staying closed "forever" thing? Once Holland gets it completely under control then Those measures I mentioned can come into play. It takes roughly 5-6 weeks for a hard lockdown to really lower the transmission rates, probably even shorter a time frame depending on the target needed.Holland already had the virus though, it wasn’t imported.
One word here, Australia. There are no guarantees even if they get cases to zero, and European borders can’t work like your suggestion.I dont understand how this relates to the staying closed "forever" thing? Once Holland gets it completely under control then Those measures I mentioned can come into play. It takes roughly 5-6 weeks for a hard lockdown to really lower the transmission rates, probably even shorter a time frame depending on the target needed.
6 + 6 = 12. Those 12 weeks can make an enormous difference in a country’s ability to test, track and trace. Which is crucial when it comes to managing the inevitable future outbreaks. I know for a fact that Ireland would have been absolutely screwed without that early, hard lockdown.One word here, Australia. There are no guarantees even if they get cases to zero, and European borders can’t work like your suggestion.
And after a 5-6 week hard lockdown, it takes roughly 6 weeks for numbers to start climbing again as we are seeing in lots of places.
It’s just not as simple as many are making out.
Emphasis on "had". Hong Kong dealt with the initial crisis quite successfully, we screened everyone coming back from overseas, we sent every SARS CoV-2 positive person (including asymptomatic carrier) to negative pressure wards, we adopted working and studying from home, we prohibited gatherings, and most importantly everyone was self-disciplinary to wear a mask. The number of cases was kept at a very low level. But then the measures were loosened and people became tired of following the rules, and we are facing an unprecedented crisis.Fundamental problems.
I thought HK had things under control?
I'm a doctor in USA.
What does that have to with Stan being angry at the Dutch government for opening again?6 + 6 = 12. Those 12 weeks can make an enormous difference in a country’s ability to test, track and trace. Which is crucial when it comes to managing the inevitable future outbreaks. I know for a fact that Ireland would have been absolutely screwed without that early, hard lockdown.
I have him on ignore. I was just wading in to point out that the end goal of a lockdown doesn’t have to be complete eradication. It’s about keeping caseload manageable while preparing to better deal with future outbreaks.What does that have to with Stan being angry at the Dutch government for opening again?
I agree with you Pogue, Stan was angry that Holland opened again and now casing are rising. There was a suggestion from another that they could close and get case numbers close to zero and then test everyone entering the country.I have him on ignore. I was just wading in to point out that the end goal of a lockdown doesn’t have to be complete eradication. It’s about keeping caseload manageable while preparing to better deal with future outbreaks.
Ok, yeah. Agreed. I’m getting really frustrated with Europeans saying we should emulate the Aus/NZ approach. There’s a bunch of clinicians in Ireland whose opinions I respect that keep banging this drum but I just don’t see how it could work in somewhere as interconnected as a European country. Even if we are an island.I agree with you Pogue, Stan was angry that Holland opened again and now casing are rising. There was a suggestion from another that they could close and get case numbers close to zero and then test everyone entering the country.
Fact is, that simply cannot work long term especially in mainland Europe. And even getting case to Aus levels guarantees nothing other than as you say... invaluable time.
Ditto, and I haven’t seen anyone suggest how it could be achieved. It’ll be something akin to locking states off from each other long term in the US.Ok, yeah. Agreed. I’m getting really frustrated with Europeans saying we should emulate the Aus/NZ approach. There’s a bunch of clinicians in Ireland whose opinions I respect that keep banging this drum but I just don’t see how it could work in somewhere as interconnected as a European country. Even if we are an island.
Id say that when 3 people died in the weekly report that theres an outside chance that there were zero reported deaths on some days. Now the confirmed cases has doubled in the last week.Have you ever “really” had zero deaths though? The increased mortality and care home data coming out of Holland says you guys are thousands short on your numbers.
First there are no regulations for Germany, just for the federal states. In case of Düsseldorf that would be North-Rhine Westphalia.Don't know if the right topic, but I'm going to Düsseldorf for the weekend (Friday - Sunday). Can someone who lives in Germany give me some pointers? Are there special regulations in bars and restaurants? Do they close at certain hours? Regulations in Musea and public places?
Thanks!
I think I have walked into something and got the wrong end of the stickOne word here, Australia. There are no guarantees even if they get cases to zero, and European borders can’t work like your suggestion.
And after a 5-6 week hard lockdown, it takes roughly 6 weeks for numbers to start climbing again as we are seeing in lots of places.
It’s just not as simple as many are making out.
Danke! @do.ob, hook me up! I'll check with the hotel too.First there are no regulations for Germany, just for the federal states. In case of Düsseldorf that would be North-Rhine Westphalia.
Most important point is, by law you are required to self quarantine for 14 days after arrival, IF you are from a designated corona risk area, luckily for you Belgium is not on it. I would recommend to ask a contact person in Germany about how it is handled, either the hotel or the person you are staying with.
In general, wear a mask in every public space indoors, and even outside when you are not able to social distance.
Edit: Maybe @do.ob knows more, I think he is from North-Rhine Westphalia.
All those costs will be passed on to the insurers, who will pass them on to the US citizens. And they will be absolutely screwed by the pharma companies over the price of the vaccines. Same way they pay over the odds for all of their healthcare.US paying 2 billion to that German company about 100 million doses of vaccine (and getting a deal for another 500m other). They also financed Moderna, so I think they will stockpile those vaccines. And I believe they have a dead for the Oxford vaccine too (these three are the most promising Western vaccines).
I think right now it is pretty shit to be in the US with regard to Covid, but it will likely be the place to be next year. Buying their way out of this mess.
From what I saw, it is the government who is buying them, not hospitals/insurers etc.All those costs will be passed on to the insurers, who will pass them on to the US citizens. And they will be absolutely screwed by the pharma companies over the price of the vaccines. Same way they pay over the odds for all of their healthcare.
This is what I found online regarding restrictions when entering the country, to be safe I would confirm with your hotel though:Danke! @do.ob, hook me up! I'll check with the hotel too.
Thanks mate, helps a lot. Some of our friends are worried to go because it wouldn't be fun with all the restrictions, but it seems it's exactly the same rules as in Belgium.This is what I found online regarding restrictions when entering the country, to be safe I would confirm with your hotel though:
https://www.rki.de/DE/Content/InfAZ...072020_17_45Uhr_en.pdf?__blob=publicationFile
In general people have become quite relaxed about the virus.
As a rule of thumb put on a mask in enclosed public spaces, especially trains. Toddlers are exempt, if you're planning to bring any.
Some places may ask you to write down contact info for potential tracing.
As for restaurants/pubs: you basically put on a mask every time you're on the move, but tables are supposed to be a safe distance from each other, so you can take it off once you're at your seat. There is no curfew for bars you're can get as drunk as before, but if you're trying to visit a club it will probably be closed.
A lot of places (super markets especially) used to ask people to pay cashless, but at the moment that doesn't seem to be a thing anymore.
Some places may require you to make an appointment/reservation to handle their Corona-adjusted capacity limits, so to be safe I would check the website of museums or other places you want to visit, before you show up.
You're welcome. I would expect most EU countries to be more or less in line. They all face the same balancing act of safety vs freedom/economy.Thanks mate, helps a lot. Some of our friends are worried to go because it wouldn't be fun with all the restrictions, but it seems it's exactly the same rules as in Belgium.
If them getting the vaccine in any way impinges on Europe's ability to vaccinate it's own people they will just block the export, same as the US would (and has tried to) do to us.US paying 2 billion to that German company about 100 million doses of vaccine (and getting a deal for another 500m other). They also financed Moderna, so I think they will stockpile those vaccines. And I believe they have a dead for the Oxford vaccine too (these three are the most promising Western vaccines).
I think right now it is pretty shit to be in the US with regard to Covid, but it will likely be the place to be next year. Buying their way out of this mess.
Only 4, no worries We just found out about 5 minutes ago, that my friend who's coming along his mothers direct colleague has tested positive this weekend. She was going to babysit on his daughter next weekend when we are in Düsseldorf. Looks like that's a no-go.You're welcome. I would expect most EU countries to be more or less in line. They all face the same balancing act of safety vs freedom/economy.
The limit on random public gatherings is currently 10 people, with some exceptions to people form the same household. So depending on how large your group is that could be a problem.
Depends on which company does it first. I think that Europe might be more generous on sharing it than the US.If them getting the vaccine in any way impinges on Europe's ability to vaccinate it's own people they will just block the export, same as the US would (and has tried to) do to us.
It's almost as if this is something that we are taught from a young age and is recommended regardless of if there is a global pandemic going on. I certainly can't remember being told it was ok for me to only eat ice cream unless there is a killer virus doing the rounds.
Oh boy, Doutzen Kroes is now a virologist as well. She has a lot of questions after doing "hours of research" like, Why doesn't anyone tell us to eat vitamins and nutritious foods to combat covid!
My main question is, how does she know about nutrition, I doubt she's ever actually eaten anything in her life.
I'd still marry her.
The news of USA securing advanced doses - I feel like that's a good thing. I would assume if the US is vaccinated, they'd donate/sell the excess vaccines that work. Getting advanced manufacturing is important to get the supply chains going and a lot of countries don't have the money for that. It is good that USA/UK have committed money to it.Depends on which company does it first. I think that Europe might be more generous on sharing it than the US.
Nice thing is that the big three (Oxford, Moderna and that German company) seem all to be doing very well, so hopefully all three of them are successful. They are made using different technology so if all are able to scale, by the end of spring most of the Western world is gonna get vaccinated. I hope that all these three companies will allocate a large dose of vaccines for Africa/South America either for free or cheaply (Us is paying 20 dollars for a vaccine, I am not sure that this is affordable for many countries where the government needs to purchase tens of millions of vaccines, especially considering the economical hit most countries have endured).
News from China and Russia seem to be quite good too, but it is hard to know if those are news or propaganda.
Research by YouTube videos is the new primary literature don't you know?Anyone that claims they've done hours of research, and aren't in a medical or science field, generally tend to 'research' areas which only support their agenda. You can add this to any of the conspiracy theorists approach, and usually is done as a method to avoid the burden of proof.