We need to advertise Darmian Rojones as a Serie A beater to Inter and they'll probably go for all three seeing as they love our garbage and have less intelligence than our board.Can someone in Italy pickup Rojo and Darmian too?
Smalling / on loan to Roma 1 year
- Thread starter Zoo
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran hold a long overdue conversation about United's awful league form with 1 win in 7. They discuss a disappointing draw at Bournemouth, a not so disappointing draw against Liverpool and a crushing defeat at Chelsea - Is time nearly over for Erik Ten Hag?
Then in a special second half of the pod, Nik welcomes Natalie ( https://twitter.com/natalie_17) to discuss the fortunes of Manchester United Women as they booked a place in the FA Cup Final after a historic first ever win vs. Chelsea.
- Status
This is fracking unbelievable, our club is run by morons
Tuanzebe is third choice already? Not too sure about that.
Bringing in the kids is great, but we've left ourselves exposed to them having to be good enough right away all over the pitch, which is a massive risk for a club needing to get top 4.
Not true. Just because he has been played there in the past does not mean he can play there. He can’t.
A better CB? Wait for the season to end man, 3games he's already getting the stick, You will see he's just an expensive Smalling, He's no better than Smalling, only for This new stupid fact of passing shit everyone going berserk for, Hope u saw with your Lindelof and Maguire Crystal palace had 3shots and scored two all to defensive errors, u would soon see that we have been robbed with Maguire,
I think it’s a very smart move for all parties..Smalling needs to play, now he is also in the shop window if he/club wants a permanent move away.
We have way too many defenders and whilst he has been a great servant, he doesn’t fit Ole’s plan for the future.
I was terrrified of how many penalties Smalling would give away with Var so I am happy he is on loan in Italy rather than with us or another English club which could affect selling price..
I am excited about how strong and smart Ole has proved to be in this window...we couldn’t get some of the players he wanted but he didn’t try and get others just for the sake of it.. at the same time he is freeing up cash and getting players out on loan and in the shop window..
We have way too many defenders and whilst he has been a great servant, he doesn’t fit Ole’s plan for the future.
I was terrrified of how many penalties Smalling would give away with Var so I am happy he is on loan in Italy rather than with us or another English club which could affect selling price..
I am excited about how strong and smart Ole has proved to be in this window...we couldn’t get some of the players he wanted but he didn’t try and get others just for the sake of it.. at the same time he is freeing up cash and getting players out on loan and in the shop window..
What on earth is going on? Smalling's a good CB. Makes no sense to hand Jones a new contract and let Smalling go.
The obsession with playing out from the back baffles me. It only works if you have defenders who can actually defend as well unless you have a midfield so dominant they starve the opposition of possession. What we have now is a starting centre back with question marks over their actual defending and any ‘ability’ they have on the ball rendered useless by our midfield not being good enough.
I hate to add to the negativity here, but I wouldn’t loan Smalling.. I would get rid of Darmian, Jones, Rojo, and Bailly, and in that order too.. but if we were to loan out Smalling then (I’ll probably get a lot of stick for this) I would keep Darmian to cover for cb with Tuanzebe and get rid of Rojo, and Jones. I feel like Darmian does decent every time he plays as a cb..
Wait why are we loaning out Smalling? I thought he was behind Maguire / Lindelof in the pecking order, shouldn't it be Rojo / Jones that leaves instead?
Maybe Smalling insisted on having first team football while Rojo / Jones / Bailly are happy with being backups.
Maybe Smalling insisted on having first team football while Rojo / Jones / Bailly are happy with being backups.
We can't loan or sell players that don't want to leave or no one wants. Someone wants Smalling and he's happy to go, so off he goes.
I understand that we've got too many CBs in the squad. However Smalling is our 3rd best CB at worst and our 2nd best CB at best. Letting him go is indeed a mistake. If the club wanted to get rid of CBs then it should have allowed Rojo and Bailly to leave + it shouldn't have renewed Jones contract. Now we're left with a kid and 3 very injury prone and shit CBs as cover. All for what? 2.3m fee? Its not as if we're buying someone till at least January.
So close to a testimonial
Honestly though I think he'll be back at the club after his loan, and I doubt Ole is still here at that point.
This thread is going round in circles. It’s either your happy he’s going, or Rojo, Bailey or Jones should of been sold first. Rinse and repeat.
Smalling and Sanchez will be paraded as if they are 'new signings' with Ole being labelled as naive and too idealistic.
He is not good enough to be starting but he’s by far our third best defender.
I don’t understand why would we ship Smalling out before Rojo or Jones.
We continue to weaken our squad and what makes it even worst is that we are not selling players, we are loaning them.
It’s one bad decision after another.
I don’t understand why would we ship Smalling out before Rojo or Jones.
We continue to weaken our squad and what makes it even worst is that we are not selling players, we are loaning them.
It’s one bad decision after another.
Pretty clear he is I think considering he's the only other CB who makes the match day squads
Depends also on whether the player accepts the offer (which most probably is lower) and if there are any takers.
What people don't understand is, no one wants Jones, Rojo and Bailey
This. It's so simple and logical - not sure why everyone is saying we shouldn't have loaned him out.
Bottom line is, are we better without Smalling in the squad? Was it a great deal?
The answer for both is no. So I don’t get why would we do that besides lowering the wage structure.
Good forbids an injury from Lindelof or Maguire and we’ll be seeing Phil “calamity” Jones starting games.
I m sure there are clubs interested in all of them but they are not prepared to pay what we and the players are asking.What people don't understand is, no one wants Jones, Rojo and Bailey
Best case scenario was letting go on a free transfer.
As things are,you re more likely to see Tuanzebe rather than Jones
Jones will start a game and walk off injured.
We do seem short of good, fit, centre backs, if we get an injury to Maguire or Lindelof. In the old days, clubs had a recall clause in loan agreements in case of injuries. Maybe we have something like that in Mike's loan agreement...
This is daft.
Smalling's better than all our CBs bar Maguire. Maybe Tuanzebe will end up better, so I'm all for him getting game time over him, but the rest? They should be out before him.
Smalling's better than all our CBs bar Maguire. Maybe Tuanzebe will end up better, so I'm all for him getting game time over him, but the rest? They should be out before him.
Smalling is the best defender at the club and I'm sad to see him leave but I can completely understand why Ole has done it. Much like Lukaku, Fellaini and Sanchez, he just doesn't fit the style of football that Ole wants to implement.
It might lead to more conceded goals due to defensive errors like Ayew at the weekend but the change in style is an extremely positive move and I completely support what Ole is doing.
Tuanzebe, Jones and Rojo as back up is more than enough.
I also really hope Smalling does well in Italy. I think he's well suited to Italian football. He's been a great servant to the club and deserves every success at his new club.
It might lead to more conceded goals due to defensive errors like Ayew at the weekend but the change in style is an extremely positive move and I completely support what Ole is doing.
Tuanzebe, Jones and Rojo as back up is more than enough.
I also really hope Smalling does well in Italy. I think he's well suited to Italian football. He's been a great servant to the club and deserves every success at his new club.
Not a fan of Smalling but I rate him higher than Lingard as he can outmuscle an opponent and win the ball for a change. That being said he doesn't fit Ole's football as not being a technically gifted baller.
Just get rid as many deadwood you can. Ole doesn't want to see him even on the bench, so there's not that many arguments to keep him anyway.
Just get rid as many deadwood you can. Ole doesn't want to see him even on the bench, so there's not that many arguments to keep him anyway.
Btw if he goes to Roma then hopefully he will smash it there. Judged harshly for years when he was our best CB. If he moves to Serie A, then can see him doing really well.
Also he will be one of the cleanest defenders there, going by how much Serie a defenders pull the shirts and all that.
Also he will be one of the cleanest defenders there, going by how much Serie a defenders pull the shirts and all that.
If he goes there's a good chance our defence would look like: AWB - Tuanzebe - Rojo - Young at some point in the season. Fun.
Lingard certainly is. It's not McT's strong point either.
All the best to Chris. Only right that Smaldini ends up playing in the Serie A. I would have kept him on as back up to any injuries to Maguire or Lindelof before Phil Jones but who would want to take Jones who can't keep fit or stop making mistakes in games?
I'm pretty sure Solskjaer and co. have weighed up the pros and cons on the departure of Smalling before letting him leave. Some of these posts on squad depth and it being a mistake to loan him out are laughable.
I agree, but finding another professional football club willing to allow Jones to play for them and pay him for the privilege is an impossible task. No one is that stupid.
We're stuck with Philip Jonas forever.
I hope he does well over there because compared to other players,he was a model pro.
Opinion seems to be divided on him,some say he was our best defender,others say he s crap.
Truth is somewhere in the middle I guess. Defensively he was good, very fast and excellent in air due to his height. His major drawback is getting the ball out of the defence, something which is considered almost indispensable.
Anyway Good Luck Chris..or Mike...whatever..
Opinion seems to be divided on him,some say he was our best defender,others say he s crap.
Truth is somewhere in the middle I guess. Defensively he was good, very fast and excellent in air due to his height. His major drawback is getting the ball out of the defence, something which is considered almost indispensable.
Anyway Good Luck Chris..or Mike...whatever..
Nobody is saying he hasnt. That doesnt mean he's made the right choice. Its not like he has a winning record
Its a strange move to me as he's a better defender than Lindelöf. But I guess he has the same profile as Maguire who can also play the ball. A shame for our actual defending if he leaves.
Truly feels like a transitional season, that is mostly about getting rid of a lot and not buying much replacement.
Truly feels like a transitional season, that is mostly about getting rid of a lot and not buying much replacement.
Change Darmian for Young and I'd be quite happy with that.
Not in preference to AWB - Lindelhof - Maguire - Shaw, but happy enough as a back-up back line.
Anyway....Good Luck Mike - you're probably too good to sit on the bench for another 10 months or so....
A good CB on his day, as you say, but too inconsistent at the same time. His proneness to errors makes him unreliable, similar to Jones, Rojo and Bailly in that regard.I hope he does well over there because compared to other players,he was a model pro.
Opinion seems to be divided on him,some say he was our best defender,others say he s crap.
Truth is somewhere in the middle I guess. Defensively he was good, very fast and excellent in air due to his height. His major drawback is getting the ball out of the defence, something which is considered almost indispensable.
Anyway Good Luck Chris..or Mike...whatever..
- Status