With your own logic, since the ball had already gone out of play when Schlupp shoved Antony down into the boards, it should not be tolerated and also be a red. It certainly wasn't part of open play.
So... Was it a red? (Casemiro / Hughes Royal Rumble)
- Thread starter Vidyoyo
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran hold a long overdue conversation about United's awful league form with 1 win in 7. They discuss a disappointing draw at Bournemouth, a not so disappointing draw against Liverpool and a crushing defeat at Chelsea - Is time nearly over for Erik Ten Hag?
Then in a special second half of the pod, Nik welcomes Natalie ( https://twitter.com/natalie_17) to discuss the fortunes of Manchester United Women as they booked a place in the FA Cup Final after a historic first ever win vs. Chelsea.
It 100% was part of open play. Read the rules, watch the game.
I meant just from red and yellow perspective
I suppose the silver lining is Casemiro will be super fresh when we play Barca. Could be the difference maker, especially if he has something to prove…..
Yeah no love lost between Real & Barca,both him & Rapha will be extra motivated for this
Gabby Abonglahor the dopey twat wants Casemiro arrested
Of course. TalkSport is the forum where you get to show how stupid you are.
So have Utd lodged an appeal yet? I assume there’s a deadline?
I don't think they are gonna appeal
FA will just turn it down and give him another match ban, which is the EFL final. So nope.
I think you're wrong there about him hating on United. He's just miserable overall. He hates on all the teams.
You’re 100% correct. There’s better angles to see exactly what happened. He grabs the shirt and is stopping him going after Antony.
Ego
Didn't GNev get into trouble for celebrating and winding up the Kop - maybe after O'Shea's goal?
Yes. Beautiful stuff that was.
Just show them the few seconds of Ayew with his hand on Fred's throat. They should either rescind it or extend the same punishment to him
Makes no difference to us if they punish a Palace player. Unless we're 100% certain there's been a mistake and the red card will be rescinded we shouldn't appeal
Well yes. whilst playing for United in a game against Liverpool..
Quite the difference!
He loves to strangle, he just can't help himself
Shocking stuff. Am surprised VAR didn't pick up on this and send him off.He loves to strangle, he just can't help himself
Why don't you want Casemiro to play in the cup final?!
Tweet
— Twitter API (@user) date
EtH thinks appealing is the wrong decision and we wouldn't have a chance.
Diplomatic; I think they are concerned if they appealed it the FA would increase the ban to 4 games as it was a decision given after VAR intervention.
Doesn’t mean he thinks it was the correct decision to send Cas off.
I guess we just have to go with Sabitzer and Fred VDB Leeds and Leicester and have Casemiro ready and raring to go vs Barca. May work in our favour.
VDB is out for the season.
So a blatant foul on Antony, and the off the ball action of Schlupp shoving him down the embankment, has now resulted in us missing two players through injury and suspension.
Whilst Palace suffer nothing.
Sounds about right.
Whilst Palace suffer nothing.
Sounds about right.
Yeah surprised Erik was so certain we wouldn't win appeal,especially in light of many pundits thinking it was wrong decision
Yeah I know, sorry should read ‘vs’ but my auto correct thinks it’s a comedian
I think there’s a risk to it either way.
I don’t think it would have been deemed an unreasonable appeal under the circumstances so it would not have been extended.
That said given the Wednesday game was so close if we appealed Monday it’s likely Casemiro would have then been made available pending the outcome. I doubt the FA would have got back to us quickly.
If the original decision was upheld then the three games would have started from the Sunday match and therefore still ran into the cup final.
I wonder what do the resident experts think about Ten Hag deciding not to appeal..
You’re one of the resident experts so do tell us?
Many, if not most, pundits are idiots and only say stuff to incite debate and generate clicks
Read my replies in this thread.
Do these appeals ever work? And considering the decision was based on video evidence in the first place I agree we wouldn't stand a chance.
The system protects itself but besides that - the decision was probably right.
They were posted before Ten Hag
True. My opinion hasn't changed. I still think it's a red card. The appeal wouldn't change that.
The ref should've sent of Ayew too but that has nothing to do with the appeal.
He’s saying the red card itself was not the right decision, which is why they considered appealing it. But also he knows they’d never win an appeal.
Yes it was a red. We should take the punishment and get on with it as it could be he gets an extra game and miss the final if we object. There should have been more bookings and maybe more sent off.
Popped in to give my input and you typed it out for me! Thanks
No, if you watch the conference it's clear what he was saying. It just looks ambiguous in text form.