Solskjær press conference vs West Ham (A)

Lash

Full Member
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
11,888
Location
Buckinghamshire
Supports
Millwall, Saint-Etienne
It's because after 3 years here, he hasn't said anything about what he wants beyond "making good decisions", "showing desire" and having a "winning mentality". He has to give the fans / journos more credit than that - he might feel that we're all idiots and we shouldn't have an opinion on football tactics, but I'm not sure what he'd gain by providing dismissive answers to perfectly straight forward questions.
What's the point though? press conferences have been clichés for decades and it's not a great deal of difference with any top manager. I'd worry if we knew that's all he said to the players, but I think there'd have been a revolt by now if that was the case
 

Pickle85

Full Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
6,371
Completely reasonable point to put across, I'm not sure that's the bulk of responses though. Think the majority want him to get a fecking whiteboard out and talk about phases of play. I think it doesn't highlight a valid point of over specialisation, but phrased in a bit of a harking back way. He has actively chased players that fit that mould though, we made a hell of an effort for Jude, but it didn't work out. I don't think anyone would say he is being a dinosaur trying to get someone like that into his system.
Yeah, this makes sense. Agree that he does seem to be after that sort of player too, it's just they're so rare!
 

Pickle85

Full Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
6,371
I can always understand comments from posters who just love to take things out of context.

When has the game ever been won or lost on Ole’s presser?
Not sure what you mean here. Are you saying we shouldn't discuss it because it doesn't win or lose games?
 

Real Name

Full Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2020
Messages
14,135
Location
Croatia
Never understood the obsession with what managers say in the pressers. But I guess its especially strong now Ole is under pressure and every tiny word he says is scrutinised.
 

Pickle85

Full Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
6,371
Never understood the obsession with what managers say in the pressers. But I guess its especially strong now Ole is under pressure and every tiny word he says is scrutinised.
Why bother having them then?! It's surely no great surprise that people discuss what managers say in a forum that's specifically designed to generate discussion?!
 

Dante

Average bang
Joined
Oct 22, 2010
Messages
25,280
Location
My wit's end
It's because after 3 years here, he hasn't said anything about what he wants beyond "making good decisions", "showing desire" and having a "winning mentality". He has to give the fans / journos more credit than that - he might feel that we're all idiots and we shouldn't have an opinion on football tactics, but I'm not sure what he'd gain by providing dismissive answers to perfectly straight forward questions.
It wasn't dismissive.

The question was 'How do you want that two man pivot to work?'

The answer was 'We look for midfielders who are complete. We try to develop that in our midfielders.'

It's pretty clear. Ole doesn't want specialists. He wants two all-rounders next to each other doing a bit of everything. There's no point going into specifics because a Bellingham/Camavinga double pivot (both recent targets) would have a different job against Bayern Munich rather than Norwich.

The main point is that he doesn't want Makalele style limited players. Nothing wrong with that as a philosophy.

Incidentally, it would also give us the flexibility not to need a plan B and help us avoid the downside of being predictable from week to week.
 

Inigo Montoya

Leave Wayne Rooney alone!!
Joined
Oct 1, 2008
Messages
38,543
Not sure what you mean here. Are you saying we shouldn't discuss it because it doesn't win or lose games?
I’m saying why the feck do people get so triggered by press conferences? It’s not going to impact the game
 

Coops73

Full Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2013
Messages
3,334
I knew there would be a mini meltdown over that comment about philosophy. It was obvious he didn’t want to answer the question and provide filler for Carl Anka’s latest puff piece in the Athletic. Anka is the latest journo who fancies himself as a tactical guru, it’s a trend nowadays with these pretentious journos. Every article of his is him explaining to us simple people what happens on a football pitch.
I listen to the podcasts “Talk of the devils” and “The totally football show” which he appears on quite a bit and apart from the volume levels of his voice which vary from loud to inaudible his tactical chat can be quite annoying, like he’s teaching us thick fecks how it works out there on the pitch.

It reminds me of some of the posts in hear when people start talking about trequartistas and mezzalas and how they work in a double pivot with a false 9…bunch of arse I tell ya!
 

mu4c_20le

Full Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2013
Messages
42,727
Why bother having them then?! It's surely no great surprise that people discuss what managers say in a forum that's specifically designed to generate discussion?!
What discussion? I just see the same bunch analyzing every word to reaffirm their own agenda
 

Inigo Montoya

Leave Wayne Rooney alone!!
Joined
Oct 1, 2008
Messages
38,543
It wasn't dismissive.

The question was 'How do you want that two man pivot to work?'

The answer was 'We look for midfielders who are complete. We try to develop that in our midfielders.'

It's pretty clear. Ole doesn't want specialists. He wants two all-rounders next to each other doing a bit of everything. There's no point going into specifics because a Bellingham/Camavinga double pivot (both recent targets) would have a different job against Bayern Munich rather than Norwich.

The main point is that he doesn't want Makalele style limited players. Nothing wrong with that as a philosophy.
That’s how I read the ‘ proper midfielders’ comment. Now they have to be able to fill more than one role in tandem. Not the battlers of the past. We won’t see their like again
 

LJJT

Full Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2010
Messages
1,536
Location
North West
All this philosophy talk I think is nonsense and I think ole thinks the same. He wants to win football matches and he wants to win them in a United way by playing fast attacking football if possible. We don’t always see that but he wins a lot of games. I don’t know why it has to be any deeper than that. Bielsa has a philosophy and he gets spanked by any half decent side, to me that makes him foolish rather than admirable as it’s just rinse and repeat for him
 

VP89

Pogba's biggest fan
Joined
Dec 6, 2015
Messages
31,121
All this philosophy talk I think is nonsense and I think ole thinks the same. He wants to win football matches and he wants to win them in a United way by playing fast attacking football if possible. We don’t always see that but he wins a lot of games. I don’t know why it has to be any deeper than that. Bielsa has a philosophy and he gets spanked by any half decent side, to me that makes him foolish rather than admirable as it’s just rinse and repeat for him
Tuchel, Klopp and Pep have one too.
 

Pickle85

Full Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
6,371
I’m saying why the feck do people get so triggered by press conferences? It’s not going to impact the game
Why do people post on the forum at all? It won't impact the game. The reality is that press conferences do have an impact beyond just the next game. They're the public face the club presents to the world so I'm surprised you're shocked that people discuss them.
 

Pickle85

Full Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
6,371
What discussion? I just see the same bunch analyzing every word to reaffirm their own agenda
I think you're seeing what you want to see, pal. People are discussing the presser...I've never been a vocal Ole Out guy but I didn't think he handled that well and thought it reflected badly on his tactical acumen.
 

VP89

Pogba's biggest fan
Joined
Dec 6, 2015
Messages
31,121
All managers do, what I’m saying is it’s not that big of a deal. Winning games is.
You win games when you actually have a better tactical nouse. Not just a general "show eagerness, show drive" approach. We've had a good sample period to know that doesn't cut it.
 

Pickle85

Full Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2021
Messages
6,371
They're contractually obliged to do press conferences. It's not by choice.
Well, yes. But the question was why people pick over them. My question was, why would they be a thing if people didn't? If there was no discussion allowed around them, why would they be carried out? It's sort of their point...
 

Inigo Montoya

Leave Wayne Rooney alone!!
Joined
Oct 1, 2008
Messages
38,543
Why do people post on the forum at all? It won't impact the game. The reality is that press conferences do have an impact beyond just the next game. They're the public face the club presents to the world so I'm surprised you're shocked that people discuss them.
Do they? When was the last time you posted about a result directly quoting a link to what was said in a PC?

I’m not shocked at a discussion because I simply want to know about injuries and availability. I am not shocked at the negativity at every fecking turn.
 

LJJT

Full Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2010
Messages
1,536
Location
North West
You win games when you actually have a better tactical nouse. Not just a general "show eagerness, show drive" approach. We've had a good sample period to know that doesn't cut it.
Why have we won so many games then and picked up so many points?
 

VP89

Pogba's biggest fan
Joined
Dec 6, 2015
Messages
31,121
Why have we won so many games then and picked up so many points?
Because it only works to an extent. You take Tuchel/Klopp/Conte/Pep and they will also deliver victories with trophies attached, in less time.

The proof is in the pudding thus far. He's in his 4th year, no cups. If he fails to challenge seriously now he's out and it's that simple. If he had won something in his 3 years he might have some good will which I think he would have had if there was better coaching in our approach.
 

Zaphod2319

Full Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2020
Messages
4,207
Supports
Chelsea
Because it only works to an extent. You take Tuchel/Klopp/Conte/Pep and they will also deliver victories with trophies attached, in less time.

The proof is in the pudding thus far. He's in his 4th year, no cups. If he fails to challenge seriously now he's out and it's that simple. If he had won something in his 3 years he might have some good will which I think he would have had if there was better coaching in our approach.
I don't know that the Glazers will want to pay out his contract by sacking him. As long as he makes top 4, they will be happy.
 

Real Name

Full Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2020
Messages
14,135
Location
Croatia
Why bother having them then?! It's surely no great surprise that people discuss what managers say in a forum that's specifically designed to generate discussion?!
I wonder that too. (!!)
Discusdion is normal but nitpicking of every word is not, on the contrary.
 

Teja

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2014
Messages
5,701
So what is the solution? Better press conference performances?
Hah, I dunno, ideally do your talking on the pitch but at this point after watching his side for 3 years repeatedly being good in some set of things while being consistently shit in others, I'm not convinced that he can do that.

It'll be nice to see him set the right expectations with the fans about what he wants to see in some capacity (whether it's pre / post match interviews, or something he does on MUTV or whatever). So far it's just win, win, win, passion, passion, passion and obviously we won't win everything, so it's just setup for failure. Passion is a flimsy thing, the players worked their socks off against YB but you don't really see anyone talking about hard work or passion here after the defeat.

What's the point though? press conferences have been clichés for decades and it's not a great deal of difference with any top manager. I'd worry if we knew that's all he said to the players, but I think there'd have been a revolt by now if that was the case
He obviously doesn't say that to the players otherwise he'd have been out of a job in about 2 months, so I give him more credit than that :lol:

It's true that press conferences are cliche mostly but I also feel like other managers talk about what they want a lot more. It's little things here and there about what went well / wrong during a pre-match / post-match interview or maybe something during a 1:1 interview. I posted a bunch of Klopp comments talking about his philosophy earlier on in the thread. Others have posted things about Tuchel and Pep. I don't think anyone can really describe what Ole's philosophy is.
 

mu4c_20le

Full Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2013
Messages
42,727
I don't know that the Glazers will want to pay out his contract by sacking him. As long as he makes top 4, they will be happy.
That was before Ronaldo. I'm sure things changed now. I don't care what he says, we are in a title race this season, and if we go on a string of bad results he'll be fecked.
 

Inigo Montoya

Leave Wayne Rooney alone!!
Joined
Oct 1, 2008
Messages
38,543
I don't know that the Glazers will want to pay out his contract by sacking him. As long as he makes top 4, they will be happy.
How do you know that?
They signed Brady to win the Super Bowl. Surely Utd winning a trophy only increases revenue
 

sugar_kane

Full Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2013
Messages
3,424

Here's a clipped version of Ole's midfield comments. It's really not as bad as some of drama queens in here are making out.

Judge from the original source, not the chinese whispers.
Yeah that’s fine, I like that he takes issue with the philosophy nonsense that is so prevalent these days.

Slightly cringing at his talk of passion, namechecking the usual United legends etc but I agree with his broader point.

To be fair - keeping it simple and letting players express themselves is a philosophy in itself. It doesn’t mean he goes into games without a plan or tactical instructions, but he doesn’t have a rigid style he wants us to constantly stick to every game.

Also, “we want midfielders who can play” is somewhat of a misquote, he interrupts the sentence partway and never finishes it. I did not pick up that at all when reading the presser quotes.
 

Abhinav

Full Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2017
Messages
843
There a lot of things to criticise Ole for but this dissection of his every word is a little overboard. A lot of it is to do with our underwhelming performance in the midweek than what he has actually said. Needs to deliver a comfortable win on Sunday.
 

sullydnl

Ross Kemp's caf ID
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
34,063
The next sentence, he elaborates what he means. He goes on to talk about "midfielders who are complete". In other words, total footballers rather than specialists.

Nothing wrong with that.

What this basically means is that he doesn't believe in the likes of Makalele having one specific job in a 3, or Lampard having one specific job in a 3. Instead, he wants all-rounders. Hence the pursuits of Bellingham last season and Camavinga this season. Those two are the future of football. Anything but throwbacks.

Solskjaer's philosophy is spot on, imo. The more limited the individuals are, the more exploitable their weaknesses become. The ideal midfield is one where everybody can do a bit of everything and is a constant threat to the opposition.
That's absolutely fine as an idealised belief to aspire towards.

But in real terms a lot of the players he is dealing with and will deal with in the future have specific strengths and weaknesses that have to be accounted for tactically.

He can't on the one hand say he doesn't believe in specialised roles in midfield and then on the other hand start Nemanja Matic against Southampton, who can only function in a specialised role. Because whatever Solskjaer's philosophy is, it has to be able to accommodate the players who are actually at his disposal, which will often involve some specialisation and quite a lot of the "intricacies" he seems to disregard elsewhere in his comments.

To use a slightly different example, take AWB. Even imagining he's the best version of himself he can be, his particular skillset means he will be a constant target for opposition press and someone they're happy to give space to in attack. In other words he is in his own way a specialist player. If we're going to play him then this means the team has to adjust tactically to try and exploit his strengths and minimize his weaknesses, which involves exactly the sort of on-paper "intricacies" Solskjaer referenced.

Ditto players like Pogba, Bruno and Ronaldo. All have strengths/weakness that require specific tactical adjustments when they play in different positions. As such it would be nice to see the manager present himself as someone who is comfortable with the intricacies of football his team depends on rather than giving the appearance of being dismissive of them. Particularly when that appearance feeds into the pre-existing perception that he is lightweight when it comes to preparing the team tactically.
 

Zaphod2319

Full Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2020
Messages
4,207
Supports
Chelsea
How do you know that?
They signed Brady to win the Super Bowl. Surely Utd winning a trophy only increases revenue
They got Tom Brady to sell more Tampa swag. Winning the Superbowl was a bonus. If they never won a Superbowl with Tom Brady he would have been welcome there as he sells tickets, shirts, and gets them on National TV. The Glazers are about the bottom line and profits going in their pocket, with both the Bucs and United.
 

Big Andy

Bloke
Joined
Oct 23, 2003
Messages
34,582
Because it only works to an extent. You take Tuchel/Klopp/Conte/Pep and they will also deliver victories with trophies attached, in less time.

The proof is in the pudding thus far. He's in his 4th year, no cups. If he fails to challenge seriously now he's out and it's that simple. If he had won something in his 3 years he might have some good will which I think he would have had if there was better coaching in our approach.
Tuchel - Chelsea (bankrolled by a billionaire)
Conte - Chelsea (bankrolled by a billionaire)
Pep - City (bankrolled by a billionaire)
Klopp - Liverpool (shit American owners, took ages to win anything and finish top 4)
 

Lash

Full Member
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
11,888
Location
Buckinghamshire
Supports
Millwall, Saint-Etienne
Yeah, this makes sense. Agree that he does seem to be after that sort of player too, it's just they're so rare!
Yeah, it fecking sucks that they are. Similar to no 9s, but no doubt we'll have a good batch of them when Haaland inspires a generation.
 

Tom Van Persie

No relation
Joined
Dec 12, 2012
Messages
24,321
You win games when you actually have a better tactical nouse. Not just a general "show eagerness, show drive" approach. We've had a good sample period to know that doesn't cut it.
You need both. What good are tactics when players aren't putting 100% in or the manager isn't getting the message across properly. There's a reason why Klopp acts like a complete maniac on the sidelines at times. It's to drive his players on. His whole philosophy is based around playing with passion. If his team are flat then his pressing game isn't as effective. Same can be said about every team tbh. You can be the greatest tactician but if you have a team that doesn't respond then it's useless.
 

RedDevil@84

Full Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2014
Messages
21,547
Location
USA
And Ole's right.

He could come up with the perfect game plan, and the perfect set of tactics. But if all the players go onto the pitch with Martial's mentality they could easily lose. Whereas if they go onto the pitch with Ronaldo's passion to win, they'd likely be victorious.

In other words, it's fine margins. There are some things the manager can never account for. If that wasn't the case, home teams wouldn't have better records than away teams. 'Desire' makes a bigger difference than you think.
I am not discounting desire to win.
And it is true that the best laid plans can go completely south due to hundreds of reasons, but yet we plan. We don't stop having strategies because they may fail nevertheless.

It is true that passion is needed to win games, but without proper trained tactics, seems pointless to have lots of passhuunnn.