Striker Poll - Who should we buy ?

Which striker should United sign this summer ? | Poll Reset

  • Viktor Gyökeres

  • Hugo Ekitike

  • Jean-Philippe Mateta

  • Benjamin Šeško

  • Jonathan David

  • Patrik Schick

  • Samu Aghehowa

  • Ollie Watkins

  • Yoane Wissa

  • Krzysztof Piątek

  • Serhou Guirassy

  • Kolo Muani

  • Alexander Sørloth

  • Gonçalo Ramos


Results are only viewable after voting.
What do you guys think will happen to the strikers we’ve linked with so far. Personally:

Ekitike - Stays at Frankfurt
Gyokeres - Liverpool
Sesko - Arsenal
Mateta - Stays at Palace
Osimhen - Juventus
 
What do you guys think will happen to the strikers we’ve linked with so far. Personally:

Ekitike - Stays at Frankfurt
Gyokeres - Liverpool
Sesko - Arsenal
Mateta - Stays at Palace
Osimhen - Juventus

Agree on Mateta. The rest are likely moving before the summer is over.
 
If we get down our list as far as Mateta then it really is a barren market.

If it comes to that then rather than scraping the barrel we ought to look to see if we can bring in someone on loan.

It would be madness to make Mateta an important player for us for the next 5 years.
I don't think Mateta is nearly as bad as you make out but rather than paying astronomical amounts on Gyok, Ekitike, Sesko, neither of whom are even dead certs for 10 goals in the league for Utd, I think it would make more sense this summer to target an A-rated midfielder while there is some (like Baleba/Wharton) still playing at mid-table clubs and then seek an affordable/free striker option until a real superstar comes on the market/ or some of the stars of tomorrow age into suitability.
 
It'll be funny if Arsenal snub Arsenal loving Gyokeres & he ends staying at Sporting & next season he has a crap season & next summer fast approaching 30yo his market value plummets.
 
It'll be funny if Arsenal snub Arsenal loving Gyokeres & he ends staying at Sporting & next season he has a crap season & next summer fast approaching 30yo his market value plummets.

'Fast approaching 30'

Literally turned 27 less than a fortnight ago.
 
Just the thought of not even getting a striker and being stuck with Hojlund and Zirkzee again is the stuff of nightmares.

At this rate i would take another stop gap just so i dont have to witness the ball bounce off Hojlund every game.
 
At this point I honestly don't know, and given the lack of reliable links to a striker I guess I'll find out if it happens.
 
Stories coming out of Italy that Wilcox has spoken with Juve about Vlahovic. Just keeping tabs it seems but the asking price might be as low as €30M although the salary would be prohibitive. Not good sources but it seems like something that could gain steam late in the window if our preferred options don’t materialize.
 
Stories coming out of Italy that Wilcox has spoken with Juve about Vlahovic. Just keeping tabs it seems but the asking price might be as low as €30M although the salary would be prohibitive. Not good sources but it seems like something that could gain steam late in the window if our preferred options don’t materialize.
He's the highest paid player in Italy with 1 year left on his contract and he has been a disappointment, €30M seems overpriced. I'm sure Juve would be very happy to get rid of his salary that breaks their wage structure. Milan has also been in rumours but I doubt they can afford to pay him, even if he accepts a 50% cut.
 
Stories coming out of Italy that Wilcox has spoken with Juve about Vlahovic. Just keeping tabs it seems but the asking price might be as low as €30M although the salary would be prohibitive. Not good sources but it seems like something that could gain steam late in the window if our preferred options don’t materialize.
Always left feeling underwhelmed by him
 
Thierno Barry would be a good option. Everton are already negotiating for him, so stepping in a few sweeteners to both club and player should be a far simpler deal than Ekitike, Osimhen, JP Mateta or the like.
 
Stories coming out of Italy that Wilcox has spoken with Juve about Vlahovic. Just keeping tabs it seems but the asking price might be as low as €30M although the salary would be prohibitive. Not good sources but it seems like something that could gain steam late in the window if our preferred options don’t materialize.
He's very poor. I'd rather have Højlund than him.
 
Provided that he actually is available and attainable, my top pick would absolutely be Goncalo Ramos. On relatively modest wages and seemingly available for around 45m he's not only a "budget-friendly" option, but also the one that IMO offers most both in terms of attacking output as well as defensive contribution. Over the last 3 seasons, per/90, he has scored 0.66 non-penaly goals + and provided 0.12 assists. He also does the "dirty work" in terms of contributing defensively and has 1.25 tackles+interception per/90, and is also solid aerially with a 48%-win rate that would also benefit us defensively on set pieces. He also looses posession much less than any of the comparisons I've looked at.

Comparing Ramos with Ekitike, Sesko, David, Kolo Muani and Mateta, on metrics (all per/90) such as G-PK, Ast, npxG+xAG, npxG, xAG, np:G-xG, aerial won%, tkl+inter, pass compl% and possession lost, it's pretty clear that Ramos is the overall most complete striker out of them.

Assuming that our transfer budget is the reported 100m ish (Cunha deal + Mbuemo bid) + sales, I'd say that we would be mad to splash around 75m on any striker, and even that a player like Jonathan David on a "free" should be prioritized over Ekitike/Sesko if that enables us to strengthen further in the squad.
 
Do not see the point in buying a striker at all cost. Important to avoid panic buys. With the way we play and the need we have Osimhen fits the bill very well. He might be expensive but is a proven and experienced striker that will strengthen all teams he'll join.

I would even say that if we cannot get Osimhen (now that Gyokeres is likely goin to Arsenal), we should find another way of increasing the gaol tally without spending any big money on other strikers and hope they'll workout.
 
He's the highest paid player in Italy with 1 year left on his contract and he has been a disappointment, €30M seems overpriced. I'm sure Juve would be very happy to get rid of his salary that breaks their wage structure. Milan has also been in rumours but I doubt they can afford to pay him, even if he accepts a 50% cut.
Yeah he's never fulfilled his promise. Which is a shame as he seemed like such an exciting prospect at Fiorentina, a real classic striker.

That said, Juve have been a incredibly dour team for years. They haven't managed 60 goals in a season since Ronaldo left, and that's not just down to Vlahovic. I dont fancy him at United, but still, he might show his quality in a more attacking team.
 
Yeah he's never fulfilled his promise. Which is a shame as he seemed like such an exciting prospect at Fiorentina, a real classic striker.

That said, Juve have been a incredibly dour team for years. They haven't managed 60 goals in a season since Ronaldo left, and that's not just down to Vlahovic. I dont fancy him at United, but still, he might show his quality in a more attacking team.
I don't think it's a good idea to buy Juve bench warmers as our main striker. He was good at Fiorentina a couple of years ago and that's a key word. Not only is he struggling in Juve, but he's also getting outscored by fat and out of shape Mitrovic (currently playing in Saudi Arabia) in Serbian national team.

No one also rates him that much in Serbia. I am Serbian and we are frustrated with his performances in our national team.
 
I don't think it's a good idea to buy Juve bench warmers as our main striker. He was good at Fiorentina a couple of years ago and that's a key word. Not only is he struggling in Juve, but he's also getting outscored by fat and out of shape Mitrovic (currently playing in Saudi Arabia) in Serbian national team.

No one also rates him that much in Serbia. I am Serbian and we are frustrated with his performances in our national team.
Agreed, I said in my post that I don't fancy him at United.

Its more just a feeling that he might still come out of his career lull at somewhere other than Juve. I think he could thrive at one of the more upwardly mobile Premier League teams like Fulham.
 
Agreed, I said in my post that I don't fancy him at United.

Its more just a feeling that he might still come out of his career lull at somewhere other than Juve. I think he could thrive at one of the more upwardly mobile Premier League teams like Fulham.
He's still young and has plenty of time to turn it around, it's up to him and his willingness to forego a large part of his wages to get playing time at a club that suits him best. But he is also probably aware that he'll never get another contract like this again and might want to cash in on his last year no matter what.
 
If we activated the 60mil release clause and got 4 good years out of Guirassy would anyone complain ? A Striker who doesn't rely on pace, just intelligent box work for the most part.
 
If we activated the 60mil release clause and got 4 good years out of Guirassy would anyone complain ? A Striker who doesn't rely on pace, just intelligent box work for the most part.
Could have gotten him for 15m but signed Zirkzee instead. Sigh
 
If Mateta is willing to come it would be a no brainer, gives us more freedom with our finances, and doesn't tie us to a massive name, we are in a building phase IMO signing a big name now could back fire, Mateta is safe, will he set the world on fire? probably not but will give us 1-2 seasons whilst we look for somebody who really fits and is willing to come here
 
Don’t really understand the Zirkzee hate. He has the potential to be a top player, his close control and dribbling is a rare trait

The fact (and correct me if I am wrong) he managed to score in just 2 EPL games is awful with a capital A.
 
The fact (and correct me if I am wrong) he managed to score in just 2 EPL games is awful with a capital A.
You’re right but he started off atrociously, then hit a bit of form and got injured. Hojlund was favoured over him all season for whatever reason.

I wouldn’t want him as our main man, but we can certainly get a lot more from him, and he brings a hell of a lot more than just goals.

For me, it’s big shiny ready made striker, or spend on goalscoring wide player (Mbeumo) and great centre mid.

To confirm, would love us to buy this lad, but we’re not flush and should have prirorities
 
You’re right but he started off atrociously, then hit a bit of form and got injured. Hojlund was favoured over him all season for whatever reason.

I wouldn’t want him as our main man, but we can certainly get a lot more from him, and he brings a hell of a lot more than just goals.

For me, it’s big shiny ready made striker, or spend on goalscoring wide player (Mbeumo) and great centre mid.

To confirm, would love us to buy this lad, but we’re not flush and should have prirorities
The bolded is actually a myth, at the point that he hurt his hamstring both had played almost an identical number of minutes, roughly 2100 each, and had almost identical stats. Ruben quite notably alternated them in the starting role almost every game during his first few months, so much so that it was a big part of the discussion that whoever started always looked terrible and whoever came on as a sub looked good. Hojlund ended up with more playing time mostly as a function of being the only fit striker for the last couple of months of the season when we were playing two games a week.
 
Poll need to be reset. Osimhen to be added, he is as likely as all options on the list. Piatek needs to be removed as he has already signed with another club.
 
Zirkzee is going to leave United and end up dominating like Mctominay because someone with basic football IQ decides to just play him in his position.
 
I don't think it's a good idea to buy Juve bench warmers as our main striker. He was good at Fiorentina a couple of years ago and that's a key word. Not only is he struggling in Juve, but he's also getting outscored by fat and out of shape Mitrovic (currently playing in Saudi Arabia) in Serbian national team.

No one also rates him that much in Serbia. I am Serbian and we are frustrated with his performances in our national team.
Yeah please keep him off the list completely
 
I would take Vlahovic at 30 million. Going into next season with no striker changes is not an option.