arnie_ni
Full Member
- Joined
- Apr 27, 2014
- Messages
- 15,200
Well maybe not, i didnt win 6 titles ha.Yeah, yours is surely the better approach.
Id wager he did give plenty of arms around the shoulder, it just doesnt make good tv.
Well maybe not, i didnt win 6 titles ha.Yeah, yours is surely the better approach.
I used to be captain of my school and local Gaelic teams, was a real hot head used to shout and swear all the time. Surprised no one told me to feck off but I suppose when you’re in the heat of battle you don’t really care you just want to win and everyone got on with it. I think a team needs someone like that because there’s so many personalities that no really speaks up or they leave it to one of the best players to speak up and say nothing themselves. Been in that situation too playing in better teams as I got older and got shouted at my first reaction was I’m going to show you so I guess it might work.It could work on one guy and not another.
I dont think take it well tbh, itd get my back up and id just go right back at him.
Tell me what im doing wrong and I'll fix it, calling me shit, will get nothing from me.
Ive been a captain in footy and rugby albeit at a low level, and I can adapt to the person.
Some guys need a kick up the arse, others need an arm around the shoulder
Same. Started watching classics on skyI was so sad to finish it. I'm desperately craving for more it's the best documentary series I've ever seen. Way above anything else I've ever seen.
Did Keane ever tell the team not to pass it to a certain teammate, or tell someone before a penalty kick that if they miss they’re not taking another one?Exactly. You can't adore SAF / Roy Keane's leadership and knock MJ for the same.
Well, you have those leadership courses in menagers schools/programs (some good, some pretty wasteful).Has there ever been a scientific study examining whether sledging, and the MJ kind of 'encouraging', actually works? Or is this all too subjective to be studied?
Morality really isn’t the way to go on this one, both Keane & SAF had their less favourable moments over the courses of their career.Did Keane ever tell the team not to pass it to a certain teammate, or tell someone before a penalty kick that if they miss they’re not taking another one?
I’m not.You also shouldn’t equate a penalty to a free throw.
No, but Michael never had management dispose of team mates like they were worth nothing, nor went against Phil in front of the rest of the team. One thing that is obvious from the documentary is that irrespective of who Michael played with, there was an inherent element of respect and for my recollection, he never once said that a certain player shouldn't be on his team or wasn't good enough. It seemed like he just played with the hand he was dealt. In any event, he pretty much just lead by example and put it on his team mates to either step up, or feck off. No different to Sir Alex at United time and time again.Did Keane ever tell the team not to pass it to a certain teammate, or tell someone before a penalty kick that if they miss they’re not taking another one?
Bringing Keane into this debate is ridiculous regardless. He has neither the stature nor the ability as a professional that the other two did. He was a great team player and a strong captain, but he was very easily replaced as a player. If you want to mention any player from United than it is Cantona, but he fails on the longevity front.
There's an argument keane is the best midfielder in pl history. Many would say he's better than Scholes Gerrard lampard viera erc.No, but Michael never had management dispose of team mates like they were worth nothing, nor went against Phil in front of the rest of the team. One thing that is obvious from the documentary is that irrespective of who Michael played with, there was an inherent element of respect and for my recollection, he never once said that a certain player shouldn't be on his team or wasn't good enough. It seemed like he just played with the hand he was dealt. In any event, he pretty much just lead by example and put it on his team mates to either step up, or feck off. No different to Sir Alex at United time and time again.
Bringing Keane into this debate is ridiculous regardless. He has neither the stature nor the ability as a professional that the other two did. He was a great team player and a strong captain, but he was very easily replaced as a player. If you want to mention any player from United than it is Cantona, but he fails on the longevity front.
That Keane isn't anywhere near Jordan. Which is true outside of the fact they were the key on field/court leadership in a 90's dominating team with similarly aggressive styles.There's an argument keane is the best midfielder in pl history. Many would say he's better than Scholes Gerrard lampard viera erc.
Not sure what your talking about tbh
Thats not what he said.That Keane isn't anywhere near Jordan. Which is true outside of the fact they were the key on field/court leadership in a 90's dominating team with similarly aggressive styles.
It is utter nonsense.Thats not what he said.
He word for word said Keane is "very easily replaced as a player."
Its complete bull tbh
What he said or what im saying?It is utter nonsense.
What they sayin'What he said or what im saying?
He Arnie, he.What he said or what im saying?
Some quality no-look passing! Amazing some of the invention in his play.He might be greatest (and I pushed that narrative), but my oh my...
Thought this quote from Magic last week maybe summed it up pretty nicely.He might be greatest (and I pushed that narrative), but my oh my...
Can't say I disagree with that. James' chapter in the NBA isn't finished though."First of all, let's not take anything away from LeBron James," Johnson said. "Because LeBron James is a great basketball player, one of the all-time greatest that's ever played the game. LeBron James to me, when you think about all-around basketball players, he's probably the best of all time. An all-around basketball player. But when you want to say 'who's the greatest ever' it's still Michael Jordan."
I mean all the GOAT talking is absolutely childish. Lebron is still active and absolutely great... even if he doesn't win anything there is a case to be made that he is the most complete player ever.Thought this quote from Magic last week maybe summed it up pretty nicely.
Can't say I disagree with that. James' chapter in the NBA isn't finished though.
Probably yes.Did Keane ever tell the team not to pass it to a certain teammate, or tell someone before a penalty kick that if they miss they’re not taking another one?
Episode VIII, for me. It set up the final two installments perfectly. The 1995 play-offs loss leading Jordan to beast it in the off-season and start the 1996 campaign in God-mode, along with his teammates. Great episode.What did people think the best episode was?
Five for me
Compare how riveting The Last Dance is compared to the bland drivel of that Man City documentary.I was so sad to finish it. I'm desperately craving for more it's the best documentary series I've ever seen. Way above anything else I've ever seen.
But on his podcast, The Dream Team Tapes, writer Jack McCallum played an interview from 2011 which contradicted Jordan’s claim.
“[Selection committee member] Rod Thorn called me. I said, ‘Rod, I won’t play if Isiah Thomas is on the team,’” says in the 2011 interview. “He assured me. He said, ‘You know what? [USA coach] Chuck Daly doesn’t want Isiah. So, Isiah is not going to be part of the team.’”
Jordan and Thomas shared an intense rivalry during their careers. In The Last Dance Jordan admitted he still had “hate” for Thomas, stemming from an incident when the Detroit Pistons refused to shake hands with the Bulls after Chicago’s victory in the 1991 Eastern Conference finals.
However, in The Last Dance, Jordan denied he had asked Thomas to be left off the team.
“I respect Isiah Thomas’ talent. To me, the best point guard of all time is Magic Johnson and right behind him is Isiah Thomas,” said Jordan in The Last Dance. “No matter how much I hate him, I respect his game. Now, it was insinuated that I was asking [for Thomas to be left off the team] but I never threw his name in there.
Huh? LeBron has 3 titles, 3 MVP awards.I mean all the GOAT talking is absolutely childish. Lebron is still active and absolutely great... even if he doesn't win anything there is a case to be made that he is the most complete player ever.
In short, enjoy the greatness no matter on which side of you.
I might remember this wrong but I remember Jordan saying that it wasn't solely down to him that Thomas didn't play. It was because none of the team wanted him in. I don't think he denied not wanting him.
FourHuh? LeBron has 3 titles, 3 MVP awards.
I didn’t get the ‘even if he doesn’t win anything’ like. I probably read it wrong.Four
And I think he meant complete as an all-round basketball player, not in terms of individual or team accolades. He's certainly a better passer and rebounder than Jordan, I don't know how their H2H steals/blocks compare but they're not really the same kind of player anyway.