Current drama (AEW diversity/ Big Swole) is a tough one for me to call out what should have been done better in terms of people being pushed.
Also I never rated Swole so when I first read her comments it was through that lens. She's just the messenger though and not the message. So I thought more on it
I already felt that Scorpio Sky should have had more after his tag run. I think he's good. But in terms of a singles championship... I think it could have been done with the TBS title instead of Miro, but people were complaining about Miro's booking before then... And I think Miro deserved his run due to the hard work he's done on his body and look and AEW not having many big physical threats like him with the exposure/star power he has. So then its like... Should that be ignored and you go with Scorpio because he could be in that mix and he's black, so even if you decide he doesnt deserve it as much, the being black part is more important so you make him champ? Maybe. I dont know the answer. And ill talk about the tag champs later but Scorpio was part of the tag team that won the first tag titles, although it was a 3 man team. Back to the singles titles for now though
What I can say is I dont think Cody needed to win the title right now. So maybe it should have been Sammy and Scorpio now with Scorpio eventually winning the title.
Other than that, I didnt rate Swole but she was getting pushed way back when before she took a break in terms of being on tv. I felt at the time she was being pushed because she was black. Whereas with Red Velvet and Jade I think if you took skin colour out of it the merits of what they are/were doing and have to offer have made sense for their pushes. Jade stands out no matter what and Red Velvet shows loads of heart, is athletic and flies around the ring. I just dont get anything out of Swole
Private Party... Could they have been champs? I wouldnt have done it but I suppose with the right story. Young Bucks and Lucha Brothers are better obviously and most people would choose them. But for the sake of pushing black champions, yeah I guess it could have been a thing.
And then obviously the new guys come in and what do you do, not feature Bryan Danielson, Punk and Malakai Black? Of course they're going to be featured and of course theres a limited amount of time on Dynamite. Why werent there big name Black wrestlers to sign also? Thats the question.
As soon as his ROH contract was up they signed Jay Lethal, they had already signed Lio Rush but he quit/retired after the birth of his child and had to keep at him to get him to come back. Lethal has only just signed, Rush has been there a few months since returning. I dont think its reasonable to think either of them could have been a singles champion in their short time in the promotion or that they were featured as regularly as Punk and Bryan Danielson.
We can absolutely say that WWE has been pushing black champs a lot in recent years. But those guys are under contract. So AEW would need to make their own black stars, and there are some black wrestlers on the way up like Powerhouse Hobbs who had a match with Punk and maybe you could do even more with him but where does merit come into it?
So again for me its a tough one and obviously I have no idea whats going on behind the scenes. I think AEW could have had a black TNT champ and/or a black tag team champs, with Kong having to give it up when her body wasnt feeling good (and Brandi Rhodes coming in to do her matches filling in for her with that whole Nightmare thing) I dont see what they could have done for the womens championship.
And then theres the fact that other diverse groups were represented and if there was a push for black champions then maybe its at the expense of mexican tag team champs, or asian female champs. So is that good?
I feel like AEW has mostly been merit based when it comes to who it features and who have been the champions. In hindsight I would probably have had Scorpio Sky be one of the people who had the TNT title, or have it now and thats about the only correction I would make.
There are a few other things I would change in AEW.
Like I would personally like to see what I would call "stronger lineups" on Rampage and sometimes even on Dynamite. Of course thats subjective and what I'm saying is I'd like more of the people I care about having matches with each other. And someone else might be getting exactly that from it because they're into people I'm not. So thats a more personal thing.
I would go a bit different with Cody. I liked Black and Andrade together for those few weeks, I would have stuck with that and added some members to make it a faction. Thats about it for now
Edit - Theres also other things, like AEW having a trans womens champion and openly gay wrestlers on the roster. I may be forgetting something but do WWE have any gay males on the roster? I know they had bi and gay females, although Sonya doesnt wrestle anymore and Tegan Nox was let go. And WWE had Daren Young, again let go. New Japan doesnt have any diversity so its hard to even make comparisons with them and then you're left with much smaller promotions so thats why its a comparison with WWE.