Gaming The SM RedCafe League

BenitoSTARR said:
Yeah you’ve been surprisingly hit with Alaba too. So LB is another issue.

Also some more bad news Damien…


He’ll be stuck on 92 now.
Click to expand...

Yeah the double whammy of Hakimi +2 Alaba -2 hurts a lot. Kinda suspected that'd happen with Nico. Got a bit of bad luck of players staying and not moving (see Mbappe) though in this case I feel it is permanent.
 
@BenitoSTARR

Excellent write up, mate. Agree with all of it. The issues are exactly what you said but it's a tough one to solve for given there are only so many top CBs and CMs at the right age. Trying a few things in the transfer market, let's see.
 
Mixed reaction to ST’s appointment

It’s been 2 days since ST was unveiled as the new Hereford FC manager, but the debate about his hiring still rages on. ST had asked fans to be patient and supportive as he outlined his plans for the new season in his press conference. He said “Everyone at Hereford is confident heading into the season. We have an excellent group of players and staff who will give their 100% to this club’s success. But we should expect some growing pains, and it’s important to remain positive”.

However, the reaction online and on social media has been mixed. Caf News has compiled some tweets and memes that have been circulating online since ST’s appointment.

"He’s worked in the same division for years and knows what it takes to build consistency. Maybe that’s what we need now,” tweeted @BullsTillIDie.

“I liked his comments about honouring Phil’s legacy. Shows he understands what this club means,” said Emma T, a season-ticket holder.

"I now know how Man Utd fans felt when they replaced SAF with Moyes", tweeted @Here4d4lyf

"We have an excellent group of players who are waiting to take the next step. So, naturally we go with the manager who failed to do that at his last club", commented @PhilKistheGOAT


We also share 7 of the best memes. Please swipe right to see all the images.




Caf News will stay on top of this story and continue to update our viewers with more reactions.

The season previews have started. Find out what our experts are predicting for next season here: https://www.redcafe.net/threads/the-sm-redcafe-league.349538/page-1362
 
Sandyman said:
Mixed reaction to ST’s appointment

It’s been 2 days since ST was unveiled as the new Hereford FC manager, but the debate about his hiring still rages on. ST had asked fans to be patient and supportive as he outlined his plans for the new season in his press conference. He said “Everyone at Hereford is confident heading into the season. We have an excellent group of players and staff who will give their 100% to this club’s success. But we should expect some growing pains, and it’s important to remain positive”.

However, the reaction online and on social media has been mixed. Caf News has compiled some tweets and memes that have been circulating online since ST’s appointment.

"He’s worked in the same division for years and knows what it takes to build consistency. Maybe that’s what we need now,” tweeted @BullsTillIDie.

“I liked his comments about honouring Phil’s legacy. Shows he understands what this club means,” said Emma T, a season-ticket holder.

"I now know how Man Utd fans felt when they replaced SAF with Moyes", tweeted @Here4d4lyf

"We have an excellent group of players who are waiting to take the next step. So, naturally we go with the manager who failed to do that at his last club", commented @PhilKistheGOAT


We also share 7 of the best memes. Please swipe right to see all the images.




Caf News will stay on top of this story and continue to update our viewers with more reactions.

The season previews have started. Find out what our experts are predicting for next season here: https://www.redcafe.net/threads/the-sm-redcafe-league.349538/page-1362
Click to expand...

To say that I’m loving this would be an understatement the memes :lol: :lol: :lol: The tweets :lol::lol::lol:
 
Sandyman said:
Mixed reaction to ST’s appointment

It’s been 2 days since ST was unveiled as the new Hereford FC manager, but the debate about his hiring still rages on. ST had asked fans to be patient and supportive as he outlined his plans for the new season in his press conference. He said “Everyone at Hereford is confident heading into the season. We have an excellent group of players and staff who will give their 100% to this club’s success. But we should expect some growing pains, and it’s important to remain positive”.

However, the reaction online and on social media has been mixed. Caf News has compiled some tweets and memes that have been circulating online since ST’s appointment.

"He’s worked in the same division for years and knows what it takes to build consistency. Maybe that’s what we need now,” tweeted @BullsTillIDie.

“I liked his comments about honouring Phil’s legacy. Shows he understands what this club means,” said Emma T, a season-ticket holder.

"I now know how Man Utd fans felt when they replaced SAF with Moyes", tweeted @Here4d4lyf

"We have an excellent group of players who are waiting to take the next step. So, naturally we go with the manager who failed to do that at his last club", commented @PhilKistheGOAT


We also share 7 of the best memes. Please swipe right to see all the images.




Caf News will stay on top of this story and continue to update our viewers with more reactions.

The season previews have started. Find out what our experts are predicting for next season here: https://www.redcafe.net/threads/the-sm-redcafe-league.349538/page-1362
Click to expand...

Love it
 
Barnsley players FULL RATING REVIEW

Updated 05/07/25

Name - Club - (age/rating prior to review) rating change prediction = actual change after review

+ Positive change
- Negative change
NO CHANGE

:+1: = correct prediction
:nono: = incorrect prediction
:nervous: = wtf (prediction way off or rating is crazy)
:mad: = annoyed I think it should be higher
~ = no prediction due to review complete prior to this post
tbc = player not reviewed yet / waiting for league review to start

Bundesliga
Noah Atubolu - Frieburg - (23/86) ~ = +2 to 88
Manuel Neuer - Bayern - (39/93) ~ = NO CHANGE
Waldemar Anton - Dortmund - (28/90) ~ = NO CHANGE
Leon Goretzka - Bayern - (30/91) ~ = NO CHANGE
Xavi Simons - Leipzig - (22/91) ~ = NO CHANGE
Thomas Müller - Bayern - (35/91) ~ = NO CHANGE
Matteo Pérez Vinlof - Bayern - (19/78) ~ = +2 to 80
Oscar Højlund - Eintracht - (20/76) ~ = +4 to 80
Hugo Larsson - Eintracht - (20/87) ~ = +1 to 88 :mad:
Jamie Leweling - Stuttgart - (24/88) ~ = NO CHANGE
Nick Woltemade - Stuttgart - (23/83) ~ = +4 to 87 :mad:

Ligue 1
Marco Asensio - Paris Saint-Germain - (29/90) +1 to 91 = tbc
Saïmon Bouabré - Monaco - (19/73) +3 to 76 = tbc :nono: :mad:
Mohamed-Ali Cho - Nice - (21/86) +1 to 87 = NO CHANGE

La Liga
Antoine Griezmamn - Atlético Madrid - (34/94) NO CHANGE = NO CHANGE :+1:
Alex Valle - Como - (21/82) +2 to 84 = +2 to 84 :+1:
Sergi Domínguez - Barcelona - (20/78) +2 to 80 = NO CHANGE :nono:
Gerard Martin - Barcelona - (23/80) +7 to 87 = +5 to 85 :nono:
Juanlu Sánchez - Sevilla - (21/85) +1 to 86 = tbc

Serie A
Carlos Augusto - Inter - (26/89) +1 to 90 = NO CHANGE :nono::mad:
Cesare Casadei - Torino - (22/82) +3 to 85 = +3 to 85 :+1:
Valentín Carboni - Inter - (20/83) NO CHANGE = NO CHANGE :+1:

Premier League
Taylor Harwood-Bellis - Southampton - (23/85) NO CHANGE = tbc
Marc Guehi - Crystal Palace - (24/90) +1 to 91 = tbc
Lisandro Martínez - Manchester United - (27/91) -1 to 90 = tbc
Dan Burn - Newcastle - (33/89) +1 to 90 = tbc
Luke Shaw - Manchester United - (29/92) -3 to 89 = tbc
Dominik Szoboszlai - Liverpool - (24/91) +1 to 92 = tbc
Jack Grealish - Manchester City - (29/92) -2 to 90 = tbc
Mason Mount - Manchester United - (26/90) -1 to 89 = tbc
Gabriel Martinelli - Arsenal - (23/91) NO CHANGE = tbc
Barbosa Evanilson - Bournemouth - (25/89) +1 to 90 = tbc
Josh Acheampong - Chelsea - (19/73) +7 to 80 = tbc
Jack Fletcher - Manchester United - (18/65) +8 to 73 = tbc
Trey Nyoni - Liverpool - (17/73) +2 to 75 = tbc
Jayden Danns - Liverpool - (19/76) NO CHANGE = tbc
Gabriele Biancheri - Manchester United - (18/65) +5 to 70 = tbc
Lewis Hall - Newcastle - (20/87) +2 to 89 = tbc
Matheus França - Crystal Palace - (21/80) +2 to 82 = tbc
Harvey Elliott- Liverpool - (22/88) NO CHANGE = tbc

Eredivisie
Kenneth Taylor - Ajax - (23/87) +1 to 88 = tbc
Kian Fitz-Jim - Ajax - (21/82) +3 to 85 = tbc
 
BenitoSTARR said:
Place holder 2 actual


Aston Villa (6th)
Meret 90
AWB 89 Maguire 90 Torres 91 Hernandez 91
Gavi 91 Parejo 91
Yamal 94 Foden 94 Wirtz 94
Kane 96 ⭐️
​
I called it before Aston Villa will struggle because of their defence and 59 goals conceded shows that unless it is fixed, they won’t be challenging for titles despite their impressive 91 goals scored (2nd best in the league). It’s a superb attacking line up but let down by a leaky back line (and nobody wants a leaky back).

In goal Meret is ok, but if I look at everyone’s squad through the lens of can it grow to beat United he’s a very uninspiring option. I think he’s maybe got a +1 in him if Napoli can win Serie A again but realistically I think he’s probably peaked. I know absolutely nothing about the back up.

Defensively, it’s gotten better since we last analysed it with the addition of Lucas Hernandez (you’re welcome!) but it still lacks a 90 rated RB and a top quality CB that is often needed to keep clean sheets. I do believe Villa have invested a lot in good young options that may one day take over but none stand out as potentially world class CB options in the near future (though I do like Bitshiabi and Egan-Riley as ones to watch next year as well as rating Anselmino in the longer term). The good news is Livramento has developed well, so they should hopefully have that RB issue solved for the foreseeable if he can hit 90 next review. When that happens I’d be selling Semedo for cash to free up squad space for another youth gamble and LB seems very high up the priority list for me. Perhaps they could test the resolve of Southend for one of their LB prospects?

In midfield we have a bit of an issue as Parejo isn’t really 91 quality and is ageing. Fortunately García can cover in the shorter term but long term I’m just not sure the quality is there. I’d be throwing a significant wedge out for a top CM prospect. As for AM they are absolutely spoilt for choice with Foden, Musiala and Wirtz (Mukasa is a good pick up too and there was lots of competition). It’s possible that selling someone like Foden could help them bring in a CM and that’s probably needed more as things stand.

Finally the attack, I’ve sort of had to cheat a bit and let Wirtz be a winger but, Yamal is the best player to own in the game. There I said it. I can see him being a 95 player soon if he can add more goals to his game and Villa hit the jackpot in getting Wirtz and Yamal in day one bidding wars. Kane is world class and with 48 goals in 48 appearances along with 26 assists he’s an absolute monster to deal with. This attack should be enough to tear holes in any back line and it does so regularly. In terms of youth (excluding Yamal)
Ngumoha, Heskey and Gomes all look promising but I’m not sure they are Yamal/Wirtz/Foden level (94+) I’d still back all 3 to hit 90+ in the next 3 years or so.

Predicted Finish: 6th (again)


Cardiff City (7th)
Chevalier 90
Pavard 91 Rüdiger 94 Tomori 90 Mittelstädt 90
Barella 94 ⭐️ Modric 92
Kubo 91 Milinkovic-Savic 91 Son 93
Isak 92
​
Thank you to @Dom Gill for this!

I sort of regret offering to do this writeup for Beni, not because it involves effort or that it takes time, but when I saw the volume of transfers and the churn this club has gone through this season I knew it was not going to be a simple thing unpicking the mind of someone that is currently in a transition period for their squad. On the other hand, it is also quite fun working out what the hell Beni is up to at the same time. So here goes….

Cardiff (7th)
Chevalier 90
Pavard 91 Todibo 90 Rudiger 94 Mittelstadt 90
Modric 92 Milinkovic-Savic 91
Kubo 91 Barella 94 Son 93
Isak 92​

To start with, since my last write up I highlighted that the goalkeeping department was one of the weak spots for the future which has been addressed with Neuer sold to Barnsley, (who has a great manager by the way), and Chevalier coming in. I am unsure what the full deal was with Rochdale to get Chevalier (Benito here it was Pino = £15m + Chevalier and Mittelstädt) but it looks like Chevalier and Mittelstadt came in and Yeremy Pino went in the other direction. Very shrewd in my opinion even if there was more to the deal, still a good deal.

Moving to defenders Rudiger and Pavard keep their places from last season but where Tomori has dropped to 90 Todibo is the safer 90 option in the squad. A slight reduction in rating across the back line with the sale of Hernandez included in the already mentioned drop for Tomori will see more goals conceded but this may not be a concern as we look across the attacking players. For the long term there looks to be a nice succession with Quaresma, Hinshelwood and potentially Kayode waiting their turn, the latter of which for me is looking a great prospect. For now there is no rush to do anything drastic in defence.

Next to the Midfield. Since last season the introduction of Modric is a nice short term plaster to address the positions I see as a deeper problem which will need attention in the coming season. The sale of Palinha was the safe option incase of a drop. Milinkovic-Savic was released at the beginning of the season but has just been bought back in order to cover what can only be described as a stop gap with the purchase and sale of both Veerman and Mkhitaryan in one season. The defensive midfield positions look to be the area that may expose the team in the shorter term versus the other positions. Looking ahead, Hinshelwood may be the saviour but he cannot play everywhere at once. Longer term there is an absolute treasure trove of potential in the youth team with Dyer, Banzuzi and Esse being my favourites to break through to stardom, (in that order), but this will not happen in the time it takes for both Modric and Milinkovic-Savic to sail into the sunset of Soccerwiki ratings..

The attacking midfield positions have changed quite a bit with Pellegrini and Diaby going and the latter was the right thing to do. Barella for me moves from DM(C) to AM(C) and the acquisition of Son on the left makes for a very strong goal scoring threat. Kubo remains from last season, and we all love him, if you don’t, you need your head tested. Of the current players Son worries me a lot prior to the Premier League review but I cannot see him getting a -3, so anything else will only be a hit to the wages rather than a major problem. If anything does happen it is only a matter of time for one of, (or all of), the three waiting in the wings to take over from Son. Semenyo, Guessand and the jewel in the crown of Endrick won’t take long to hit 90 and from there onwards who knows. This attacking midfield could be very scary for a long time. The youth team have a few other potential world class players, notably Bardghji and Gomis, and I do like Rego a lot so that is one to watch too.

Finally the Striker….ISAK!!! Well that position is nailed down forever, pretty sure the deal was bigger than Ben Seghir, Sudakov and £15m, if not well then it is a masterstroke (Benito again, no that was the full deal). Backups without mentioning the above are not really needed so opportunities to sniff out the youth potential is probably on the cards.

In summary, there has been some real positive steps forward in one season with the only area that needs an overhaul being defensive midfielders. One more season under the current stewardship probably will see some more interesting moves which will cement the long term path for the club. I look forward to watching it

Predicted Finish: 6th, one place up from last season (but I have not looked across the whole Gameworld)

Nottingham Forest (8th)
Sommer 92
Porro 91 Marquinhos 94 Militão 93 Estupiñán 90
Caicedo 92 Camavinga 92
Sane 93 Álvarez 93 Chiesa 91
Lewandowski 95 ⭐️
​
I am disappointed in Forest. Looking at their side and depth they have the quality for so much more than 8th and should be doing better. But I can’t see them breaking top 4 without a tactical change.

In goal Sommer is a solid choice and they’ve got 3 potential 90+ goalkeepers as back up. The issue is 4 GKs is overkill and Lunin is going to hit major concerns very soon as an 88. Personally I’d just back Sommer with Suzuki as back up and keep Urbig another season to see if in 2026/2027 season he takes over at Bayern.

Defensively they have one of the best back lines in the league all 90+ and a CB pairing to rival United’s. Ndicka, Khusanov and Mosquera are all terrific younger options that should develop further given time so central they look all set. In the full back positions they are spoilt for choice. LB in particular is just silly in how many young quality players could dethrone Estupiñán soon. Carreras, Barco, Netz, Garcia are all stunning options and at RB Porro and Jelert are two solid options for now and the future.

In midfield they have an excellent pairing of Caicedo and Camavinga with Diarra a promising understudy. Both have potential to be 94 rated players and so patience is needed here. In attacking midfield Karetsas is an outstanding young talent along with Uzun, but they do lack a natural starting AM so the recently risen Alvarez comes in here.

Finally in their attack they have the imperious Lewandowski who in the last two real life seasons has scored 46 league goals (Isak has 44) and so I can’t see any reason to trade him even if I believe this will be his last at Barcelona. When that happens Forest will need to move Alvarez to ST, which means someone needs to step up at CAM soon. Theres not an obvious alternative to this solution as Richarlison isn’t very good, will drop to 89/90 and probably just needs selling now. Out wide though I think they are in good knick. Schejelderup, Fernandes, Savinho and Adeyemi are good longer term replacements for Chiesa and Sanè so sit tight and watch them grow.

Predicted Finish: Around 8th (again) but definitely in Europa.

Barnsley (9th)
Neuer 93
Anton* 90 Guehi 90 Martinez 91 Shaw 92
Goretzka 91 Szoboszlai 91
Griezmann 94 ⭐️ Simons 91 Grealish 92
Benzema 92
​
The Barnsley and Cardiff transfer bromance continued this season with both Müller and Neuer transferring over for cash after Cardiff’s failed title gambit and reports tonight suggest there could be further deals afoot next season. A side that consistently punches above its weight and is a thorn to all who suffer a 1-0 defeat at their hands.

In goal Neuer is world class. Unfortunately injuries are affecting him now and it looks like he may only have one more world class season in him but that won’t bother Barnsley who have Atubolu waiting in the wings. I would imagine one more season and he should hit 90 but the short term gain of having a 93 keeper cannot be overstated. I do not share the popular view of others that GK doesn’t matter, it does, it’s what’s helped Cardiff in the past.

Defensively Barnsley are solid but not outstanding like some clubs above them and Shaw’s long term injury woes mean a -1/-2 is to be expected (and Barnsley have accepted an offer for him) that said Hall will hit 89 this review and has no reason not to reach 90 by winter meaning long term the position is secured. It’s a great example of using short term ratings to stay competitive while your young players develop which has been a staple of Barnsley’s squad building for as long as I can recall. Also at fullback Acheampong provides some promise if he can get a chance to show it at Chelsea. At CB they have Martinez (one of the best ball playing CBs in world football but unlucky with his injury) and Guehi another promising CB at a good age too coming off the back of a good season for Palace. Burn is a great CB/LB option who given another superb season with Newcastle and time with England should be 90+ shortly (I campaigned for this last year).

In midfield Szoboszlai, Goretzka, Taylor, Fletcher, Larsson and Casadei offer a good blend of current ability and future potential across ages. Szoboszlai should rise to 92 after his title win, Goretzka has been solid and there is 90+ potential amongst the others to eventually replace Goretzka in a few years. But for me, it’s attacking midfield wherein lies their strength. Simons, who looks destined to move this window, Carboni, Nyoni, Elliot (who had a ridiculously good Euros), Milambo (who has just moved to Brentford) are all incredibly talented young players with lots of room to grow. Combine them with Muller and Mount and you’ve got solid options that can give them time to grow. Where have we seen that said?

Finally the attack. Benzema will not drop and at 37 is still tearing up the Saudi league and Griezmann is a multitool of a forward able to add a touch of world class in any attacking position. But they are old. And we cannot get away from the fact that they need long term replacement. Woltemade is the obvious CF candidate and I’d be holding onto him with both hands given his likely move to Bayern as Kane’s successor. He was dominant in the U21 Euros and while only 87, won’t stay there for long. With Toney, Jesus (who I think will drop) and Evanilson there is probably room to let one or two go to make room for more youth investment, but I would stick with Benzema a little while longer. Jayden Danns is a very promising youth player here too but with Liverpool after a CF I’m not sure he’ll get the chances he needs to grow without a loan. In the wings Martinelli is the bright hope with Bouabré a top prospect who just needs a season to develop and get minutes but it’s Virgili who could be the next big thing at Barca. If he can break through you’re looking at a 93+ wide forward in a couple of years time. Nico Williams not moving this summer could be the best transfer never made for Barnsley.

Predicted Finish: 7th (certainly in Europe again)


Fulham (10th)
Costa 91
Dalot 90 Witsel 89 Pavlović 88 Hernández 92
Ugarte 90 Koke 91
Neto 91 Musiala 94 ⭐️ Di Maria 91
Pedro 89​
Click to expand...


Thanks for the write-up.

Keepers have ALWAYS been my thing. Over the years I got Pope before he was big, Trafford, Carneschhi, Horvath, Sommer, Simon, Gulasci, Gazzaniga, Schmiechel, Romero Gollini and a few other young kids. Love finding keepers that will make it next. You just watch out for Hornicek in the Portugal review.

I am a little concerned about my defenders, I do not have the bridging players to slot in (hence that rather large Carlos Augusto message I sent over) but the youth is there. Midfield I am comfortable with and that should all play out nicely.

Attack is going to be the interesting part. I have purposefully gambled on a lot of players here, I need to have a bridge between Benzema/Griezmann and Woltemade and currently I cannot really see who it is in a natural striker position, so Evanilson, Toney and Jesus are pawns for the review then sell. When I have a view of the team structure.

I have a few short term holds over the transfer window. I took a punt on Szymon Wlodarczyk as the previous Sturm Graz strikers have been;

Rasmus Hojlund
Mika Biereth
Emanuel Emegha
Kelvin Yeboah

Next scouting stop some defenders!!!!
 
Dom Gill said:
Thanks for the write-up.

Keepers have ALWAYS been my thing. Over the years I got Pope before he was big, Trafford, Carneschhi, Horvath, Sommer, Simon, Gulasci, Gazzaniga, Schmiechel, Romero Gollini and a few other young kids. Love finding keepers that will make it next. You just watch out for Hornicek in the Portugal review.

I am a little concerned about my defenders, I do not have the bridging players to slot in (hence that rather large Carlos Augusto message I sent over) but the youth is there. Midfield I am comfortable with and that should all play out nicely.

Attack is going to be the interesting part. I have purposefully gambled on a lot of players here, I need to have a bridge between Benzema/Griezmann and Woltemade and currently I cannot really see who it is in a natural striker position, so Evanilson, Toney and Jesus are pawns for the review then sell. When I have a view of the team structure.

I have a few short term holds over the transfer window. I took a punt on Szymon Wlodarczyk as the previous Sturm Graz strikers have been;

Rasmus Hojlund
Mika Biereth
Emanuel Emegha
Kelvin Yeboah

Next scouting stop some defenders!!!!
Click to expand...
I always find keepers really hard to scout so I fully rely on external sources for those. I had Joan Garcia and Chevalier as the two GKs I desperately wanted to replace Neuer so if the Pino deal didn’t happen it was Garcia.

Defenders I find easier to scout since PSV-99 related metrics have been released and build up passing data is more readily available I basically look firstly “Is this player an athlete?” and then “Can they do on the ball progression?” And if they pass those two they are worth exploring. It’s how I found Zabarnyi. There’s about 8 players at external that I really like as defenders but just don’t have squad space for. Plus I want to see how the real life transfer market goes.

I do think keeping Benzema till he drops is the best strategy. Sell Jesus too. Sturm Graz is increasingly being called “the striker factory” along with Bodø/Glimt (Mikkel Bro Hansen anyone?)

I’ll read the bigger message once I’ve had a cup of tea.
 
BenitoSTARR said:

Season 34 approaches and we’re smack bang in the middle of review season which means transfers, trials and tribulations as managers scramble to grind every morsel of quality from their squads.

Back by popular demand, this is once again your friendly guide to the movers and shakers in Division 1 as we delve into the potential starting XIs, ones to watch and predicted finishing positions of the top flight clubs.


Newcastle United (2nd)
Courtois 95
Carvajal 92 Konate 92 Christensen 90 Cucurella 91
Kovacic 92 Merino 92
Gnabry 91 Odegaard 94 Vini Jr 96 ⭐️
Morata 91
​
I was about to begin my analysis of Newcastle when I saw “accepted” on De Brunye. So here is version 2.0.

Newcastle performed admirably this season, 86 points 11 behind United but 12 clear of Everton, with 90 goals and only 39 conceded (2nd best in both) they really were good value for their finish (as predicted).

In goal Thibaut Courtois continues to be a world class presence and while Bazunu isn’t a world beater he is Irish, and I know that matters.

Defensively Newcastle have made efforts to add in players like Kambwala (who I also went for and is due a sizeable rise) and Diakite’s recent rise means their depth is improving here. Of course their biggest asset is Konate, who appears to be a future Real Madrid free transfer target so certainly someone to build around. My worry here would be RB. Carvajal isn’t starting over Trent next season and he will drop like a stone soon and there doesn’t appear to be a RB in the squad close to 90 ready to take over. A priority need for the squad to deal with now.

In midfield De Brunye is gone, off to Middlesbrough with De Ketelaere being the main aspect of the swap. This leaves CM light of world class ratings but there is the promising Angelo Stiller emerging (I campaigned hard for him to get 91 and was told no) he should become a capable 91/2 player if he can get a transfer this season. The issue I think Newcastle will have is the midfield is mainly players around 30. Now the plan could be to drop Odegaard deeper and then rotate the older players in the AM spot (it’s what I’d do personally) which would then bide some time to scout younger replacements, but if not then Kovacic, Zielinksi and Merino aren’t players you build a squad around and the competition (United) are much better placed in the long term here.

In attack there is world class quality in Vini Jr, a 96 rated attacker always gives you a chance in any season to do well. The supporting cast is solid but ageing and uninspiring but Newcastle have sensibly gambled on Boniface for cash (looks to be joining Turkey). It at least gives them a solid more youthful option at 90 allowing time for Barry and Wahi to develop more. Cunha’s move to United worries me though. The only player who has rose in attack at United has been Bruno. He should hit 91 this review and is capable of more, but it’s hard to feel convinced of that.

Predicted Finish: 5th due to the De Brunye sale

​
Click to expand...

I missed all this so only responding now.

Mostly agreed with a lot of the sentiment. KDB and Diakite out for CDK and Collins is a risky move, but am hoping Collins will get a +1 (wishfully thinking +2) and CDK can push on for a +2 over the next year or so.

Kambwala is certainly one i have a lot of hope for going forward, but am hoping O Brien goes up after having a good debut season in the prem.

My midfield options are light, largely due to my silly transfer policy of backing green... Shall see how we do.

Cunha is an interesting one, I like the player and am happy to see him at united. I know his stock in the GW has risen as a result cause he has often come up as a desire when discussing transfers. I am losing hope in Wahi to develop to higher than a 90 rated at this rate. Has had a huge slow down since leaving Montpellier. As for Barry the man cant go a summer and not move it seems. Doing well at Villareal but now linked to Everton to replace DCL which again I am so conflicted about...

Happy with a potential 5th.

Thanks Beni
 
CrackersJr said:
I missed all this so only responding now.

Mostly agreed with a lot of the sentiment. KDB and Diakite out for CDK and Collins is a risky move, but am hoping Collins will get a +1 (wishfully thinking +2) and CDK can push on for a +2 over the next year or so.

Kambwala is certainly one i have a lot of hope for going forward, but am hoping O Brien goes up after having a good debut season in the prem.

My midfield options are light, largely due to my silly transfer policy of backing green... Shall see how we do.

Cunha is an interesting one, I like the player and am happy to see him at united. I know his stock in the GW has risen as a result cause he has often come up as a desire when discussing transfers. I am losing hope in Wahi to develop to higher than a 90 rated at this rate. Has had a huge slow down since leaving Montpellier. As for Barry the man cant go a summer and not move it seems. Doing well at Villareal but now linked to Everton to replace DCL which again I am so conflicted about...

Happy with a potential 5th.

Thanks Beni
Click to expand...
Collins is actually the best CB in the PL for “On the Ball Value” a metric from HudlStatsbomb which basically means when he’s got the ball, he usually does something productive for the side +0.13 (for context of the rest of the XI see here). I think he deserves at least +2 he’s class.



It’s why I’ll be royally pissed off if Leao doesn’t drop but Son does because the most advanced metrics on the planet show he’s not responsible for Spurs shit season.

Barry will hit 88/9 at Everton and put himself in the shop window (again).
 
End of Season 33 stats and tables
C9Vk0Kc.png
uLXJuYc.png
QPB0QtO.png
 
Power Rankings
Curr PRPrev PRChngTeam NameWorst FinishBest FinishLast 5 Season Avg.33 Season Average
11-Everton1612.05.0
22-Manchester United1213.83.3
36▲ 3Newcastle United2325.010.0
44-Southend United8125.429.7
53▼ 2Aston Villa1715.89.0
65▼ 1Nottingham Forest2817.67.7
711▲ 4Leyton Orient9728.051.5
88-Cardiff City4328.821.9
910▲ 1Fulham2229.611.2
107▼ 3Hereford100410.644.5
118▼ 3Middlesbrough42611.020.4
1314▲ 1Sunderland31314.412.8
1413▼ 1Wolverhampton Wanderers24315.214.1
1519▲ 4Southampton45815.421.3
1619▲ 3Bournemouth69716.627.1
1716▼ 1Arsenal26117.48.2
1818-West Ham United411518.625.2
1916▼ 3Norwich City37519.221.6
2121-Milton Keynes Dons63421.021.9
2122▲ 1Manchester City32121.012.8
2326▲ 3Barnsley57522.429.2
2523▼ 2Kidderminster Harriers991225.652.1
2625▼ 1Bristol City431326.826.9
2627▲ 1Blackburn Rovers41126.822.5
2931▲ 2Tottenham Hotspur35229.415.8
3141▲ 10Rochdale892232.265.4
3233▲ 1Sheffield United562633.839.4
6875▲ 7Bury872070.245.3
7988▲ 9Torquay United1004276.891.6

There we go! Full spreadsheet here

Complete list of clubs who have been #1 in PR (last 5 season average placing):

S05: Manchester United
S06: Manchester City
S07: Manchester United
S08: Manchester United
S09: Manchester United
S10: Tottenham Hotspur
S11: Manchester United
S12: Manchester City & Manchester United (joint 1st)
S13: Manchester City
S14: Manchester City
S15: Manchester United
S16: Everton
S17: Everton
S18: Everton
S19: Darlington
S20: Darlington
S21: Darlington
S22: Everton
S23: Everton
S24: Everton & Manchester United (joint 1st)
S25: Manchester United
S26: Everton
S27: Manchester United
S28: Manchester United
S29: Nottingham Forest
S30: Everton & Manchester United (joint 1st)
S31: Everton
S32: Everton
S33: Everton

The lowest Manchester United have ever been in the Power Rankings is 3 (S14 - City was 1st and Everton was 2nd, S19 & S20 - Darlington was 1st and Everton was 2nd). Tottenham Hotspur remain the only side to be 1st in the power rankings without winning the league.
 
Division 1 top flight records tables (new entries this season/ongoing streaks in light purple)

P0SNUrY.png
xQ6ed2W.png
tPzHB9u.png

bOEZcB0.png
AAWxuv8.png

Division 2 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

MDAJVG0.png

Division 3 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

93Nx0Mt.png

Division 4 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

ivHXum6.png

Division 5 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

IKTlJ6l.png

Thank you to each and every one of you for being part of the league. Without you all, this wouldn't have lasted as long as it has done so far.
 
Visualisations (click the underlined stuff below to see visualisation in full)

Cumulative Division 1 points

IpIlPoB.png
  • Nottingham have overtaken Arsenal on Division 1 points.
  • Manchester United have been top on cumulative points since Season 6.
Cumulative Division 1 goals

6vtq36A.png
  • Sunderland and Fulham have overtaken Manchester City on Division 1 goals.
  • Manchester United have been top on cumulative goals since Season 1, though Everton aim to overtake this in the next couple of seasons.
Cumulative Division 1 Top 4 finishes

jKrzEQM.png
  • Everton (S12 to S20 inclusive) and Manchester United (S20 to S28 inclusive) had the longest streak of cumulative Top 4 finishes.
  • 22 teams have finished in the Top 4, with Leyton Orient being the latest in Season 32.
  • Manchester United have been top/joint top on Top 4 finishes since Season 1.
Cumulative major honours

sn7xKcq.png
  • 31 teams have won at least one major honour with Leyton Orient the latest side to do so in Season 33.
  • Manchester United have been top/joint top on major honours won since Season 9, earning the same number of trophies as 22 sides on the above graphic combined (55).
 
33 Seasons of the RedCafe League: All-time Division 1 standings.

tMcrSOS.png

New records below in blue

Most

Games Played: 1254 (Aston Villa, Everton and Manchester United)
Overall Wins: 728 (Manchester United)
Overall Draws: 297 (Arsenal, Fulham)
Overall Losses: 465 (Liverpool)
Overall Goals For: 2475 (Manchester United)
Overall Goals Against: 1759 (Aston Villa)
Overall Goal Difference: +1043 (Manchester United)
Overall Points: 2427 (Manchester United)
Home Wins: 372 (Manchester United)
Home Draws: 153 (Arsenal)
Home Losses: 227 (Liverpool)
Home Goals For: 1278 (Manchester United)
Home Goals Against: 865 (Aston Villa)
Home Goal Difference: +553 (Everton)
Home Points: 1234 (Manchester United)
Away Wins: 356 (Manchester United)
Away Draws: 146 (Fulham)
Away Losses: 240 (Wolverhampton Wanderers)
Away Goals For: 1197 (Manchester United)
Away Goals Against: 894 (Aston Villa)
Away Goal Difference: +498 (Manchester United)
Away Points: 1193 (Manchester United)

Top 5 Overall Win %
  1. Manchester United - 58.05% (728/1254)
  2. Everton - 54.71% (686/1254)
  3. Manchester City - 48.17% (421/874)
  4. Nottingham Forest - 47.54% (542/1140)
  5. Arsenal - 45.25% (533/1178)
 
Damien said:
33 Seasons of the RedCafe League: All-time Division 1 standings.

tMcrSOS.png

New records below in blue

Most

Games Played: 1254 (Aston Villa, Everton and Manchester United)
Overall Wins: 728 (Manchester United)
Overall Draws: 297 (Arsenal, Fulham)
Overall Losses: 465 (Liverpool)
Overall Goals For: 2475 (Manchester United)
Overall Goals Against: 1759 (Aston Villa)
Overall Goal Difference: +1043 (Manchester United)
Overall Points: 2427 (Manchester United)
Home Wins: 372 (Manchester United)
Home Draws: 153 (Arsenal)
Home Losses: 227 (Liverpool)
Home Goals For: 1278 (Manchester United)
Home Goals Against: 865 (Aston Villa)
Home Goal Difference: +553 (Everton)
Home Points: 1234 (Manchester United)
Away Wins: 356 (Manchester United)
Away Draws: 146 (Fulham)
Away Losses: 240 (Wolverhampton Wanderers)
Away Goals For: 1197 (Manchester United)
Away Goals Against: 894 (Aston Villa)
Away Goal Difference: +498 (Manchester United)
Away Points: 1193 (Manchester United)

Top 5 Overall Win %
  1. Manchester United - 58.05% (728/1254)
  2. Everton - 54.71% (686/1254)
  3. Manchester City - 48.17% (421/874)
  4. Nottingham Forest - 47.54% (542/1140)
  5. Arsenal - 45.25% (533/1178)
Click to expand...
You know I love all these.

Cardiff aren’t far off top 5:
44.74% win record

If you only consider my time in charge from full seasons (I can’t remember how far into the first season I joined Cardiff)

  1. 29/38 (1st promoted)
  2. 16/38 (10th)
  3. 20/38 (3rd)
  4. 17/38 (7th)
  5. 14/38 (10th)
  6. 18/38 (6th)
  7. 12/38 (14th bad season)
  8. 17/38 (6th)
  9. 19/38 (4th)
  10. 16/38 (7th)
  11. 22/38 (3rd)
  12. 25/38 (most wins in the league 2nd so gutted)
  13. 12/38 (17th worst finish)
  14. 12/38 (15th)
  15. 18/38 (7th)

267/570 games (full seasons) ~ 46.03% win rate which when you consider how my squad was when first taking over I think earns me my 5th place above Arsenal who have Salah!

AVG finishing position 7.47th
 
BenitoSTARR said:
Collins is actually the best CB in the PL for “On the Ball Value” a metric from HudlStatsbomb which basically means when he’s got the ball, he usually does something productive for the side +0.13 (for context of the rest of the XI see here). I think he deserves at least +2 he’s class.



It’s why I’ll be royally pissed off if Leao doesn’t drop but Son does because the most advanced metrics on the planet show he’s not responsible for Spurs shit season.

Barry will hit 88/9 at Everton and put himself in the shop window (again).
Click to expand...

Just hope a stint in liverpool doesnt hinder his chances of moving again cause suddenly everton want silly money for a striker...
 
Damien said:
Division 1 top flight records tables (new entries this season/ongoing streaks in light purple)

P0SNUrY.png
xQ6ed2W.png
tPzHB9u.png

bOEZcB0.png
AAWxuv8.png

Division 2 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

MDAJVG0.png

Division 3 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

93Nx0Mt.png

Division 4 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

ivHXum6.png

Division 5 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

IKTlJ6l.png

Thank you to each and every one of you for being part of the league. Without you all, this wouldn't have lasted as long as it has done so far.
Click to expand...
Thanks Damo! appreciate the work you do for us all!

Very dissapointing to see my best season where i finally get into some of the positive records and i still came second by a comfortable margin...
 
Damien said:
Division 1 top flight records tables (new entries this season/ongoing streaks in light purple)

P0SNUrY.png
xQ6ed2W.png
tPzHB9u.png

bOEZcB0.png
AAWxuv8.png

Division 2 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

MDAJVG0.png

Division 3 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

93Nx0Mt.png

Division 4 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

ivHXum6.png

Division 5 records table (new entries this season in light purple)

IKTlJ6l.png

Thank you to each and every one of you for being part of the league. Without you all, this wouldn't have lasted as long as it has done so far.
Click to expand...
West Ham broke 4 of the 6 division records last season? Didn’t realise!
 
infamous7 said:
Benito I don't have gold how do I sign defenders l0l
My last signing was ages ago
I've just been living off good business from the last 10 years
Click to expand...
Sorry haha imagine you did then? :lol:

I’ll get it for you if you want?
 
Blackburn Rovers draft

Next up: Norwich City @coolredwine

Rules:
  1. Only Gold managers will unfortunately be allowed to do transfers thanks to SM. We can't do the workaround anymore as they have patched it. If you're non-Gold but intend on getting Gold, let me know and I'll put you back in draft.
  2. Time between picks is now 16 hours instead of the previous 12. I would prefer if you message me picks in advance to make things go faster.
  3. Once the draft is over and the temp manager has resigned, bid face value for the player.
Draft order:
  1. Norwich City - £204.9M
  2. Sheffield United - £237.5M
  3. Torquay United - £245.8M
  4. Bury - £248.9M
  5. Bristol City - £289.5M
  6. Sunderland - £315.1M
  7. Southampton - £332.2M
  8. Cardiff City - £333M
  9. Bournemouth - £336.1M
  10. Kidderminster Harriers - £339.4M
  11. Barnsley - £350.1M
  12. Wolverhampton Wanderers - £377.2M
  13. West Ham United - £378.2M
  14. Milton Keynes Dons - £383.3M
  15. Manchester City - £386.8M
  16. Hereford - £420.1M
  17. Nottingham Forest - £437.6M
  18. Aston Villa - £437.6M
  19. Southend United - £470.9M
  20. Newcastle United - £478.3M
  21. Leyton Orient - £488.7M
  22. Rochdale - £495.6M
  23. Middlesbrough - £496.5M
  24. Everton - £508.5M
  25. Manchester United - £613.2M

(To make it easier I’m just leaving picked players up and I’ll removed teams that missed out or skipped)

Tottenham Hotspur - £192.9M
Arsenal - £287.8M
Fulham - £336.9M
 
Damien said:
Blackburn Rovers draft

Next up: Norwich City @coolredwine

Rules:
  1. Only Gold managers will unfortunately be allowed to do transfers thanks to SM. We can't do the workaround anymore as they have patched it. If you're non-Gold but intend on getting Gold, let me know and I'll put you back in draft.
  2. Time between picks is now 16 hours instead of the previous 12. I would prefer if you message me picks in advance to make things go faster.
  3. Once the draft is over and the temp manager has resigned, bid face value for the player.
Draft order:
  1. Norwich City - £204.9M
  2. Sheffield United - £237.5M
  3. Torquay United - £245.8M
  4. Bury - £248.9M
  5. Bristol City - £289.5M
  6. Sunderland - £315.1M
  7. Southampton - £332.2M
  8. Cardiff City - £333M
  9. Bournemouth - £336.1M
  10. Kidderminster Harriers - £339.4M
  11. Barnsley - £350.1M
  12. Wolverhampton Wanderers - £377.2M
  13. West Ham United - £378.2M
  14. Milton Keynes Dons - £383.3M
  15. Manchester City - £386.8M
  16. Hereford - £420.1M
  17. Nottingham Forest - £437.6M
  18. Aston Villa - £437.6M
  19. Southend United - £470.9M
  20. Newcastle United - £478.3M
  21. Leyton Orient - £488.7M
  22. Rochdale - £495.6M
  23. Middlesbrough - £496.5M
  24. Everton - £508.5M
  25. Manchester United - £613.2M

(To make it easier I’m just leaving picked players up and I’ll removed teams that missed out or skipped)

Tottenham Hotspur - £192.9M
Arsenal - £287.8M
Fulham - £336.9M
Click to expand...
Annoyed at this draft order. I should have been before Southampton.
 
Leao and Colwill gone.

Next up: Torquay United (PM'd on SM)

Rules:
  1. Only Gold managers will unfortunately be allowed to do transfers thanks to SM. We can't do the workaround anymore as they have patched it. If you're non-Gold but intend on getting Gold, let me know and I'll put you back in draft.
  2. Time between picks is now 16 hours instead of the previous 12. I would prefer if you message me picks in advance to make things go faster.
  3. Once the draft is over and the temp manager has resigned, bid face value for the player.
Draft order:
  1. Norwich City - £204.9M - Rafael Leao (£36M)
  2. Sheffield United - £237.5M - Levi Colwill (£20M)
  3. Torquay United - £245.8M
  4. Bury - £248.9M
  5. Bristol City - £289.5M
  6. Sunderland - £315.1M
  7. Southampton - £332.2M
  8. Cardiff City - £333M
  9. Bournemouth - £336.1M
  10. Fulham - £336.9M
  11. Kidderminster Harriers - £339.4M
  12. Barnsley - £350.1M
  13. Wolverhampton Wanderers - £377.2M
  14. West Ham United - £378.2M
  15. Milton Keynes Dons - £383.3M
  16. Manchester City - £386.8M
  17. Hereford - £420.1M
  18. Nottingham Forest - £437.6M
  19. Aston Villa - £437.6M
  20. Southend United - £470.9M
  21. Newcastle United - £478.3M
  22. Leyton Orient - £488.7M
  23. Rochdale - £495.6M
  24. Middlesbrough - £496.5M
  25. Everton - £508.5M
  26. Manchester United - £613.2M

(To make it easier I’m just leaving picked players up and I’ll removed teams that missed out or skipped)

Tottenham Hotspur - £192.9M
Arsenal - £287.8M
 
Last edited:
infamous7 said:
Its not the money
Its the principle of paying sm
Saying that I'm tempted to get back in
Click to expand...
@infamous7 you may aswell get back in.

You’ve got a brilliant Musiala that needs help to shine.

And it’s £17.99 which is £1.50 a month. I know you’ll get £1.50 worth of enjoyment out of it. Plus I’d love to do more coverage of your rebuilding process. Anyone who scouts Musiala and Pedro has an eye for talent we don’t want wasted.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.