Those who didn’t like the trailer should do this show a favor by not watching it.
Television The Wheel of Time | Thread for the TV show - book nerds shoo
- Thread starter SmashedHombre
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran hold a long overdue conversation about United's awful league form with 1 win in 7. They discuss a disappointing draw at Bournemouth, a not so disappointing draw against Liverpool and a crushing defeat at Chelsea - Is time nearly over for Erik Ten Hag?
Then in a special second half of the pod, Nik welcomes Natalie ( https://twitter.com/natalie_17) to discuss the fortunes of Manchester United Women as they booked a place in the FA Cup Final after a historic first ever win vs. Chelsea.
Theres one particular scene from the trailer that has hinted at something that I suspected when I read the books but I don’t want to mention it in case I’m right 
I remember a lot of people saying they weren’t going to watch it anymore as Ned was their favourite character
I don't get the GOT thing, same nonsense with the Witcher, other than sharing a genre all 3 are nothing alike in terms of feel, pacing and the world in general.
It's like watching Alien and Interstellar and expecting one to be like the other cause they are both Sci Fi space movies.
Anyone that goes into this expecting GOT will be quickly gone.
It's like watching Alien and Interstellar and expecting one to be like the other cause they are both Sci Fi space movies.
Anyone that goes into this expecting GOT will be quickly gone.
I'd say a 50 to 60 run lead for england looking likely but that could prove match winning for sure.
Can’t see that happening with Matt batting with the ruby hilted dagger and a Loial at slip.
I dunno ain't no bowler like an Aes Sedai bowler, could be close in the end
Typical English arrogance thinking they could just waltz into the Aiel Waste and run up the score.
FFS, you cheeky cnuts
Character and world building in WoT is excellent to be fair. Not sre if series will do it justice but if done correctly
I don't think it'll be possible with 2 books per season or so, to nail the world building either. My big worries about world building and characters is this is gonna move at 200mph and not have time for all the details, while occasionally it was a slog to read, Jordan was really great with the details. I do think we'll get a lot of merged cast further down the line to prevent bloat etc.. maybe a couple of wise ones getting merged into one character and the same for some mildly important Aes Sedai etc.. Still the trailer has me cautiously optimistic that its at least done by people who love the books.
I'm also curious to see how they handle certain cultures like the Atha an Miere which might be seen as offensive on screen.
Some story arcs can be completed ignored tbh.. Elayne andor accension and faile kidnapping etc
SHUT THE feck UP
I think one or two might happen, the Faile one is one I'd put money on was I having to pick something.
I think you are fighting a losing battle.
Indeed, Eye of the World was published over 30 years ago. Pointless trying to surpress all book comments.
I'm gonna be nice and spoiler:
Really? Rands character development could've been done with about a third of the books, same goes for Elayne or Egwene. Mat is the one where slow development would be great, Perrin maybe and the power dynamics at the white tower (characters like Siuan are great) also shouldn't be rushed, same for the Black Tower (Mazrim and Logain) and the Forsaken.
I wonder if they introduce most of the characters but kill them here and then to keep the audience interested and have other characters do their story relevant stuff. Because who the heck actually dies before book 12? I think TV audience would like a bit more action.
I wonder if they introduce most of the characters but kill them here and then to keep the audience interested and have other characters do their story relevant stuff. Because who the heck actually dies before book 12? I think TV audience would like a bit more action.
Why don’t you nerds stop bickering and start a book thread and a separate tv thread like you did in GOT?
Then I can steal your milk money in both of them.
Because I’m only halfway through the third book so I will end up moaning in both.
Oof. That’s a tricky one alright.
Yeah fortunately it’s only about another 9000 pages to get through and I can join the book thread.
The book comments are certainly going to be taken more seriously, if this gets big and popular.
I agree with most of that but still think 2 books per season or so will move stupidly fast, maybe not for the middle books where you could probably get 5 into 1 episode. In the book thread I've made my feelings on Rand and Mat clear before.
Might be best for those of us in the know to take our discussion to there and leave this thread completely devoid of book discussion before I feck up and predict a timeline.
https://www.redcafe.net/threads/wheel-of-time.311227/
Thought we were friends man
Friends don’t post book spoilers in a TV Series thread.
can we all just hug it out and admit that the part where Rand turned into a dragon in book 10 was awesome?
About as seriously as Rand took the betrayal of the All-Badgers?
He came like the wind, like the wind touched everything, and like the wind was gone.
From the Dragon Reborn
By Loial, son of Arent son of Halan , the Fourth Age.
From the Dragon Reborn
By Loial, son of Arent son of Halan , the Fourth Age.
What I've said is not spoilers. If you don't want peole to talk about the books or series, then don't open the thread about it ffs
This is a TV series thread as denoted by the category it’s been set to. If you want to discuss the book there is already a book thread for that.
I'm not too fussed (yet) but tbf it is the tv thread and normally goes without saying not to talk about other sources
That's really not how it works as you well know you naughty wee scamp. Although I do blame the OP for not making it clear that this is the TV thread. @Damien - could you change the thread title to stop book nerds spoiling.
Not really all that interested in this show, the trailer didn't really inspire me to watch it. They could and should have done a better job with the opening trailer if their objective is to try and bring new people into watching it.
Done, but yeah I can imagine this thread being as big a pain as the GOT thread to moderate.
I genuinely don't know the original source — going by the reaction I assume that it's a classic? I share the same worries as the few posters above me — visually it looks just as clean as CW or Netflix shows (and CGI looks cheap which is not a good look for a show that, going by the trailer, is going to use a lot of it).
I think conclusions about how "clean" it looks are pointless based on a short trailer.
I'd say it's a classic, yes. One of the best-selling fantasy series ever.
Nah, it's how literally every character looks — a girl in the middle of a forest with full make up & one little perfectly placed line of dirt to show that she's just been through some stuff. Flawlessly shaved guys with barbershop hairstyles and pristine clothing in what looks like a village tavern. Etc.
I'm not even talking about Rosamund Pike who looks like a powerful magical being so that ideal ageless look makes sense. Just about the regular non-magic folk.
I mean, maybe, but here's Jon Snow:
Robb Stark:
Sansa:
Ygritte the wildling:
The Wheel of Time isn't set in the middle ages either, and in any case it's a myth that everyone living in a village was always dirty and dressed in drab clothes. Now I'm definitely not saying it's going to be good, look good or really do anything well. I just think it's silly to base opinions on two-second shots of characters in a teaser trailer. The options aren't just grimdark or CW.
There's a world of difference between pristine and not dirty — but for me it's clear that the stuff in the trailer is not somewhere in the middle. Anyway, we clearly won't agree on that, so I'm going to let it go (although not before noticing that Sansa and Rob are at full parade and Jon Snow is straight from a promo shot). GoT, like literally any (well, unless it's something intentionally gore like German's Hard to be a God) fantasy adaptation will be shinier and cleaner than it would be in "reality". But, at least for me, there's still a line when the fantasy world starts to look fake.
We'll see. I'm still going to watch that anyway, at least at the beginning, hopefully I'm wrong.
Those people are all royalty bar Ygritte, who might have just got out of a very pleasurable bath, and two of them are in formal attire. Not really the best example to use.I mean, maybe, but here's Jon Snow:
Robb Stark:
Sansa:
Ygritte the wildling:
The Wheel of Time isn't set in the middle ages either, and in any case it's a myth that everyone living in a village was always dirty and dressed in drab clothes. Now I'm definitely not saying it's going to be good, look good or really do anything well. I just think it's silly to base opinions on two-second shots of characters in a teaser trailer. The options aren't just grimdark or CW.
So Ygritte doesn't count because she might have had a bath recently?